The U.S.-Canada Trade War: A Masterclass in Mutual Destruction

Alright, let’s be clear—nobody wins a trade war. Not the U.S., not Canada, not businesses, not consumers. But here we are, slapping tariffs on each other like two neighbors in a petty fence dispute, except instead of just being annoyed, we’re both setting our houses on fire.

This all started when the U.S. decided to charge Canada extra for things like lumber, aluminum, and energy, hoping to “protect American jobs.” Canada, obviously not wanting to be bullied, fired back with their own tariffs. And now? Everything is more expensive, businesses are panicking, and supply chains are a disaster.

So, let’s talk about who gets hurt and how long this mess will take to clean up.

Short-Term: Buckle Up, It’s About to Get Painful

This isn’t some distant economic theory—you’re going to feel this trade war in your wallet almost immediately.

1. Everything Just Got More Expensive (For Both Countries)

• Housing: The U.S. imports 30% of its lumber from Canada. That means new homes in America just got $9,000 more expensive, pricing out over a million homebuyers. But it’s not much better for Canada—tariffs mean lumber mills are laying people off because their biggest customer (the U.S.) just made their wood too expensive.
• Cars: Canada is the biggest supplier of U.S. steel and aluminum. Tariffs mean making cars in the U.S. just got pricier—$500 to $1,000 more per vehicle. Meanwhile, Canadian auto plants are sweating because the U.S. buys 80% of their cars. If demand drops, Canadian factories could start shutting down.
• Food & Consumer Goods: Canada is the #1 buyer of U.S. farm products. So when they hit back with tariffs on things like Wisconsin cheese and Florida orange juice, guess who suffers? American farmers. But it works both ways—Canadian grocery stores rely on American imports too, so food prices are going up on both sides of the border.

2. Supply Chain Disaster: It’s Not Just Higher Prices—It’s Delays, Too

A lot of things we buy are made from parts that go back and forth between the U.S. and Canada multiple times. A single car part might cross the border eight times before the vehicle is finished. Add tariffs and delays start stacking up fast.

• U.S. car companies? Costs up. Delays up. Layoffs coming.
• Canadian manufacturers? Same problem, just in reverse.
• Businesses on both sides? Trying to figure out how to survive.

3. Retaliation: Canada Hits Back, and U.S. Farmers and Factories Feel It

Canada isn’t just sitting there taking hits—they’re hitting back strategically by targeting things that will hurt U.S. businesses the most.

• Whiskey from Kentucky? Tariffed.
• Cheese from Wisconsin? Tariffed.
• U.S. farm exports? Tariffed.

This is not good for either side. Canada is a top buyer of U.S. products, and if they find new suppliers, those sales don’t come back.

Long-Term: Canada Moves On, and the U.S. Loses a Reliable Trade Partner

Let’s say this trade war drags on. What happens? Canada starts looking for new customers. And once they find them, they might not come back.

1. Canada Shifts Lumber to China

• The last time the U.S. messed with Canadian lumber, Canada increased exports to China by 700% in just three years.
• If Canada decides to make Asia their main customer, U.S. builders will be stuck paying premium prices forever.

2. Canadian Aluminum Heads to Europe

• After the U.S. slapped tariffs on Canadian aluminum, exports to the EU jumped 11-fold in one year.
• If Canada locks in long-term contracts with Europe, American manufacturers will have to pay more for aluminum, or get it from further away at higher costs.

3. Canadian Oil Flows to Asia

• Right now, 90% of Canada’s oil exports go to the U.S. But if the U.S. makes it too expensive with tariffs, Canada will start sending that oil to China and India.
• And here’s the fun part: The U.S. can’t easily replace that oil. American refineries are built for Canadian crude. Retooling them? Takes years and billions of dollars.

How Long Until the U.S. Can Replace Canada?

Some people will say, “Who cares? The U.S. will just make its own stuff.”

Oh really? Let’s break that down:

• Lumber: U.S. sawmills can ramp up, but fully replacing Canadian supply? 3-5 years minimum. And prices will still be higher.
• Aluminum: The U.S. doesn’t have enough smelters. Building more? 5-10 years at best.
• Oil: The U.S. can drill more light oil, but refineries aren’t built for it. Retooling them? 10+ years and billions of dollars.

So no, the U.S. can’t just “make everything itself” anytime soon.

The Bottom Line: A Trade War Nobody Wins

Here’s the brutal truth: Both the U.S. and Canada are going to suffer in this trade war.

• The U.S. loses a stable, affordable supply of materials.
• Canada loses its biggest customer.
• Consumers on both sides pay more.
• Jobs in both countries are at risk.

And for what? So we can make things more expensive for ourselves?

This isn’t “The Art of the Deal”—this is The Art of Shooting Yourself in the Foot.

But what do you think? Is this actually Trump’s Art of the Deal, or is it just the sequel to The Art of Shooting Yourself in the Foot? Drop your thoughts below.

The information contained herein is for general guidance on matters of interest only. This information contained herein is not intended to provide you with any advice on financial planning, investment, insurance, legal, accounting, tax or similar matters and should not be relied upon for such purposes. Marcin Drozdz, M1 Real Capital Inc are not financial, legal or tax advisers. You should assess whether you require such advisers and additional information and, where appropriate, seek independent professional advice. You understand this to be an expression of opinions and not professional advice. You are solely responsible for any actions you take with the content and hold Marcin Drozdz and M1 Real Capital Inc or any of it's affiliates harmless in any event or claim.