Understanding Supply Chain Cost Analysis

Identifying and analyzing all the costs incurred throughout the supply chain is essential for a comprehensive understanding of supply chain costs. This involves a detailed process of recognizing various cost elements at different stages of the supply chain, including sourcing, production, and distribution. The total cost of ownership (TCO) analysis is a key approach to identifying these cost elements, encompassing direct, indirect, and associated costs.

To achieve end-to-end supply chain cost transparency, it is important to differentiate fully loaded costs by product and customer and to consider various cost components such as the cost of goods, inbound and outbound handling, distribution network costs, and other relevant expenses.

Additionally, activity-based costing (ABC) is a valuable method for understanding supply chain costs as it provides a detailed and accurate view of costs at a granular level, allowing for a more precise cost analysis within the supply chain.

Furthermore, the main drivers of supply chain costs include investment costs, transportation costs, procurement costs, production costs, and inventory costs, all of which need to be carefully identified and analyzed to gain a comprehensive understanding of supply chain costs.

Activity-Based Costing (ABC) is a useful way of understanding supply chain costs as it provides a precise and accurate view of costs at a granular level, such as individual products, services, and customers. ABC is particularly beneficial in the logistics and supply chain management field as it identifies activities in an organization and assigns the cost of each activity with resources to all products and services, thus offering a more accurate reflection of the costs involved.

Additionally, ABC is being increasingly used in warehousing and distribution to capture cost information and improve cost management in the supply chain. This approach enhances the costing process by expanding the number of cost pools and creating new bases for assigning overhead costs, thereby allowing for a more appropriate pricing strategy and a better understanding of costs.

ABC is a valuable method for understanding supply chain costs due to its ability to provide a more accurate and detailed cost analysis at various levels within the supply chain.

Applying the total cost of ownership (TCO) analysis to the supply chain involves identifying all direct, indirect, and other associated costs. This includes expenses related to the production process, transportation, procurement, and inventory costs.

The TCO method aims to analyze the actual cost of purchasing a product or service beyond the basic purchase price. It encompasses various components such as the initial purchase price, costs associated with operating the item, ongoing maintenance, training needed, and how long the item is expected to last before replacement is needed.

The components of TCO usually include;

o??? Purchase price: Cost price and supplier margin

o??? Cost incurred: Transport, packaging, customs duties, and payment terms

o??? Cost of acquisition: Procurement department operations

o??? Cost of ownership: Stock management and depreciation cost

TCO analysis is a holistic approach that assesses both the purchase price and the costs of operation. Businesses need to consider TCO when making purchasing decisions, as it provides a more comprehensive view of the total cost of owning an asset over its life cycle. This method allows companies to make more informed decisions by considering not only the short-term price but also the long-term cost of the product or service

The Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) approach goes beyond the purchase price of a product or service, taking into account all direct and indirect costs associated with its acquisition, use, and maintenance throughout its life cycle. This includes factors such as shipping costs, inventory costs, and other associated expenses, providing a more accurate and complete view of supply chain costs.

The components of TCO encompass various elements, including;

o??? Purchase Price: This includes the supplier’s manufacturing costs, overhead, and profit

o??? Shipping Costs: Costs and complexity increase with distance, involving expenses such as packaging, transfer, inspection, customs charges, import duties, and storage costs

o??? Inventory Costs: Expenses related to storing, managing, and handling inventory, which can significantly impact supply chain costs

o??? Maintenance Costs: These cover repairs, upgrades, service or support contracts, and other expenses related to the ongoing use of the product or service

TCO analysis is a valuable tool for decision-making in supply chain management, as it helps in making critical lease vs. buy comparisons, and prioritization of capital acquisition. It also enables businesses to calculate customer profitability and employ a cost-driver approach, leading to enhanced profitability and informed decision-making.

By considering TCO, organizations can make more informed decisions about procurement, supplier selection, and inventory management by taking into account all relevant cost components. This approach provides a more accurate understanding of the total costs involved in the supply chain, enabling businesses to optimize their operations and pricing strategies.

Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) analysis can be used to evaluate the performance of suppliers by providing a comprehensive view of the costs associated with owning and operating a product or service over its entire life cycle. When sourcing products or services from different suppliers, evaluating and comparing the TCO of different suppliers involves considering not just the initial purchase price, but also all the costs associated with the product or service. This includes both the visible and hidden costs that may not be immediately apparent, such as acquisition costs, operating costs, and support costs.

To evaluate the TCO and value for money of suppliers, organizations can use TCO and value for money (VFM) frameworks. These frameworks are tools that help assess the full impact of supplier relationships on the bottom line. By using TCO and VFM to benchmark supplier performance, organizations can enhance their decision-making and identify opportunities for improvement.

