Unveiling the Unseen Challenges in Servicing of the Lithium-ion Batteries

Introduction

Servicing lithium-ion battery packs in stationary energy storage systems is an intricate task shaped by a multitude of interlinked factors.

Complexities, including joining mechanisms, pack design, cooling technologies, thermal solutions, wiring harness design, the use of flame retardant materials, and additional challenges like laser welding, wire bonding techniques, chassis-integrated pack designs, immersion cooling, heat pipe cooling, thermal pad attachments to cells, and small gauge wire sizes, can make maintenance challenging.

In this blog post, we'll delve into these challenges, explore their cumulative impact, and recommend an ideal battery pack design that can streamline servicing.

The Complex Interplay of Challenges

1. Joining Mechanisms: The methods used to connect battery cells or modules significantly impact servicing:Spot Welding: This approach, which uses welded connections, can be challenging to modify or repair. Opt for packs with accessible welding points to simplify cell replacement.Laser Welding: Laser welding, while precise, can be challenging to work with during servicing due to its specialized requirements and potential for localized heat damage.Wire Bonding Techniques: Packs utilizing wire bonding techniques for cell connections can pose difficulties during maintenance, requiring careful handling to avoid damage.Adhesives: Avoid packs with excessive adhesive bonding, as these can slow down disassembly. Choose packs that utilize adhesives sparingly or adopt adhesives that are easier to remove during maintenance.
2. Pack Design: The overall design of the battery pack plays a pivotal role in how efficiently it can be serviced:Modularity: Prioritize packs with a modular layout that allows for individual cell or module replacement. This design simplifies maintenance by reducing the need for extensive disassembly.Accessibility: Look for designs that ensure easy access to key components. Battery packs with clear access points can significantly expedite servicing.Layering: Avoid packs with excessive layering of components, which can complicate maintenance. Choose designs that minimize the number of layers to reach critical components.Design Philosophies: Adopt a design philosophy that emphasizes user-friendliness and serviceability, with modularity, clear access points, and minimised layering.Integrated Pack Designs: Integrated designs may require partial or complete disassembly of the chassis for servicing, increasing complexity.
3. Cooling Technologies: Cooling systems are crucial, but their complexity can introduce challenges:Efficient Cooling: Opt for battery packs with efficient cooling technologies that require minimal maintenance. Well-designed systems can reduce the need for frequent checks and adjustments.Immersion Cooling: Immersion cooling, though effective, may necessitate specialized equipment and training for maintenance.Heat Pipe Cooling: Maintenance of heat pipe-based cooling systems may involve disassembly and replacement of heat pipes, adding complexity to servicing.
4. Thermal Solutions: Efficient thermal management is vital but should be user-friendly:Low-Maintenance Thermal Solutions: Select packs that utilize thermal management solutions requiring minimal user intervention. Attachments like thermal pads may require periodic inspection and replacement.Thermal Pad Attachments: Thermal pads, if used, may need regular monitoring and replacement to maintain optimal thermal performance.
5. Wiring Harness Design: Wiring harnesses play a pivotal role in the overall system, and their design can impact servicing:Complex Wiring Layout: Packs with intricate wiring layouts can complicate diagnosis and repairs. Favor designs with organized wiring, clear labeling, and simplified connections.Small Gauge Wire Sizes: Wiring harnesses with small gauge wire sizes may pose challenges during servicing, requiring delicate handling and potential replacement due to wear.
6. Flame Retardant Materials: The inclusion of flame retardant materials for safety can add to servicing challenges:Increased Complexity: Flame retardant materials may require special handling during maintenance, adding an additional layer of complexity to servicing procedures.

The Cumulative Impact on Servicing

When these challenges converge, servicing lithium-ion battery packs becomes a complex undertaking with the following cumulative impact:

• Extended Downtime: Cumbersome joining mechanisms, intricate pack designs, complex cooling systems, intricate wiring layouts, flame retardant materials, and additional challenges can lead to extended downtime, particularly problematic for applications requiring continuous power supply.
• Labor-Intensive Maintenance: Technicians often face labor-intensive tasks, such as disassembling packs, troubleshooting cooling issues, reconfiguring thermal solutions, navigating intricate wiring layouts, handling flame retardant materials, and addressing specialised welding or bonding techniques.
• Safety Concerns: Compounded challenges increase the potential for safety hazards during servicing, especially when dealing with intricate components, cooling systems, wiring, flame retardant materials, and specialised joining techniques.
• Cost Escalation: Extended downtime, labor-intensive maintenance, safety precautions, and the handling of flame retardant materials contribute to higher servicing costs, potentially impacting the economic feasibility of energy storage systems.
• Environmental Implications: The complexities of servicing may inadvertently lead to improper disposal or recycling of batteries, with potential negative environmental consequences.

The Ideal Battery Pack for Simplified Servicing

Considering the challenges mentioned, an ideal battery pack for simplified servicing would incorporate the following features:

• Modularity: The pack should be designed with modularity in mind, allowing for individual cell or module replacement without extensive disassembly. This minimizes downtime and labor requirements.
• Accessible Design: Clear access points and an intuitive layout should be prioritised to simplify troubleshooting and maintenance tasks.
• Efficient Air Cooling: Choose packs with efficient air cooling systems that require minimal maintenance and are designed for long-term reliability.
• Low-Maintenance Thermal Solutions: Opt for packs that utilize passive cooling methods, complemented by well-placed thermal pads for monitoring and replacement.
• Organized Wiring Harness: Battery packs should feature organized wiring harnesses with clear labeling, standardized connectors, and larger gauge wire sizes to enhance durability and ease of maintenance.
• Flame Retardant Material Selection: Carefully select flame retardant materials that prioritize safety while minimizing complexity during maintenance.

By selecting a battery pack with these characteristics, you can significantly streamline servicing, mitigate the cumulative impact of challenges, and ensure the long-term reliability and cost-effectiveness of your energy storage system. These design considerations will not only reduce the burden on technicians but also contribute to the overall efficiency and effectiveness of your stationary energy storage solution.

It's important to noteImage that the views expressed in this newsletter are personal and do not necessarily reflect the views of any organisation or company mentioned herein.

I hope you found this newsletter informative and thought-provoking. If you have any questions or feedback, please don't hesitate to reach out.

Best regards,

GM

About the Author

Ganesh Moorthi

I am an accomplished Lithium-ion Battery Pack Expert and Energy storage Expert with over a decade of experience in designing and developing EV and ESS battery packs. Throughout my career, I have spearheaded the technology development of Battery Packs and Battery management systems with different AFE's and architectures. I have also led the development of Hardware, Firmware, Packaging, and Software for Energy Storage Systems. I possess a deep understanding of Lithium-ion chemistry and have demonstrated expertise in the production of LiB's with proprietary technologies. With my extensive educational qualifications and vast experience, I believe I can bring unique perspectives about the Energy Storage industry.

Image by freevector on Freepik