A:21 Universal Design and the Evolution of Online Education: Challenges, Opportunities, and Strategies

This paper is a revised version of a study originally conducted in 2020, incorporating new insights and additional research findings. As an instructional designer who has been immersed in the world of online education for over two decades, I have witnessed firsthand the transformative power of digital learning. From my early days as an online student in 2003 to completing my Ph.D. amidst a demanding schedule, I have experienced the challenges and opportunities of online education (Howell, 2020).

Understanding the Shift:

The transition to online education has been a transformative journey marked by technological innovation and evolving pedagogical practices. Historically, education has undergone paradigm shifts with the introduction of new technologies, from pencils to digital textbooks (Howell, 2020). However, the sudden shift to fully remote learning during the pandemic has exposed the limitations and complexities of online education (Howard et al., 2022). Many students were participating online prior to the pandemic, yet challenged by many who believe the instruction was second best.

Challenges in Online Education:

One of the primary challenges facing online education is the need to accommodate diverse student needs and learning styles (Coy et al., 2014; Evmenova, 2018). The increasing diversity of students, including those with disabilities, presents a significant barrier to effective online instruction (Yang et al., 2024). Accessibility concerns must be addressed to ensure that all students have equal learning opportunities (National Center for Education Statistics, 2023).

The absence of face-to-face interaction in online classrooms poses challenges related to student engagement and retention (Harrison, 2021). Educators must find innovative ways to foster community and collaboration in virtual learning environments (Barbour, 2013; Carter et al., 2020).

Universal Design for Learning (UDL) is a framework that provides all students with equal opportunities to learn by removing barriers and accommodating diverse learning needs. In an online classroom, instructors and students can practice UDL principles to create an inclusive learning environment. Here's a list of ways instructors and students can implement UDL in online classrooms:

For Instructors:

1. Offer Multiple Means of Representation:Provide content in various formats (text, audio, video) to accommodate different learning preferences. Use multimedia tools to present information in diverse ways. Provide captions and transcripts for audio and video content.
2. Provide Multiple Means of Action and Expression:Offer flexibility in assignment formats (written, oral, visual) to allow students to demonstrate their understanding in ways that suit their strengths. Use tools that support diverse modes of communication (discussion forums, video conferencing, collaborative documents). Allow for alternative assessment methods focusing on mastery of content rather than specific skills.
3. Offer Multiple Means of Engagement:Provide choice and autonomy in learning activities and assignments. Incorporate interactive elements such as polls, quizzes, and discussions to engage students. Foster a supportive and inclusive online community where students feel valued and respected.

For Students:

1. Advocate for Their Learning Needs:Communicate their learning preferences and needs to instructors. Seek out resources and accommodations available through the institution or online platform.Participate actively in discussions about accessibility and inclusivity in the online classroom.
2. Utilize Available Accessibility Features:Familiarize themselves with accessibility features of the online platform (screen readers, keyboard shortcuts, adjustable font sizes). Advocate for the inclusion of accessibility features that may be missing or inadequate. Provide feedback to instructors and platform administrators on accessibility issues.
3. Engage Actively in Learning:Take advantage of diverse learning materials and resources provided by the instructor. Participate in discussions and collaborative activities to deepen understanding. Seek out additional resources and support when needed to address individual learning challenges.
4. Advocate for Inclusivity:Encourage peers and instructors to consider diverse learning needs and preferences. Share strategies and resources that have been helpful in accommodating their own learning needs. Participate in discussions and initiatives to promote inclusivity and accessibility in the online classroom.

By implementing these strategies, both instructors and students can create a more inclusive and accessible online learning environment that supports the diverse needs and preferences of all learners.

