Urban Failing Schools: The Solution Starts with Recognizing the Sympathetic Vagal Balance

Introduction

As an educator and researcher passionate about evidence-based practices, I am deeply puzzled by academic institutions’ reluctance to adopt science-based pedagogies. Is it due to the complex nature of these concepts, their lack of marketability, or the difficulty of implementation? Despite the global popularity of learning styles, they have been proven scientifically inconclusive at best. Yet, widely used!

Failing schools in urban communities share a common thread: students facing immense adversities and complex trauma. These students encounter significant challenges that hinder their academic performance, including elevated levels of stress stemming from socioeconomic instability, exposure to violence, and inherited issues. These levels of toxic stress negatively impact their cognitive functions.

A critical factor linking stress to poor cognitive performance and inferior academic outcomes is the Sympathetic Vagal Balance (SVB). Although not a common teaching concept, it needs to become one. SVB refers to the equilibrium between the sympathetic (fight-or-flight) and parasympathetic (rest-and-digest) branches of the autonomic nervous system. This balance is crucial for regulating stress responses and maintaining cognitive functions that are necessities for the criteria for learning: attention, memory, and executive function. Understanding and addressing the impact of SVB on these cognitive functions can provide valuable insights into the reasons behind poor academic outcomes in failing school.

The Role of Sympathetic Vagal Balance

The autonomic nervous system (ANS) controls involuntary bodily functions, with the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) preparing the body for stressful situations and the parasympathetic nervous system (PNS) promoting relaxation and recovery. Sympathetic Vagal Balance is the optimal modulator between these two branches, allowing for appropriate responses to stress while maintaining calm during rest periods. In high-stress classroom spaces and environments, an imbalance occurs, typically skewed towards excessive sympathetic activity. This chronic stress activation can impair cognitive functions critical for learning, resulting in explosive behaviors which is typical in these community schools. These schools are identified in many schools’ systems. The Chicago Public Schools tags these schools as incentivize, yet interventions are limited to nothing.

We Must Maximize Cognitive Functions

Attention: Attention is the cognitive process of selectively focusing on specific stimuli while ignoring others. It is crucial for learning as it allows students to concentrate on the information being presented. Elevated levels of stress disrupt attention by constantly engaging the SNS, leading to difficulty in sustaining focus. This impaired attention means students may miss key information during lessons, resulting in fragmented learning and poor academic performance.

Memory: Memory involves encoding, storing, and retrieving information. Stress negatively affects memory by impairing the brain's ability to consolidate and recall information. The chronic activation of the SNS due to stress interferes with the hippocampus, a brain region critical for memory formation. This results in students struggling to retain and recall knowledge, impacting their ability to build on previous learning and perform well in exams. Our MABEN model uses cognitive load theory to maximize working memory.

Executive Function: Executive function encompasses skills such as working memory, cognitive flexibility, and inhibitory control. These skills are essential for goal-directed behavior, planning, problem-solving, and self-regulation. Chronic stress impairs executive function by disrupting the prefrontal cortex, the brain region responsible for these higher-order cognitive processes. Students with poor executive function may have difficulty organizing tasks, managing time, and controlling impulses, all of which are necessary for academic success.

Avoiding Fragmented Learning Starts with Attention????????

Avoid Multitasking: Multitasking, often perceived as a way to enhance productivity, can actually fragment attention, reduce the quality of work, and impair cognitive performance. When the brain is forced to switch between tasks, it leads to cognitive overload and increased errors, undermining efficiency, and learning. Therefore, fostering sustained attention by discouraging multitasking is essential for achieving deeper understanding and higher academic and professional success.

Focus and Engagement: Attention enables students to stay focused on their lessons, which is essential for absorbing and processing information effectively. Without sustained attention, learning becomes fragmented and less effective.

?Filtering Information: Attention helps in filtering out irrelevant information and distractions, allowing students to concentrate on the most important aspects of the lesson

?Foundation for Other Cognitive Functions: Attention is foundational for other cognitive processes such as memory and executive function. It sets the stage for information to be encoded into memory and used in higher-order thinking.

Reasons for Student’s Poor Academic Outcomes

In failing schools, the compounded effect of impaired attention, memory, and executive function leads to poor academic outcomes. Students who cannot focus on lessons, retain information, or apply knowledge to new situations are at a significant disadvantage. Additionally, the stress from their environment exacerbates these cognitive impairments, creating a vicious cycle of stress and inferior performance. Teachers in these settings face the challenge of addressing not only the academic needs of their students but also their emotional and psychological well-being.

