Understanding Thermal Design Power (TDP) in CPUs and GPUs: A Comparative Analysis Across Different Notebook Classes

#85

Thermal Design Power (TDP) is a critical specification that often goes unnoticed by the average consumer. Yet, it plays a pivotal role in the performance and efficiency of CPUs and GPUs, particularly in notebooks and workstations. TDP is essentially a metric that represents the maximum amount of heat generated by a CPU or GPU that the cooling system in a computer is designed to dissipate under any workload.

When comparing consumer notebooks, commercial notebooks, and mobile workstations, TDP becomes a defining factor in their performance capabilities. Consumer notebooks are typically designed with lower TDP values, prioritizing battery life and portability over raw performance. These devices are suitable for everyday tasks such as web browsing, document editing, and media consumption.

Commercial notebooks, on the other hand, strike a balance between performance and mobility. They are equipped with slightly higher TDPs compared to consumer notebooks, allowing for better handling of more demanding business applications while still maintaining reasonable battery life and thermal management.

Mobile workstations represent the zenith of notebook performance, with TDPs that are significantly higher than those found in consumer and commercial notebooks. These powerhouses are engineered to handle the most intensive tasks such as 3D rendering, complex data analysis, and high-resolution video editing. The superior TDP in mobile workstations translates to more robust CPUs and GPUs, capable of sustaining peak performance for prolonged periods without throttling due to thermal constraints.

Same CPU, different performance

The same CPU can exhibit different performance characteristics across various notebook classes due to the differences in TDP, Watt input and cooling capabilities, with mobile workstations offering the best performance at the cost of portability and battery life. Professionals in fields that demand high computational power should consider these factors when choosing the right notebook for their needs.

First we need to distinguish between the different CPU choices available for Notebooks:

In the Latest Intel Meteor Lake CPU lineup there are 3 different overall models, with 4 different Watts:

• U CPUs locked at 9 Watts, made for the absolute Ultra-Thin & Light products. Performance comes in third over the choices of portability and battery life in these products.
• U CPUs locked at 15 Watts, made for various Modern Thin & Light notebooks, like the Lenovo ThinkPad E, L and T series.
• H CPUs running at 28 Watts, made for various Performance Thin & Light notebooks, like the Lenovo ThinkPad E, L and T, and even entry level P models like the ThinkPad P14s Gen 5 and ThinkPad P16s Gen 3.
• H CPUs running at 45 Watts (same CPU model as the 28W), made for the Enthusiast and Mobile workstation notebooks, like the Lenovo P series, like P16v Gen 2 and P1 Gen 7.
• On the very high-end Halo Enthusiast Workstation the Intel Raptor Lake HX CPUs rule the game. Those CPUs runs a an staggering 55 Watts, delivering the ultimate in performance. This CPU type is present in the ThinkPad P16 Gen 2.

If we take the latest CPUs from Intel as an example, the Intel Core Ultra 9 185H runs at 28 Watts in any regular commercial notebook from any brand, but in the ThinkPad P14s Gen5 is is able to run at 45 Watts, which gives an enormous performance boost. It also means, that an Intel Core Ultra 5 125H running at 45 Watts in a ThinkPad P14s outperforms an Intel Core Ultra 7 165H running at 28 Watts in a ThinkPad T14 by almost 30%, due to the higher TDP!

As a side note some of the most popular benchmark sites, like Passmark, has a hard time separating the tests that comes from the users, as the same CPUs models, but with different Watts and TDP settings, are being tested from all vendors. Therefore these test doesn't make a lot of sense anymore, when measuring their individual performance. You need to look at the specific model and TDP to get the right picture.

What about graphics?

The same story applies to the different graphic cards that are available in the specific platforms.

TDP represents the maximum amount of heat a GPU can generate under typical load, measured in watts, in the same manner as on a CPU. It's a guideline for the required cooling system's capacity to ensure efficient heat dissipation.

If you, for instance, take an Nvidia RTX 2000 Ada graphics card, this card with perform differently depending on the overall TDP limit in the specific platform. This specific GPU will deliver about 60 Watts in our top of the line machines (ThinkPad P16 and P1) but merely half in a ThinkPad P16v, due to the overall limit in the Thermal Design. An Nvidia RTX 5000 Ada card will run at 115 Watts in comparison, which in turn will deliver an incredible amount of performance.

Why a mobile Workstation?

The reason mobile workstations are often deemed superior lies in their ability to incorporate more powerful components that would otherwise overheat in a smaller chassis. Their larger body allows for more efficient heat dissipation, enabling the use of high-performance parts that are essential for professional-grade applications. Furthermore, features like ECC memory, solid-state drives, and better GPUs contribute to their reliability and stability in scenarios where precision and uptime are paramount.

In conclusion, TDP is more than just a number; it's a reflection of a device's capability to handle heat and, by extension, its performance potential. Whether you're a casual user, a business professional, or a creative expert, understanding TDP and its implications on different types of notebooks can guide you in choosing the right device for your needs. Mobile workstations, with their high TDPs, are indeed superior for those who require uncompromising performance and reliability in their computing tasks.

#tdp #thermal #design #power #intel #nvidia #workstation #mobile #thinkpad #wearelenovo