A Wake-Up Call from Canora: Championing Stricter Safety Standards for Young Workers

In the quiet town of Canora, Saskatchewan, a disheartening incident unfolded that not only endangered a young life but also exposed glaring deficiencies in workplace safety and employer accountability. On an ordinary day, Wil Krotenko, a 14-year-old with hopes tied to his first job at a local grocery store, was exposed to lethal levels of carbon monoxide while operating a gas-powered pressure washer in a confined space—an activity far beyond what one would deem safe or appropriate for a teenager. This harrowing experience, which led to severe carbon monoxide poisoning requiring hospitalization and a fight for survival in a hyperbaric chamber, serves as a stark reminder of the critical gaps in our enforcement of safety regulations.

As an experienced Environment, Health, and Safety Professional, my journey across various sectors, from rail construction to emergency management, has ingrained a deep understanding of the importance of comprehensive safety protocols and the profound impacts of regulatory oversight or its absence. The incident at Canora, which tragically mirrored systemic issues prevalent across many Canadian provinces, compels a discussion on the necessity of stringent enforcement measures and the role of employers in safeguarding their workers.

In this article, I aim to delve into the persistent issues highlighted by Wil’s story—underscoring the dire need for significant reforms in occupational health and safety standards and the enforcement mechanisms that should support them. Drawing from my background in regulatory compliance and risk management, I will explore how preventive strategies, rather than reactive measures, could serve as bulwarks against such preventable tragedies. Moreover, through this discourse, I aspire to ignite a call to action among policymakers, industry leaders, and the public to reevaluate and reinforce the safety nets that are meant to protect our most vulnerable workers—our youth.

Understanding "Reasonable Precaution" in Workplace Safety

In light of the recent incident in Canora, it becomes imperative to dissect what "reasonable precaution" entails under the law. The general duties clause, common across North America, mandates employers to take "every reasonable precaution" to ensure workplace safety. However, the ambiguity in this mandate often leads to its interpretation only being tested in courts—typically after an incident has occurred. This reactive approach is detrimental and often too late for those involved.

Case in Point: In Ontario, the Occupational Health and Safety Act specifies under section 25 (2) (a) that an employer shall provide "information, instruction, and supervision" to protect the worker's health and safety. This is a clear directive that goes beyond the often cited "common sense" approach, which is subjective and unreliable.

The Role of Comprehensive Information and Instruction

The necessity for employers to provide clear and comprehensive safety information is paramount. This includes legislation, codes, standards, Safety Data Sheets (SDS), manufacturer manuals, and more. Unfortunately, while the information is available, it's often scattered across different bodies of legislation, making it challenging to get a holistic view of all compliance requirements. This fragmentation can lead to gaps in knowledge and, subsequently, in safety practices.

Example: An in-depth analysis conducted by the Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety (CCOHS) emphasizes that effective safety training and clear communication are fundamental to preventing workplace injuries and fatalities. Yet, the diversity and complexity of laws mean that understanding and applying this information correctly is often left to professionals who might not always have the requisite skills or accountability, as there's no stringent barrier to entry in the field of health and safety.

The Competence Question

The reliance on health and safety professionals, who vary significantly in expertise, underscores a critical flaw in the system. Unlike professions such as law or engineering, there are minimal barriers to entry for safety professionals, which can result in a lack of necessary competence.

Statistical Insight: According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, industries with stringent and clear safety standards, like aviation and nuclear, have significantly lower rates of incidents compared to sectors where such standards are less defined or enforced. This disparity highlights the critical need for competent safety professionals who can effectively implement and manage safety systems.

Conclusion: A Call for Proactive Safety Measures

The incident in Canora is a grim reminder of what can happen when "reasonable precautions" are not clearly defined or adequately enforced. It also highlights the urgent need for legislative bodies to provide more comprehensive, accessible, and integrated safety information, and for the criteria for professional competence in the safety field to be stringent.

Advocacy for Change: To truly protect workers, especially young or inexperienced ones like Wil Krotenko, it is crucial for all workplace parties to not only comply with the letter of the law but embrace its spirit. By advocating for clearer standards, better training, and stricter professional requirements, we can improve safety outcomes and prevent incidents before they occur, ensuring that no job becomes a life-or-death gamble.