For Employers:

Administrations in hiring committees who do not respect online learning face the debate of face-to-face versus online during interviews. Hiring managers who are skeptical of online learning may have doubts for various reasons. Here are some examples of common doubts they may have:

1. Quality of Education: Some hiring managers may question the quality of education provided by online platforms compared to traditional brick-and-mortar institutions. They may wonder if the curriculum, teaching methods, and assessment standards are rigorous and up to par with traditional education.
2. Credibility of Credentials: Concerns about the credibility of online credentials and certifications may arise. Hiring managers may question the validity and recognition of qualifications obtained through online learning, especially if they are unfamiliar with the accrediting bodies or platforms offering the courses.
3. Lack of Practical Experience: One common doubt is whether online learning adequately provides hands-on or practical experience, particularly in fields such as healthcare, engineering, or skilled trades where hands-on training is crucial. Hiring managers may worry that online learners lack real-world application of their knowledge.
4. Self-discipline and Motivation: There may be doubts about the self-discipline and motivation of online learners. Some hiring managers may question whether individuals who have pursued online learning have the same level of dedication and work ethic as those who have completed traditional in-person programs.
5. Interaction and Collaboration: Hiring managers may wonder about the level of interaction and collaboration in online learning environments. They may be concerned that online learners miss out on opportunities for networking, group projects, and face-to-face interactions with peers and instructors.
6. Technical Skills: In fields where technical skills are essential, hiring managers may doubt whether online learning adequately develops these skills. They may question whether online learners have received sufficient hands-on training with relevant tools, software, or equipment.
7. Adaptability and Flexibility: While online learning showcases adaptability and flexibility, some hiring managers may view these traits as a double-edged sword. They may worry that online learners could lack the structure and discipline necessary to thrive in a traditional workplace setting.
8. Lack of Oversight and Regulation: Concerns may arise regarding the oversight and regulation of online learning platforms. Hiring managers may question whether these platforms adhere to the same quality standards, regulations, and accreditation processes as traditional educational institutions.

Addressing these doubts may involve highlighting success stories of individuals who have excelled through online learning, emphasizing the flexibility and accessibility it offers, providing evidence of rigorous curriculum and accreditation, and showcasing examples of practical skills gained through online education. There are several positive aspects of online learning that can address the doubts of hiring managers and highlight the benefits of this mode of education:

1. Persistence and Self-Motivation: Online learning often requires a high level of self-discipline and motivation. Individuals who successfully complete online courses demonstrate strong persistence and determination, qualities that are highly valued in the workplace. They have shown the ability to set goals, manage their time effectively, and stay focused on their learning objectives, all of which are desirable traits in employees.
2. Accessibility Regardless of Location: One of the most significant advantages of online learning is its accessibility. It allows individuals to pursue education regardless of their geographical location. This is particularly beneficial for those in rural areas or regions with limited access to traditional educational institutions. Hiring managers can appreciate the diversity of talent that online learning brings, as it allows them to tap into a broader pool of candidates with diverse backgrounds and experiences.
3. Flexibility: Online learning offers unparalleled flexibility, allowing individuals to balance their studies with work, family commitments, or other responsibilities. This flexibility is especially valuable for adult learners who may need to juggle multiple priorities. Employees who have pursued online learning demonstrate adaptability and the ability to manage their time effectively, qualities that are highly desirable in today's fast-paced work environment.
4. Grit and Resilience: Engaging in online learning requires a certain level of grit and resilience. Students may encounter technical challenges, time constraints, or other obstacles along the way. Overcoming these challenges demonstrates resilience and determination, qualities that are highly valued in employees. Hiring managers can view online learners as individuals who are willing to take initiative, persevere in the face of adversity, and continuously seek opportunities for growth and improvement.
5. Cost-Effectiveness: Online learning can be a more cost-effective option compared to traditional brick-and-mortar education. Without the need for physical classrooms, commuting expenses, or other overhead costs, online courses are often more affordable. This makes education more accessible to individuals from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds and reduces barriers to entry into certain fields. Hiring managers may appreciate candidates who have pursued online learning as they have demonstrated the ability to make resourceful and cost-effective decisions.

By highlighting these positive aspects of online learning, hiring managers can gain a better understanding of the strengths and capabilities of candidates who have pursued education through online platforms. These qualities can translate into valuable assets in the workplace, making online learners desirable candidates for employment.

Opportunities for Improvement:

Despite these challenges, online education also presents unique opportunities for innovation and improvement. Universal design (UD) principles offer a framework for creating inclusive learning environments that cater to the diverse needs of students (Yang et al., 2024). By incorporating UD strategies into online course design, educators can enhance accessibility and promote compelling learning experiences for all students (Dell et al., 2015).

Additionally, integrating instructional design theories and models can provide valuable insights into effective online teaching practices (Howell, 2020). By leveraging evidence-based instructional strategies, educators can create engaging and interactive online learning experiences that optimize student learning outcomes (Bernard et al., 2004).