Implications for Intervention

Addressing the SVB in students from high-toxic-stress environments can mitigate these cognitive impairments and improve academic outcomes. Interventions such as bilateral stimulation, EDMR’s tapping, gratitude journaling, movement breaks, mindfulness practices, relaxation techniques, and physical activity can help balance the ANS by promoting parasympathetic activity. For instance, incorporating deep breathing exercises, progressive muscle relaxation, and guided imagery into the daily classroom routine can reduce stress and enhance attention, memory, and executive function. Additionally, creating a supportive and safe school environment, providing access to mental health resources, and implementing social and emotional learning (SEL) programs can further help students manage stress and improve their cognitive functions.

Conclusion

The connection between Sympathetic Vagal Balance, cognitive functions, and academic outcomes highlights the importance of addressing stress in high-toxic-stress community schools. By focusing on implementing SVB concepts in the classrooms and supporting cognitive functions such as attention, memory, and executive function, educators can help mitigate the adverse effects of stress, modulate secondary trauma, and promote better academic performance. Interventions that balance the autonomic nervous system and foster a supportive learning environment are essential steps towards breaking the cycle of stress and academic failure, paving the way for a brighter future for all students.

Expert Opinions

Insights from Psychologists and Neuroscientists:

• Dr. Nadine Burke Harris: A pediatrician and advocate for trauma-informed care, Dr. Harris emphasizes the need for addressing toxic stress to improve children’s health and educational outcomes.
• Dr. Bessel van der Kolk: A trauma researcher who highlights the impact of trauma on brain development and cognitive functions, advocating for interventions like mindfulness and yoga.
• Dr. Daniel Siegel: A clinical professor of psychiatry known for his work on the connection between interpersonal neurobiology and education, promoting the integration of mindfulness in schools.

SVB in Action

Here are some actual case studies and examples that illustrate the successful implementation of interventions focusing on Sympathetic Vagal Balance (SVB) and their impact on academic outcomes in schools facing high levels of stress:

Case Study 1: Mindfulness in High-Poverty Schools

Location: Visitacion Valley Middle School, San Francisco, California

Intervention: The school implemented a daily mindfulness program called Quiet Time, which included two 15-minute sessions of Transcendental Meditation.

Results:

Reduction in Suspensions: The suspension rate decreased by 79%.

Improved Attendance: Absenteeism dropped by 25%.

Academic Performance: Students’ grades improved significantly, particularly in math and English.

Emotional Well-Being: Students reported feeling calmer and more focused.

Program Details:

The program was integrated into the school day, with sessions held in the morning and afternoon.

Teachers received training on how to facilitate the meditation sessions and support students’ mindfulness practices.

Case Study 2: Social and Emotional Learning (SEL) in Urban Schools

Location: The Cleveland Metropolitan School District, Ohio

Intervention: The district implemented the PATHS (Promoting Alternative Thinking Strategies) curriculum, focusing on SEL to help students manage their emotions and build positive relationships.

Results:

Behavioral Improvements: The number of behavioral incidents decreased by 42%.

Academic Gains: Students in SEL programs scored higher on standardized tests in reading and math compared to their peers.

Emotional Resilience: Students showed improved emotional regulation and interpersonal skills.

Program Details:

The Social Emotional Learning curriculum was taught by classroom teachers who received specialized training.

Lessons included activities and discussions aimed at enhancing students’ self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, relationship skills, and responsible decision-making.

Case Study 3: Physical Activity Breaks in Rural Schools

Location: A rural school district in Eastern Kentucky

Intervention: The district introduced regular physical activity breaks throughout the school day, including yoga and aerobic exercises.

Results:

Enhanced Focus: Teachers reported that students were more attentive and engaged in class after physical activity breaks.

Academic Improvement: Standardized test scores in reading and math showed significant improvement.

Reduced Stress: Students reported lower levels of stress and anxiety.

Program Details:

The school schedule was adjusted to include short physical activity breaks between classes.

Teachers incorporated movement-based learning activities into their lessons.

Case Study 4: Trauma-Responsive Practices in Urban Schools

Location: The Compassionate Schools Project, Louisville, Kentucky

Intervention: The project implemented trauma-responsive practices, including mindfulness, yoga, and SEL, across multiple schools.

Results:

Behavioral Outcomes: Schools saw a 25% reduction in disciplinary referrals.

Academic Performance: Reading and math scores improved by 15% on average.

Mental Health: Students exhibited lower levels of anxiety and depression.

Program Details:

The project provided extensive professional development for teachers on trauma-informed practices.

Schools adopted a holistic approach, integrating mindfulness and SEL into daily routines and curricula.

These case studies provide concrete examples of how interventions focusing on SVB, and related practices can positively impact students’ cognitive functions, emotional well-being, and academic outcomes.

?