Useful Skepticism

It’s fairly easy to be skeptical of something - in fact, like entropy, it’s kind of the default state. Entropy happens because there are more disordered states than ordered ones (Update: ok, maybe it has to do with quantum entanglement but I'm not reworking the analogy!) Skepticism happens because there are more ways something could fail than ways it could succeed (usually). So it’s easy to find a story to be skeptical, if you want to.

But it’s not enough to just be skeptical and contrarian. If you’re an investor, you have to be contrarian and right. If you’re an entrepreneur or engineer, you don’t get a lot of credit for just saying “no” - you also have to find a solution you’re not skeptical of, and then build something useful eventually. Big companies are filled with "that won't work" engineers. (another variation is the "we are already doing it" engineers - but both of these are fundamentally stories about why they can be skeptical and not get something done).

So it’s good to challenge our own skepticism. Instead of "how can this fail?" we should aask questions like “how could this work?”, and if it does, is it worth the effort to build it. Once we have a strong idea, we can examine the problems we see and ask about potential solutions to them. But only once we have that idea - if we look at the problems first, we'll never do anything.

And it’s good to examine your own biases. I’ve been doing this a lot personally with crypto. I’m pretty inherently skeptical about a lot of that field (update: I initially wrote this before the "current" crash, so...yeah), but I also recognize that my younger self would happily be playing with all the tools and looking for interesting things, so I’ve been trying to keep myself in that mindset. When I look at solutions in this space that have problems (most of them do), I try to ask “can that problem be solved? If it is solved, does this do something useful for a user that hasn’t been done before?” Mostly of the time I’m still skeptical, but some of that exploration has led me to find things that are at least more interesting to ponder further, and more than a few related ideas that are probably worth doing.

Skepticism is a very useful tool, both in life and in engineering. But it also has the potential to get in our way and to create bias in our thinking if we aren’t careful about using it. It should be one tool of many, not the only way we approach challenging ideas.

Soham Mehta

Founder & CPTO at Interview Kickstart & AI Training

2 å¹´

Aren't all forms of challenge to ideas, rooted in skepticism? What other ways can an idea be challenged to better understand its viability?

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Sam Schillace的更多文章

  • AI analogies and historical lessons

    AI analogies and historical lessons

    How to make sense of it all. I've decided to keep the primary posts over on Substack.

    1 条评论
  • Motion, Thought, Systems and AI

    Motion, Thought, Systems and AI

    In which I ponder how motion is like thought, why LLMs are like early steam engines (hitting things and pumping water),…

    4 条评论
  • Looking back at the Schillace "laws"

    Looking back at the Schillace "laws"

    Way back in, I think, March or so of 2023, after I’d spent a little while trying to build things with GPT-4, I wrote…

    5 条评论
  • A strange tech parable

    A strange tech parable

    In my role at Microsoft, part of what I do is spend time with the leadership team that runs M365, Office, and Windows…

    12 条评论
  • Simplicity, Clarity, Humility

    Simplicity, Clarity, Humility

    There is an old joke: “sorry this letter is so long, I didn’t have time to write a shorter one”. It’s funny, but it’s…

    4 条评论
  • A matter of context

    A matter of context

    It’s interesting that, as we talk about using AI more and more, the phrase we use is “human in the loop” instead of “AI…

    3 条评论
  • The tension between Chaos and Order

    The tension between Chaos and Order

    I’ve been spending the last week in Japan, meeting with makers and crafts people. as always, it’s a humbling…

    4 条评论
  • No Prize for Pessimism

    No Prize for Pessimism

    A book! I’ve been writing these letters for about 12 years now. I started writing them when I was at Box, as a way to…

    10 条评论
  • Adding Value in the Age of AI

    Adding Value in the Age of AI

    If you wrote out all possible combinations of, say, 1000 letters, the vast number of them would be nonsense. And the…

    3 条评论
  • Don't use AI to make work for humans

    Don't use AI to make work for humans

    I’ve started to notice an interesting pattern. More enlightened teams and people are using AI to get lots of work done…

    5 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了