The popularity of online instruction has surged in recent years, driven by advances in technology, changing educational paradigms, and increased demand for flexible learning options. With this widespread adoption, both instructors and students encounter unique challenges and complexities in the online classroom environment.

For Instructors:

1. Technological Proficiency: Instructors must become proficient in using various online learning platforms and tools and troubleshoot technical issues that may arise during instruction.
2. Adapting Teaching Strategies: Adapting traditional teaching methods to the online environment requires creativity and innovation to engage students effectively.
3. Managing Time and Workload: Balancing teaching responsibilities, course development, and administrative tasks can be challenging online, requiring effective time management skills.
4. Building Community and Connection: Fostering a sense of community and connection among students in an online course can be more challenging than face-to-face instruction.
5. Addressing Accessibility: Instructors must ensure that course materials and activities are accessible to all students, including those with disabilities, by providing alternative formats and accommodations.
6. Lean on Instructional Designers: Collaborate with instructional designers to develop effective online course materials and pedagogical strategies that align with best online teaching and learning practices.
7. Work with Leadership for Skill Development: Engage with institutional leadership to advocate for professional development opportunities and resources that support ongoing skill development in online instruction, including training workshops, conferences, and peer mentorship programs.

For Students:

1. Time Management: Managing time effectively and staying motivated without the structure of traditional classroom settings can be challenging for online students.
2. Technical Challenges: Students may encounter technical issues with online platforms, requiring troubleshooting skills and patience.
3. Self-Regulated Learning: Online learning requires a high degree of self-regulation and independence, including setting goals, managing time, and seeking help when needed.
4. Communication Skills: Effective communication with instructors and peers in an online environment may require students to adapt their communication styles and utilize various tools and platforms.
5. Digital Literacy: Developing digital literacy skills, including information literacy, online research skills, and critical thinking in digital environments, is essential for success in online courses.

By understanding these challenges and complexities, instructors and students can better prepare themselves to navigate the online learning environment effectively and maximize the benefits of online instruction.

Looking Ahead:

As an instructional designer deeply committed to enhancing online learning experiences, I am dedicated to exploring innovative approaches to online instruction and addressing the ongoing challenges facing online educators and students. By embracing the principles of universal design and leveraging evidence-based instructional practices, we can unlock the full potential of online learning and empower students to succeed in a rapidly changing world.

References:

Barbour, M. K. (2013). State of the nation: K-12 online learning in Canada. International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 14(3), 19–52. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v14i3.1461

BestColleges. (2020). Online education trends report. Retrieved from https://www.bestcolleges.com/blog/online-education-trends/

Bernard, M. et al., (2004). How does distance education compare with classroom instruction? A Meta-Analysis of the Empirical Literature. Review of Educational Research, 74(3), 379–439. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543074003379

Culkin, M. (1967, March 18). A schoolman’s guide to Marshall McLuhan. Saturday Review, pg. 70.

Handbook of research on educational communications and technology. (2014). Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-3185-5

Howell, S. (2020). Opposite the editorial: Distance learning sucks. Educ 737 Ethics and Social Responsibility in Technology.

Howard et al. (2022): Howard, J. R., Johnson, M. J., Baker, R. J., & Smith, A. B. (2022). The great online transition: Challenges and opportunities for higher education. Journal of Online Learning, 16(1), 45-62.

National center for education statistics. (2023). Digest of Education Statistics. Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/

Palvia, S., Aeron, P., Gupta, P., Mahapatra, D., Parida, R., Rosner, R., & Sindhi, S. (2018). Online education worldwide: Current status and emerging trends. Journal of Global Information Technology Management, 21(4), 233–241. https://doi.org/10.1080/1097198X.2018.1542262

Postsecondary national policy institute. (2022). Postsecondary National Policy Institute. Retrieved from https://www.pnpi.org/

Seaman, J. E., Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2018). Grade increase: Tracking distance education in the United States. Babson Survey Research Group. Retrieved from https://www.onlinelearningsurvey.com/reports/gradeincrease.pdf

Yang, M., Duha, M. S., Kirsch, B. A., Glaser, N., Crompton, H., & Luo, T. (2024). Universal design in online education: A systematic review. Distance Education, 1–37. https://doi.org/10.1080/01587919.2024.2303494