The Unseen Side of Gender Equality: A Call for Balance in Indian Law By Anu Sharma, Gender Equality Advocate

In recent years, the discourse around women's empowerment has rightfully taken center stage. Across India, significant strides have been made to uplift women, providing them with opportunities and protections that were once denied. However, as we celebrate these victories, it is crucial to address an often overlooked and deeply troubling consequence of this progress—the impact on men, particularly in the context of certain laws designed to protect women.

The empowerment of women is essential for a just society, but what happens when the scales tip too far? While it's true that men have historically held more power in many areas of life, we must acknowledge that modern society is complex and nuanced. The simplistic narrative that men have always been empowered, and therefore do not need protection or support, is both outdated and harmful.

The Misuse of Women-Centric Laws

India's legal system has introduced several laws aimed at protecting women from abuse, harassment, and discrimination. The intent behind these laws is commendable, but their implementation has led to unintended consequences. Laws such as Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), the Dowry Prohibition Act, and the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act were designed to shield women from the harsh realities of a patriarchal society. Unfortunately, these laws have also been exploited, leading to the victimization of men and their families.

Section 498A, for example, was enacted to combat dowry-related harassment and cruelty by husbands and in-laws. However, it has become a tool for some to seek revenge or manipulate situations to their advantage. The Supreme Court of India has noted instances where false accusations under Section 498A have led to the harassment and humiliation of men and their families. The Court has even gone so far as to describe the misuse of this section as "legal terrorism."

?

The consequences of these false accusations are severe. Men accused under such laws face social stigma, legal battles, and emotional distress. In some cases, entire families are dragged into the fray, leading to a breakdown in relationships and even suicides. The National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) has reported a significant number of male suicides linked to marital discord, a stark reminder of the toll these situations can take.

?

The Business of Financial and Property Claims

Another troubling trend is the increasing use of divorce and separation proceedings as a means for financial and property gain. In recent years, there has been a rise in instances where women use divorce as a business strategy to secure substantial financial settlements or property from their husbands. While it is important to recognize that some women face genuine economic hardships in divorce, there are also cases where the pursuit of financial gain becomes a primary motive.

This phenomenon reflects a broader issue within the legal system: the imbalance in the application of financial support laws. For many women, the prospect of a financial settlement or property division is seen as a way to secure their future. While this can be a legitimate concern, it also underscores the need for a more equitable approach to financial and property settlements in divorce cases.

?

The Need for Judicial Reform

The Indian judiciary has made some attempts to address these issues. In 2014, the Supreme Court mandated that arrests under Section 498A should only be made after a thorough investigation, rather than automatically upon the filing of a complaint. This was a step in the right direction, but more needs to be done.

Judicial reform is necessary to ensure that the spirit of gender equality is truly upheld. This means creating a more balanced approach to laws that affect both men and women. For example, while women have access to legal aid and counseling, similar support structures should be made available for men who find themselves falsely accused. Additionally, there should be stricter penalties for those who misuse these laws, as a deterrent against false claims.

Furthermore, financial and property settlements in divorce cases should be approached with fairness and impartiality. Both partners should be entitled to equitable financial support, recognizing contributions made during the marriage and the needs of both parties. This would ensure that neither partner is unfairly disadvantaged or exploited.?

The Role of Society in Achieving Balance

Legal reform alone is not enough. Society must also shift its mindset. The notion that men are always the aggressors and women are always the victims is a harmful stereotype that needs to be challenged. Gender equality means fairness for all, regardless of gender. This includes acknowledging that men can also be victims of abuse and that their rights deserve protection.

Men who are falsely accused often suffer in silence, fearing that they will not be believed or that their reputations will be irreparably damaged. There needs to be greater awareness and support for men in these situations. This includes educational campaigns, support groups, and legal assistance programs specifically designed for men.

Toward True Gender Equality

True gender equality cannot be achieved by only focusing on one side of the equation. Women's empowerment is vital, but it should not come at the expense of fairness and justice for men. As we continue to fight for the rights of women, we must also ensure that men are not unfairly punished by laws that were designed to protect. The goal should be a society where everyone, regardless of gender, is treated with dignity, respect, and fairness under the law.

It's time for India to take a more balanced approach to gender equality, one that recognizes the complexities of human relationships and the need for a legal system that serves all its citizens equally.

?