Are We Fated to Live with a Polarized Mindset?
Image credit: Depositphotos

Are We Fated to Live with a Polarized Mindset?

Read on my website / Reading time: 6 min.

A few days ago, Monika Bielskyte (PROTOPIA FUTURES) published an excellent idea that

For the longest time, the fact that SciFi opens our imagination for future possibilities was considered as a given. Increasingly though, we realize that SciFi, especially in the form of most popular audio-visual future fictions brought to our screens, has profoundly misguided us in what/who we consider futuristic & what/who we utterly forget to consider in our very real future propositions (& hence our actions/inaction that end up shaping the future we end up inhabiting).

This made me think of a survival game we are endlessly playing against external and internal forces that shape the mindset of our world and the urgent need for new narratives and stories that reflect who we truly are. Are we destined to defeat others and always polarize into black and white, right and wrong, "us" versus "them"? Is this where we end up in this storyline, and where did this idea come from?

Roots of hero's journey

Everybody is familiar with the idea of a hero’s journey, which states that we are here to become heroes in our lives and overcome all difficulties and obstacles.

Reflecting on the hero’s journey and its life relationship, Joseph Campbell beautifully wrote:

What I think is that a good life is one hero journey after another. Over and over again, you are called to the realm of adventure, you are called to new horizons. Each time, there is the same problem: do I dare? And then if you do dare, the dangers are there, and the help also, and the fulfillment or the fiasco. There’s always the possibility of a fiasco.
But there’s also the possibility of bliss.

Hidden consequences of hero's games

However, a hero is a solitary figure amidst a sea of adversaries, either conquered or yet to be.

They are all cast as villains; otherwise, heroes would appear peculiar, and thus, we have a starkly polarized mindset.

Even when a hero engages in an internal struggle, their ego or shadows are portrayed as foes to be vanquished.

They also have a fan base to whom they demonstrate their brilliance, reaping adoration for their qualities.

A hero is the one who gains the most, extracting the best from the best.

Being a hero, therefore, is the most coveted path, a path everyone aspires to tread.

When we make the conscious decision to turn our attention inward, to our state and emotions, we liberate ourselves from the shackles of external results.

This notion of focusing on our inner world, of letting go of external results challenges the very fabric of our current concept of life achievements.

A hero cannot let go of achievements and desires, which is never possible because this is the final result and the only meaning of a journey itself. A hero needs challenges, and he reveals himself by overcoming them.

The hero model is a result of successful survival, our legacy from past generations. The hero moment is an essential episode in every individual's life and an aspect of masculinity revelation, which we all need for a period of time.

However, when everyone is a hero, nobody is.

Should we agree on less than a hero and take what is available instead of the most desirable?

An alternative view from Nash Equilibrium and the Game Theory

Quoting The Gift of Sensitivity: “You need to see the film “Beautiful Mind” for an artistic representation of a decision strategy that could be used within game theory when all players can achieve the desired outcome by not deviating from the initial plan. The film's main character explains to his peers what would happen if they all ignored a blonde girl in the bar as the most desirable one when everyone gets his girl. The case represents the win without competition for the hero position where everyone harvested for themselves yet without suppression of others. Most desired is the perception, not the reality.”

Similarly, a hero is just a method, not an end goal.

This understanding came with psychological practice when I met the downturn of heroic achievements and understood the inner state of people from desired life by many.

It happened when I achieved my childhood dreams, celebrated them for a few minutes, and got the empty sense back.

Why should I dream of a hero state if the aftertaste is so painful?

Emptiness is hurtful, would you agree?

It took time, however, until I fully got an answer to why people would desire something else if, traditionally, everyone wants to have the best, be the best, achieve the best, and live the best life of the best.

Nobody dreams of being ordinary

Therefore, I was confused about the hero's journey and mundane path.

My inner hero felt nothing but tiredness from victories.

Asked during a workshop about how the hero’s journey can be adapted as a model for women today, Campbell acknowledges that it’s not up to him to say:

I don’t know what the counterpart would be in the woman’s case . . .? There is a feminine counterpart to the trials and the difficulties, but it certainly is in a different mode. I don’t know the counterpart––the real counterpart, not the woman pretending to be male, but the normal feminine archetypology of this experience. I wouldn’t know what that would be.
Women will have to tell us the way a woman experiences the journey, if it is the same journey.