What can we as leaders do to transcend the minimum compliance standards and foster a culture where safety is inherently valued and proactively managed?

Leadership Engagement: Leaders must be actively involved in safety, not just delegating it to safety officers. For example, senior executives at XYZ Company conduct monthly safety walk-throughs and discussions with floor workers to understand firsthand the safety challenges and improvements needed.

Comprehensive Training: Go beyond basic compliance training. For instance, ABC Manufacturing has implemented a training simulator that allows employees to experience potential safety hazards in a controlled virtual environment, enhancing their ability to react appropriately in real situations.

Encouraging Reporting: Create an environment where employees feel safe to report near-misses or safety concerns without fear of reprisal. A case in point is DEF Logistics, where an anonymous reporting app led to a 70% increase in hazard reporting, significantly reducing accident rates.

Regular Audits and Continuous Improvement: Instead of waiting for annual audits, companies like GHI Electronics perform quarterly safety audits and use the findings to continuously refine their safety protocols and emergency response strategies.

Innovative Technology: Utilize technology to enhance safety measures. JKL Construction uses wearable technology to monitor the health signs of workers in real-time, allowing for immediate medical response in emergencies.

Community and Family Engagement: Engage families in safety programs to reinforce its importance and create an extended community of safety advocates. MNO Petroleum holds family safety fairs annually, educating families about the safety standards and practices their loved ones follow at work.

Leaders and Business Owners should ask yourself:

?1.????? Vision and Commitment:

"What does an ideal safety culture look like in our organization, and how does it align with our overall vision and values?"

"How can you, as a leader, demonstrate a more visible commitment to safety every day?"

2.????? Employee Engagement:

"How can we better engage our employees in safety initiatives to ensure they feel a part of the safety solutions rather than just followers of rules?"

"What steps can we take to make safety discussions a regular part of our team meetings across all levels of the organization?"

3.????? Communication:

"In what ways can we improve our communication about safety, ensuring it is clear, consistent, and impactful?"

"How can we create more open channels for employees to communicate their safety concerns without fear of repercussion?"

4.????? Learning and Development:

"What learning opportunities can we provide to our managers and employees to enhance their understanding and skills related to safety?"

"How can we ensure that our safety training is practical and directly applicable to the daily tasks of our employees?"

5.????? Accountability:

"What accountability measures are in place for safety, and are they known and understood by all team members?"

"How can we develop a system that rewards positive safety behaviors and effectively addresses non-compliance?"

6.????? Innovation and Improvement:

"What innovative safety practices or technologies have we not yet explored that could be beneficial for our organization?"

"How often do we review and update our safety procedures, and is there a process in place to incorporate feedback from these reviews effectively?"

7.????? Risk Management:

"What are the most significant safety risks in our operations, and how are we managing them currently?"

"How can we better utilize data and incident reports to predict and prevent future safety incidents?"

8.????? Cultural Integration:

"How can we integrate safety more deeply into our everyday operations and corporate culture?"

"What role do middle managers play in our safety culture, and how can we support them in this role more effectively?"

9.????? Feedback and Follow-Up:

"How effective is our current method of soliciting feedback on safety issues from our staff, and how can we improve?"

"What follow-up actions have been most effective in addressing safety concerns raised in the past, and how can we ensure such effectiveness consistently?"

James MacLeod is an experienced Environment, Health, and Safety Professional whose extensive background spans various sectors, including rail construction, emergency management, and more. With a deep understanding of the importance of comprehensive safety protocols and the profound impacts of regulatory oversight, James brings a wealth of knowledge and a keen insight into workplace safety issues. His expertise exhibits his commitment to advocating for significant reforms in occupational health and safety standards, aiming to protect the most vulnerable workers and promote a culture of safety across all industries.

?

#WorkplaceSafety #HealthAndSafety #EmployeeProtection #SafetyFirst #OccupationalHealth #SafetyStandards #CanadianSafety #YouthAtWork #SafetyTraining #RegulatoryCompliance #RiskManagement #CanoraSafetyIncident #PreventativeMeasures #SafetyAdvocacy #LeadershipInSafety #EHSProfessionals #SafetyCulture #PublicPolicy #SafetyReforms #CommunityAwareness

?

@SafetyAndHealthMagazine

Article