When evaluating supplier performance, TCO requires purchasers to identify and measure costs beyond the standard unit price, transportation, and tooling when evaluating purchase proposals or supplier performance. This involves considering all costs associated with a product, service, or capital equipment that are incurred over its expected life. Typical cost components to include in a TCO analysis can be broken into four broad categories: purchase price, acquisition costs, ownership costs, and opportunity costs.

TCO analysis provides a robust framework for evaluating supplier performance by considering the complete cost picture associated with a product or service. By understanding and comparing the TCO of different suppliers, organizations can make more informed decisions about supplier selection.

Understanding the main drivers of supply chain costs is crucial for effective cost management. The main cost drivers include investment costs, transportation costs, procurement costs, production costs, and inventory costs.

Investment Costs: In today's globalized economy, supply chains often involve sprawling multi-site networks of suppliers, manufacturers, distributors, and retailers. Smart strategic decisions about investment costs over a time horizon of up to ten years are essential. These decisions include investments in new facilities such as warehouses and factories, as well as the necessary resources and equipment.

Transportation Costs: Moving products from one place to another incurs costs related to fuel, driver salaries, and other expenses associated with the transportation of goods. Choosing the right transportation mode is crucial, as it impacts capacity utilization, inventory levels, and working capital.

Procurement Costs: Procurement costs encompass the amount paid for products, as well as the costs associated with maintaining supplier relationships, negotiating prices, and managing supplier performance. Reducing the number of suppliers and streamlining procurement processes can help reduce these costs.

Production Costs: Production costs can be influenced by factors such as inefficient utilization of assets, protracted machine set-up times, and ineffective workforce management. These costs are significant for manufacturing companies and can be optimized through efficient production planning and resource utilization.

Inventory Costs: Inventory is a vital buffer against supply and demand uncertainty, but it also represents a significant cost for companies across the supply chain spectrum. Costs related to storing, managing, and handling inventory need to be carefully managed to minimize their impact on overall supply chain costs.

Achieving end-to-end supply chain cost transparency is a critical aspect that enables companies to optimize their operations, pricing strategies, and customer relationships. By identifying and analyzing various cost elements within the supply chain, businesses can gain a comprehensive understanding of the costs involved in moving products from manufacturing sources to the end customer.

This transparency is essential for making informed decisions about pricing strategies, customer segmentation, and operational improvements. It also allows companies to calculate customer profitability and employ a cost-driver approach, leading to enhanced profitability and informed decision-making.

Supply chain transparency not only benefits businesses but also consumers, as it enables streamlined operations, leading to cost savings that can be passed on to consumers in the form of lower prices. However, achieving supply chain transparency can be challenging, especially for smaller companies or those with limited resources. It requires the allocation of necessary resources and the implementation of transparent systems and processes, which can be resource-intensive.

Furthermore, supply chain transparency is closely linked to supply chain visibility, which is the business's ability to see into operations at every tier of its supply chain and to enable its supply chain stakeholders to share all relevant information. This visibility, coupled with reliable data, is instrumental in enabling supply chain transparency.

Furthermore, supply chain transparency is closely linked to supply chain visibility, which is the business's ability to see into operations at every tier of its supply chain and to enable its supply chain stakeholders to share all relevant information. This visibility, coupled with reliable data, is instrumental in enabling supply chain transparency.

Leverage Reliable Suppliers: Utilize a network of reliable suppliers and choose known partners who understand the nuances of your supply chain

Use Historical Data and Real-Time Insights: Make decisions based on historical data and real-time insights while comparing the performance and production costs.

Conduct Spend Analysis: Perform a spend analysis to reduce supply chain costs. This involves cataloging business spend data and reviewing it to root out unnecessary costs and remove waste.

Implement Product Manufacturing Cost Analysis Best Practices: Utilize product manufacturing cost analysis best practices to mitigate supply chain and product cost issues. This includes leveraging automated manufacturing cost analysis for accurate supplier pricing data and should-cost analysis.

Identify Main Supply Chain Cost Drivers: Determine the main drivers of supply chain costs, which include investment costs, transportation costs, procurement costs, production costs, and inventory costs.

Identify Critical Costs in the Supply Chain: Identify critical costs in the supply chain by attributing numbers to the cost elements identified in the process map. This involves preparing a list of costs in each category, estimating the values of those costs, and identifying which of those costs are critical in the supply chain.

These best practices encompass various aspects of supply chain cost analysis, including supplier management, data-driven decision-making, spend analysis, product manufacturing cost analysis, and identification of cost drivers and critical costs in the supply chain.

Predictive Analytics and Forecasting: AI algorithms can analyze supply chain data, predict patterns, and accurately forecast future demand. This allows businesses to maintain optimal inventory levels, reducing the costs associated with overstocking or understocking.

