Unethical Business - A Fair COP Guv?

Mea Culpa: The Integrity Deficit?

Recent events have thrown the precarious state of global ethics into sharp relief. From a searing Netflix documentary to the high-stakes debates at COP 2024, the week underscored the uncomfortable truths about corporate and governmental complicity in perpetuating social and environmental harm. These issues aren’t new, but their scale—and the absence of accountability—feels increasingly dire.

Ethics Inc.: The Price Tag on Doing Good

The Netflix documentary Buy Now! The Shopping Conspiracy paints a stark picture of how far corporations will go to maximise profits. A different story lies behind marketing campaigns that tout sustainability, fairness, or inclusivity. Corrupt practices in manufacturing, pricing, and waste disposal are too often the norm, while governments and regulators look the other way or enable them.

Corporations craft narratives around fighting climate change or championing mental health, but these efforts often serve as shields to deflect criticism. Beneath the surface lies a singular focus: profits above all else. While some companies adopt these strategies unknowingly, many exploit societal concerns with calculated intent.

Blame Game Theory: Accountability in the Era of Corporate Potatoes

Responsibility for ethical misconduct is often passed around like a hot potato.

Marketing teams argue that they’re simply addressing consumer needs and wants.

Sales teams justify pushing low-cost products by pointing fingers at leadership.

CEOs cite shareholder pressure, while governments claim national debt or global competition ties their hands.

This systemic evasion perpetuates cycles of harm, with workers, consumers, and the environment left to bear the brunt. Meaningful change will only be elusive once every stakeholder owns their role in these issues.

Government and Industry: When Watchdogs Become Lapdogs, Public Trust Takes a Hit

The most disturbing aspect of corporate misconduct is its connection to political power. Several high-profile cases highlight this troubling partnership:

Car Emissions Scandals: Volkswagen’s 2015 emissions scandal revealed a deep-rooted culture of deception. German authorities knew of these practices yet opted to protect their automotive sector, prioritising short-term economic gains over public health and environmental responsibility. Even after the scandal broke, the government lobbied to minimise EU penalties.

Oil and Gas Exploitation: In Nigeria, oil companies like Shell have faced accusations of collaborating with corrupt officials to suppress activism. In 1995, environmentalist Ken Saro-Wiwa and eight others were executed after protesting Shell’s operations in the Niger Delta. Investigations revealed how these corporations benefited from—and arguably enabled—state violence.

E-Waste Dumping: In Ghana, Western nations and corporations ship enormous volumes of electronic and fashion waste under the guise of recycling agreements. Local governments, incentivised by financial dependency, allow toxic materials to pollute ecosystems, creating environmental and social crises.

It's a grim pattern: profit often takes precedence over ethics, aided by governments unwilling to disrupt economic powerhouses.

Greenwashing: When Marketing Ethics is Easier than Practising Them

Even well-intentioned campaigns can fall into the trap of greenwashing. Fast fashion brands, for instance, launch sustainable collections that make up a fraction of their output, while the bulk of their operations remain environmentally harmful. Beverage companies promote recyclable packaging, yet microplastics from their products infiltrate food, water, and even human bloodstreams.

Mental health and social causes are also fair game for exploitation. Brands encourage consumers to “be kind” or “prioritise self-care” while maintaining supply chains that push workers to exhaustion. Similarly, companies promote diversity and inclusion while outsourcing production to regions rife with human rights abuses.

Hypocrisy Unlimited: CEOs in Retirement Redemption

What’s particularly galling is the trend of retired CEOs publicly condemning the very practices that built their empires. In Buy Now!, a former executive strolls along a pristine beach, criticising his past company’s unethical behaviour. The disconnect is jarring. Genuine accountability requires more than words—it demands proactive change while still in a position of influence.

Signs of Life: The Fight for Real Accountability

Amid these challenges, some organisations and movements are striving to make a difference:

• The Right to Repair Movement: Advocates for consumer rights to repair their devices, challenging manufacturers’ planned obsolescence.
• Patagonia: Continues to lead by example, encouraging reduced consumption and sustainable practices.
• Stronger Regulations: The EU is tightening rules on sustainability claims, requiring businesses to substantiate their promises with measurable action.?

These efforts provide glimpses of hope, but vigilance is critical to ensure they don’t devolve into yet another layer of greenwashing.

Profit Without Poison: A Blueprint for Ethical Growth

Profit itself isn’t the enemy. The problem lies in how it’s pursued. Ethical businesses balance profitability with transparency and accountability. They own their mistakes, commit to long-term sustainability, and centre the well-being of workers and communities.

True transparency goes beyond surface-level campaigns. A company that values mental health ensures fair wages and reasonable workloads. A business claiming to fight climate change actively reduces emissions across its supply chain—not just in its marketing.

The Future Won’t Forgive Today’s Failures of Accountability

Change won’t happen without collective will. Governments must close the loopholes that enable corporate misconduct.

Investors should prioritise long-term ethical growth over quick returns.

For CEOs, leadership means taking responsibility now—not after retirement.

Ultimately, the price of inaction will be borne by future generations.

The question isn’t whether we can afford to make these changes—it’s whether we can afford not to.

How Brands Can Profitably Improve the World

1. Embrace Sustainability and Combat Climate Change

Practical Tips:

• Commit to Sustainability: Use sustainable materials, renewable energy, and circular economy principles. Set clear sustainability goals and report progress openly.
• Eco-Friendly Operations: Cut emissions and waste through energy-efficient manufacturing and logistics.
• Sustainable Packaging: Choose biodegradable or recyclable packaging to reduce environmental harm.
• Support Environmental Restoration: Engage in initiatives like tree planting and pollution clean-ups.

Promote Ethical Conduct:

• Avoid Corruption: Enforce anti-corruption policies and focus on innovation over unethical practices.
• Adopt Ethical Labour Practices: Provide safe workplaces, fair hours, and training opportunities. Apply consistent ethical standards globally.
• Uphold Human Rights: Vet suppliers for compliance with human rights standards. Advocate for diversity, inclusion, and fairness across your brand and campaigns.

2. Prioritise Health, Well-Being, and Social Responsibility

Practical Tips:

• Deliver Safe Products: Ensure products enhance consumer health and safety.
• Invest in Health Initiatives: Sponsor community health programs like fitness events or educational workshops.
• Enhance Employee Wellness: Offer comprehensive health benefits and mental health support, and encourage work-life balance with flexible schedules.
• Promote Mental Health: Provide counselling, foster self-acceptance campaigns, and reduce societal pressures through thoughtful branding.

Balance Ethics and Profit:

• Weigh Impact: Measure profit goals against social and environmental consequences. Maintain transparent, fair pricing without exploiting customers.
• Support Economies: Offer affordable products, flexible payment options, and invest in local growth.
• Promote Honesty and Transparency: Openly share sourcing and business practices. Address mistakes swiftly and educate customers to make informed choices.

Market Responsibly:

• Stay Ethical: Ensure truthful advertising free of exploitation or stereotypes. Respect cultural differences in campaigns.

Would you be interested in my addressing your next keynote?

Part proceeds from any talks will go to a charity of your choice. Get in touch today!