This quote made me think: What story can I tell the world as a woman, mother, and advocate for human empowerment?

I found an alternative path and will share it with you right now.

My inner hero was reborn to become a magician with a lamp of inner truth: being at the best place is a never-ending journey, and another best place always arises as a new goal.

Our plan doesn’t mean to be/have the best, yet it must be yours.

It is so for the most straightforward reason: not followed by the pain of emptiness pushing for a new search to fill the inner void.

External needs and desires are insatiable, not fulfilling, and don’t give inner peace or long-term joy.

We must find our place, step into our power, and reflect on what belongs to our inner world.

External achievements provide a sense of great energy, which, unfortunately, is finite and require subsequent fulfillment.

A hero’s path is so fascinating. However, many dived deep into it and didn’t come back absorbed by that game.

Our emotional state is more important than outside achievements; instead

This understanding reveals the magical truth that sages believed.

This truth says the whole world will support you if you are on your path.

In this case, nothing could stop you, as you are ignited by inner light, not because you can overcome whatever; you don’t need any wins.

It is so because you are in a magic flow

All doors are open, all moments are synchronized, all needs arrive by time, there is nobody to defeat, and life amazingly happens for us.

A few additional notes:

The support flow started to show up in my life, confirming that the quality of my life journey had changed.

However, this only happened when I opened up to my emotions and put them above any consequences of the experience, such as victories or failures.

This method allows us to feel first to understand and only then proceed.

We can feel what is ours and what is not.

This is crucial for people who don’t distinguish themselves from other’s goals embedded in their minds during childhood or by false ideas of competition where we need to become the best.

Remember, when everyone is a hero, nobody does

What if the world were full of magicians and not just a few unsatiable heroes?

This is how women wish to experience the journey and the world: we are weary of wars, both external and internal, and we seek peace. We need a new, inspiring story where everyone thrives in a community empowered and ready to share with individuals who can understand, accept, and lend a hand. We need to level up the game.

That’s all for today.

We'll talk again in two weeks.

If these words were helpful to you, please share your thoughts with Your Emotional Capital Newsletter readers: we are happy to hear from you!


Find me on LinkedIn, Medium, Substack or a website. Send me professional inquiries at Kirkus ProConnect.

Whenever you’re ready, there are three ways I can help you:

  1. Your Emotional Capital Newsletter informs you with a mosaic of perspectives and insights on how emotional depth can fuel transformation, expedite learning, and activate greater cognitive capacities. Here, vulnerability meets strength, and sensitivity is recast not as a liability but as a potent asset.
  2. Emotional Capital for the Triple Win: 50 Innovative Ways to Lead the Consumption Revolution reveals 50 innovative strategies to transform consumer behavior for a triple win: benefitting people, the planet, and universal prosperity. It is a groundbreaking guide for the next generation of business leaders, founders, and innovators. Available 24th June 2025.
  3. The Gift of Sensitivity Book saves your precious time summarising 8 years of research & personal journey. Take a copy to discover your own sensitivity, transforming it into a superpower for a future with extraordinary faculties such as creativity, originality, innovation, intuition, flexibility, and inclusiveness in times of technological acceleration.

?

?

Jesús Martín González

Anthropologist of an Ecosocial Transition (Sustainability & Wellbeing) | Transdisciplinary Researcher | Creating Meaningful Synergies | Paradoxical Thinker | Essayist |

3 周

Great post, Elena V. Amber. My 2 p. Never follow just one metaphor but a triangulation (3 is a good minimum) as a rule of thumb because, like in the metaphor of the hero, you will find some ambiguities and inconsistencies and from a triangulation, there is more openness and fill the weakness of some of them with the strengths of the other (depending on the context). Head/Heart/Hands Just thinking out of the box, the three three-part structure of the stories (it usually happens in the Journey of the Hero) could be triangulated with other structures, for example, Kishōtenketsu: Exploring The Four Act Story Structure. When West meats East. ;-) https://artofnarrative.com/2020/07/08/kishotenketsu-exploring-the-four-act-story-structure/

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Elena V. Amber的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了