The Upside of Downfalls: How Mediocrity Gets Promoted

Have you ever scratched your head in bewilderment as a colleague, who seems to be the epitome of “meh,” ascends the corporate ladder with impressive speed?

Welcome to the baffling world of “failing upwards,” where mediocrity is tolerated and sometimes celebrated. It’s like a plot twist in a movie that leaves you saying, “Wait, what?” Let’s dive into this perplexing phenomenon and explore how it’s shaping (or misshaping) our workplaces.

What is “Failing Upwards,” Anyway?

Imagine this: you’re working hard, meeting your goals, and then—BAM!—someone who seems to coast along suddenly gets a promotion. “Failing upwards” is this peculiar scenario where individuals ascend in their careers despite a track record that’s more dud than dynamo. Here’s how it typically plays out:

• The Steady Eddie Effect: Those who consistently meet expectations but rarely surpass them are sometimes promoted because they’re seen as dependable—even if they’re not exactly groundbreaking.
• The Popularity Contest: Employees who are well-liked or part of an inner circle can be promoted based on their social connections rather than their performance. Being in the right clique can sometimes overshadow true talent and results.
• The Blame Game: In large, convoluted projects, failure is often a team effort. This diffusion of responsibility can shield individuals from accountability, allowing them to climb the ranks unscathed.
• Stuck in the Past: Long-time employees might get promoted based on tenure rather than merit. Their historical knowledge and relationships can be valued over fresh, innovative ideas, further fueling the cycle of mediocrity.

The Ripple Effect on Corporate Culture

When failing upwards becomes a trend, it sends ripples through the entire organization, often leading to a less-than-stellar workplace culture. Here’s how:

• Meritocracy Meltdown: Watching mediocrity get rewarded can be demoralizing. High achievers might feel their efforts are futile and start looking for greener pastures.
• Standards Slide: When mediocrity is the norm, overall standards drop, impacting the company’s performance and competitive edge.
• Quiet Quitting: Disillusioned employees may not leave outright but instead do the bare minimum, disengaging from their work and eroding team morale and productivity.
• Turnover Turmoil: Talented employees may jump ship if they believe their hard work goes unnoticed, leading to a brain drain.

Why Does This Happen?

Several factors contribute to this head-scratching scenario:

• Corporate Complexity: In large organizations, pinpointing individual contributions can be tricky, allowing underperformers to fly under the radar.
• Political Prowess: Those skilled in office politics often maneuver their way to the top, regardless of their actual performance.
• Risk-Averse Decisions: Companies sometimes prefer promoting familiar faces over taking a chance on fresh talent, inadvertently rewarding mediocrity.
• Lack of Clear Performance Metrics: When there are no clear, objective standards for evaluating performance, promotions can become subjective, leading to the advancement of those who may not truly deserve it.

Breaking the Cycle: What Can Be Done?

To curb the rise of mediocrity, organizations need to take a proactive stance:

• Crystal Clear Metrics: Establish transparent and objective criteria for performance and advancement to ensure promotions are genuinely earned.
• Strong Accountability: Implement systems to hold individuals accountable for their results, making it harder for underperformers to coast along.
• True Leadership: Promote those who not only excel in their roles but also inspire and uplift their teams, fostering a culture of excellence.
• Constructive Feedback: Regular, meaningful feedback and development opportunities can help employees realize their potential and avoid the trap of mediocrity.

Wrapping It Up

Failing upwards clearly indicates deeper issues within corporate culture that can stymie success if left unaddressed. Companies can reward real performance and build a brighter, more competitive future by embracing accountability, transparency, and a true meritocracy. Recognizing the problem and committing to change is a challenge every organization must face head-on.

As leaders, it’s our responsibility to create environments where talent thrives and mediocrity is not just managed but actively discouraged. Setting high standards and holding everyone accountable ensures that success is earned, not given, and that our organizations are poised for long-term success.

Ash Serrano is a marketer with nearly 15 years of in-house and agency experience and a knack for creating engaging written and creative content that performs. She has worked with major brands like Amazon, discovery+, Gensler, HGTV, Hulu, KPMG, Mondelez, Pizza Hut, Sugarbear Hair, Synovus, and the Kardashians. She specializes in executive personal branding, creative direction, and influencer marketing. She also owns a career services company, Fairy Career Mother , geared toward getting more women of color into leadership positions.

LinkedIn | Instagram | YouTube | Website