The vicious Circle of Workplace Toxicity
Nicolas BEHBAHANI
Global People Analytics & HR Data Leader - People & Culture | Strategical People Analytics Design
?? Employees ranked #recognition and #rewards programs at the top of their list of what makes a balanced work culture, showing how much they long to be heard and recognized for their #work but believed that their leadership and senior management are mostly responsible for the #toxic work environment in tech companies and most alarming they think that #leadership is unaware of the toxicity and lives in a bubble, thinking the company #culture is healthy but almost half of the employees don’t do or say anything in face of toxicity, according to a new interesting research published by TalentLMS and Culture Amp - using data from 1,000 employees who work in US #tech companies?conducted online on February 23, 2023.
? Leadership and management mostly responsible for Toxic Culture
This #research found that as employees are holding their #leaders liable for the toxic work culture in their companies. The disconnect is wide and concerning:?43% say that the leadership is turning a blind eye to toxic behaviors, and 45% say that senior #executives promote unhealthy competition among managers and employees.
Close to half of employees (47%) agree there’s a lack of leadership and accountability within their company. Regardless of if the leadership actively contributes to a climate of #toxicity or is simply out of touch and interacts only with a few select people, the consequences are deeply damaging. They open a way for toxicity to spread throughout the organization.
?Silence of employees in a Toxic Work Environment
When faced with toxic behaviors or situations, almost half (49%) of surveyed employees said they don’t do or say anything.
?The vicious circle of Workplace Toxicity
Leaders have a vast and disproportional influence over employees according to researchers. Employees look up to their leaders, who are setting an example and modeling social norms and everyone’s behavior. Leadership that’s accountable, considerate, and open to #feedback will inspire and foster these same traits throughout the workforce. And vice versa: a?leadership’s lack of accountability and consideration will be reproduced and magnified across teams.?
Employees often mirror executives’ behavior and attitudes. So, if leaders are turning a blind eye to misconduct, employees will too. And that's what we saw above, almost half of the employees don’t do or say anything in face of toxicity.
And this chain reaction feeds what researchers called the vicious circle of toxicity.
?The top 5 Toxic Culture attributes
Another interesting research published last year by MIT Sloan Management Review found that the "Toxic Five attributes" poison corporate culture in the eyes of employees. Donald Sull ? Charlie Sull Caio Brighenti ?
Researchers observed that this Five attributes have by far the largest negative impact on how employees rate their company’s culture in Glassdoor reviews.
These attributes are:
1?? Disrespectful,
2?? Noninclusive,
领英推荐
3?? Unethical,
4?? Cutthroat,
5?? Abusive
?Soft Skills training for Leadership
Researchers observed that workplace #training can help in fostering a more positive and healthy work environment.
Employees ranked?#softskills training?for leadership as the second most important ingredient of healthy workplaces, right after recognition and reward programs. Furthermore, soft #skills training for all employees ranks in fourth place. The data showed that soft, or #people skills are credited with fostering a positive and collaborative atmosphere at work.?
?Eliminate Toxic work culture
Researchers investigate how to eliminate toxic work culture and found that 43% of employees think managerial and leadership training for leaders and managers would be helpful.
46% of the employees found applying a #360feedback policy helpful in eliminating toxic #workculture . This is the tool that gives employees an opportunity to express their opinion, as opposed to just being evaluated. With 360 feedback, they can evaluate the #performance and behavior of their managers, and highlight any problematic areas.
? Repairing company culture: Healthy Workplace Culture
Researchers noticed that employees ranked recognition and rewards programs at the top of their list of what makes a balanced work culture, showing how much they long to be heard and recognized for their work. Specifically, employees ranked?soft skills training?for leadership as the second most important ingredient of healthy workplaces.
?Another powerhouse training type that helps build a healthy work environment is?bystander intervention training. It's specifically designed to prevent harassment and discrimination, by educating people on how to react proactively when witnessing others facing discrimination or harassment.
?? Finally researchers conclude that the next step for leadership is to actually listen to what the employees have said, and utilize this valuable data in the day-to-day workings of their organization.
Thank you ??? TalentLMS and Culture Amp ?researchers team for these insightful findings:? Ana Casic Christina Pavlou Giota Gavala Dr Joel Davies
Lead consultant in HR Strategy & Value Management. Enhancing Value through Human Performance. Delivery of Equality, Diversity & Inclusion Training. Lecturer and International Speaker on HRM and Value Management.
1 年Another great post Nicolas - thank you for posting. The decline of cultural & social cohesion, mentioned in the article by Dave Ulrich (see link in his comment), goes to show how poor leadership & management of the Organisational Structure (in this case Remote) can have a detrimental effect on the culture within an organisation. As highlighted in his article, there are many more reasons why organisational culture can turn toxic. One such reason is the way in which leaders tend to compare one employee against another - even though they might be at different stages in their professional development. Instead, I would suggest that treating people as individuals, whereby they are given work that will help them to develop and then assessing their performance against the tasks provided for them, would help to create a culture that is inclusive for all. Furthermore, it would help them to understand the importance of the task being undertaken - as well as provide them with a feeling that they matter.
Founder | Business Entrepreneur | Virtual Chief of Staff | Strategic Business Partner Executive/Personal Assistant | Mindful & Conscious Leadership | Mentor | Online Business Manager | LinkedIn Open Networker | LION
1 年Thank you Nicolas BEHBAHANI
CXO & Head of People & Culture | HR | Talent Acquisition | Talent Branding & Attraction | Digital Transformation | Talent Strategy | Talent Management | Speaker | Author | Guest Faculty | Diversity, Equity & Inclusion.
1 年Nic, at times I wonder how you are able to hit the nail right on the head! It's proven; if there is no reward for good work ethics and reprimand for poor work ethics, then the culture is bound to become toxic and most of it is controlled by the leadership and management! This pie chart clearly shows the responsible parties! And, as I've seen the world so far, most if it is a result of people at work putting their personal individualistic goals above the organizational goals! And, we need to be mindful of that fact that it can be at any level in the org hierarchy! If the leadership is able to recognize and fix then I'm sure the life at work would be better for all! More power to you Nicolas BEHBAHANI, keep sharing these insights! #culture #leadership #management #humanresoruces
Neuroscience, Drug Use Evaluation, Medicines Information, and Pharmacovigilance Clinical Pharmacist
1 年I find dialogue, accountability, and transparency to turn a toxic culture to a productive one.
Speaker, Author, Professor, Thought Partner on Human Capability (talent, leadership, organization, HR)
1 年Nicolas BEHBAHANI Thanks again for posting interesting research. Given that the sample are employees from US technology companies, the results make sense because so many US technology companies are downsizing. The data you reported yesterday showed a 10 to 20% decline in morale with decline, which is to be expected, confirmed by this research on toxic culture. For me, the broader implication is that leaders (55% in the chart) are the primary influencers of "any" culture. The (HR) policies only explain 14% and peers the rest. Culture (toxic or abundant) gets shaped and reinforced by leaders at all levels, and by peers who influence how culture (and leader behaviors) are interpreted. More to explore in the cultural playbook, but this research helps with some of the messages: https://www.dhirubhai.net/pulse/playbook-culture-agenda-why-what-how-dave-ulrich/h