Unlocking the Synergy Between Management and Leadership: Are They Really at Odds?

Recently, a fascinating conversation about the dynamic between management and leadership was sparked by a friend's email. As she expressed her thoughts on the subject, it became apparent that the age-old discussion of "Management vs. Leadership" still ignites strong viewpoints today.

Have you ever heard the claim that "management is not leadership"? It's a common sentiment, and one I understand the context for the discussion.

Management is the “process of dealing with or controlling things or people,” according to one definition. Managers often find themselves consumed managing the resources and processes to reach their team’s organizational goals.

Leadership, on the other hand, is about “the action of leading a group of people or an organization". Renowned leadership guru, John Maxwell, simplifies the concept by saying "Leadership is influence - nothing more, nothing less."? Doesn't this perspective apply to management too?

Granted, I recognize and understand the technical distinctions between management and leadership. However, it's hard to ignore the lingering perception that too many view management as taking a back seat to the elevated aura surrounding leadership.? But here's the twist - are these concepts truly differentiated, or are they part of the same fabric?

I recall stumbling upon a saying that stuck with me all these years. A friend of mine, who was a former Vistage coach in Atlanta, used to love to share it with executive groups he coached after I shared it with him. The saying goes, "If a person thinks they are leading and no one is following, then they are just out taking a walk."? Doesn't this resonate with both leadership and management?

Regardless of the managerial level you are at, don't you find yourself wearing the hat of a leader and embracing leadership traits? Certainly, there are different levels of leadership, but consider the relationship between leadership and management may not be as divided as some would suggest.

I'm genuinely intrigued by your perspective on this matter. Where do you stand on the dynamic between leadership and management?

#Leadership #Management #LeadershipVsManagement #EliteDevelopment