The use, and abuse, of power in organizations
Photo by Lauren Allen

The use, and abuse, of power in organizations

I have been thinking about the use and abuse of power in organizations and would appreciate the input of others regarding my thinking that I mention below.

I would appreciate your critique of my thoughts below.

When someone becomes an employee of your organization, do remember that they are voluntarily, and temporarily, ceding some of their personal autonomy to your organization in exchange for certain benefits such as financial compensation, health benefits, the opportunity to have a platform to practice their craft, and etc. This is a voluntary and temporary exchange.

Secondly, you as a leader / manager, are only exercising the authority over the organization's employees that has been granted (delegated) to you by the organization. You, as an individual apart from the organization, do not actually have any authority over the employees. It becomes dangerous when a leader / manager forgets that they are simply stewards of that authority that should be used to accomplish the ends of the organization and for the good of the employees.

The misunderstanding, and abuse, of the limits of your power as a leader / manager will result in damage to those under your authority and to the ends of the organization. Those employees will become disgruntled, and eventually they will reassert their personal autonomy and leave your organization to become part of another organization that respects them as individuals and understands the limits of, and proper use of, organizational authority.   

So, any thoughts on this? I would appreciate any feedback.

This reminds me of what John Maxwell calls the "Levels of Leadership". Positional Leadership is the lowest level, and is basically, "you do what I tell you to do because you work for me, or I outrank you". I'd hardly call that leadership! However, due to many managers not embracing a continuous learning mind-set or a lens of abundance, they cease to evolve their leadership skills. This means they become stagnant in their understanding how to lead people and things like emotional intelligence, influence, collaboration, and SITLE are totally foreign concepts. Leadership is about influence, not authority. If you have to play the "because I said so" card, I'd argue you've already lost. I think the first step in facilitating meaningful change is fostering a culture of self-awareness. If a leader isn't teachable, then your chances of getting them to see there is a better way are probably close to zero. However, if you can get them to realize that reaching a management role is the start of the leadership journey, not the destination, then there's hope. In Tim Grover's book Relentless, he talks about the mindset of Michael Jordan. Here's a guy that the term GOAT was designed for. Nobody was better, nobody had more raw talent, and nobody could match him mentally. If anyone was in a position to coast, it was him. However, Grover states that he was the hardest working professional athlete he'd ever seen. First in the gym, last one gone, always mentally and emotionally dialed in. Nobody prepared, studied film, worked out harder. The result was that a gifted athlete became a legend. Having raw talent and capability is great. Getting the job is awesome. Stopping there is shameful. We need less managers and more GOATS.

Stephanie Colcord MBA, SHRM-SCP, PHR

Strategic HR Business Partner | HR Consulting | Passionate about the Experience | Innovator | Dedicated HR Business Leader

4 年

BG, I wish I could say that every organization understood the transition between the agreement between an employee and an organization. The employee agrees to do a job well in exchange for being treated as an individual and compensated as such. Sometimes I see leaders treating employees who challenge the status quo as the problem instead of the solution finder. Leaders become so busy fighting fires or dabbling in their day to day that they sometimes forget to be a servant to the people they lead. Listening and asking questions for understanding becomes too much, a hassle. Leading is really in the simplest form, serving others. People are people, we are people. What do we as people appreciate and value in our leaders and organization? Most people want the same thing. To be treated with respect, transparency, grace given when needed, someone to walk beside them to challenge them and guide them outside their boundaries, and lastly compensated fairly. I find when you have a servant leader at the top, it trickles down to the rest of the organization. The wolves don’t last.

Rusty Buys

Retired from AT&T/BellSouth after 36 years in multiple roles including Sales Management, Sales, and Technical Support of various types.

4 年

BG, everything you wrote is true. How far you want to take it will determine how you continue to develop it. For instance my experience 0ver a 36 year time frame in an evolving industry saw many leadership changes and styles. The evolving industry called for evolving skill sets. How leadership “led” through the changes varied by leader. Some were approachable, others were not. Some had an open door policy but a closed ear. Clearly the goal of any company is to hire and maintain high quality personnel, however, the truth is corporate America seems to have forgotten that the key component to creating a sustainable competitive advantage, even a competitive advantage is by keeping highly skilled workers in their jobs for a long time. The idea of outsourcing has undermined that competitive advantage and in fact that is probably one contributing factor to the fact that companies that led their industry in cust sat now rank near the bottom. If you will call me I can elaborate more. One of the bottom line takeaways is your article has the feel of trying to help leadership hire and keep people but another factor is people have to want to stay. So that individual goal factors in as well.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

BG Allen的更多文章

  • Thinking about Thinking

    Thinking about Thinking

    Do you ever stop and think about your thinking (by the way - this is called metacognition)? Amazingly few people do…

    1 条评论
  • A Curious Mind

    A Curious Mind

    The one thing that I have noticed in the leaders that I coach is that they have curious minds. That is one reason they…

    2 条评论
  • Want to improve the productivity of your organization?

    Want to improve the productivity of your organization?

    Productivity. It is important for organizations that people are truly productive.

  • when your strength is your weakness

    when your strength is your weakness

    Your strength could be your weakness? The title does seem to be a bit of a paradox does it not? How can a strength be a…

    1 条评论
  • Too Old to Start a Business? Think Again!

    Too Old to Start a Business? Think Again!

    Is it too late to start that business that you always wanted to start? For those of us that are a bit older, we often…

  • You need this kind of friend and colleague

    You need this kind of friend and colleague

    This morning I received a call from former colleague that is now a good friend. He is a friend that has a very…

    3 条评论
  • Unvisited Tombs

    Unvisited Tombs

    Do not forget that a faithful life of quietly serving others is of great importance. Think on the people that have most…

    1 条评论
  • don’t put your employees in the hospital!

    don’t put your employees in the hospital!

    “Simply put, employers can make decisions to improve people’s lives in fundamentally important ways. Or, alternatively,…

    6 条评论
  • We Have a Crisis in Leadership—Or Do We?

    We Have a Crisis in Leadership—Or Do We?

    “More is written about leadership than ever, but we have fewer real leaders.” I have heard this, or something similar…

  • A Framework for Reflection

    A Framework for Reflection

    We have all read and heard about the importance of taking time to reflect on our day so that we may learn from the day.…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了