Optimization of Supply Chain Processes: By analyzing data from multiple sources, AI algorithms identify the best action to optimize supply chain processes, reduce costs, and enhance customer satisfaction.

Supplier Performance Evaluation: AI evaluates supplier performance, including efficiency, quality, and delivery times. This data is then used to estimate the cost of products or services, enabling organizations to make informed decisions during supplier negotiations and procurement optimization.

Routing Optimization and Transportation Cost Reduction: AI's routing optimization curtails transportation costs and improves delivery timelines, enabling businesses to allocate resources effectively.

Inventory Management and Demand Forecasting: AI's analytical capabilities are leveraged to monitor inventory levels and predict demand, aiding businesses in maintaining an optimal stock level that aligns with fluctuating demand. By scrutinizing extensive datasets, AI identifies potential supply chain risks, offering the opportunity for proactive mitigation.

Cost Reduction and Efficiency Improvement: AI-powered analytics enable businesses to make data-driven decisions that drive operational efficiency, optimize processes, reduce costs, and improve overall supply chain performance by identifying inefficiencies in the supply chain.

AI is being used to transform supply chain costing and analysis by providing advanced predictive analytics, optimizing supply chain processes, evaluating supplier performance, reducing transportation costs, improving inventory management, and driving overall cost reduction and efficiency improvement. These applications of AI are reshaping the landscape of supply chain operations.

To conduct a complete supply chain cost analysis for your organization, the following step-by-step approach can be used as a guideline;

• Start by clearly defining the objectives of the supply chain analysis, including which parts of the supply chain will be assessed and what specific goals are to be achieved.

• Collect information from various sources, such as enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems, warehouse management system (WMS), transportation management systems (TMS), inventory records, transportation data, and supplier performance reports. Key data may include inventory levels, lead times, transportation costs, order fulfillment rates, and demand forecasts.

• Procurement practitioners should collect invoices and payments from all departments, associated plants and business units, accounts payable, eProcurement systems, the general ledger, and financial software. The data collected must represent a specific time period to get an accurate picture of spending and recurring expenses.

• It is essential to ensure that the data collected is up-to-date and consistent to facilitate meaningful analysis. Collaboration with various departments and stakeholders is necessary to gather the required data. IT teams can help extract information from each system, while inventory managers and procurement officers can provide inventory and supplier data.

• Utilize AI and predictive analytics to analyze supply chain data, predict patterns, and accurately forecast future demand. This helps in maintaining optimal inventory levels and reducing the costs associated with overstocking or understocking.

• Identify cost drivers such as the number of suppliers, shipments, and the cost of raw materials. Look for areas of potential cost savings and develop strategies to reduce costs.

• Evaluate supplier performance, including efficiency, quality, and delivery times. This data is then used to estimate the should cost of products or services, enabling informed decisions during supplier negotiations and procurement optimization.

• Define supply chain costs using the TCO approach, which includes the combination of a product or service's purchase cost and additional costs incurred before or after delivery. This provides a comprehensive view of supply chain costs.

• Achieve end-to-end supply chain cost transparency by identifying and analyzing all cost elements within the supply chain. This enables the optimization of operations, pricing strategies, and customer relationships.

• Apply cost analysis techniques to estimate a supplier's overall cost structure. This involves performing a detailed analysis of different cost elements and identifying opportunities to reduce costs.

Knowing supply chain costs is crucial as it forms the foundation of any optimization efforts and continuous improvement within the supply chain. It is the key to achieving cost transparency, which in turn feeds into relative supply chain Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).?

Cost Optimization: Supply chain costs account for a significant percentage of the final product cost. Besides raw material costs, logistics can account for anything between 5% and 50% of the total product cost, depending on where products are sourced, their value, and the shipping methods. Reducing these costs while improving operational outcomes has become a primary mechanism for successful cost optimization.

Risk Mitigation: Simply reducing supply chain costs often introduces other problems, and the lowest-cost supply chains are not the most resilient. By understanding the true costs and profitability of each order, businesses can make more informed decisions about pricing, customer segmentation, and operational improvements, thus mitigating risks.

Cost Transparency: Achieving end-to-end supply chain cost transparency is crucial for businesses to optimize their operations, pricing strategies, and customer relationships. By identifying and analyzing various cost elements within the supply chain, businesses can gain a comprehensive understanding of the costs involved in moving products from manufacturing sources to the end customer.

Supply Chain KPIs: Cost transparency feeds into relative supply chain KPIs by enabling businesses to calculate customer profitability and employ a cost-driver approach, leading to enhanced profitability and informed decision-making. It also allows companies to make more informed decisions about pricing strategies, customer segmentation, and operational improvements.

Thank you for reading...

[And, if you need a remote Supply Chain specialist, Subject Matter Expert, Advisor, Consultant, Project Manager or know someone that does, please feel free to connect & message me directly on LinkedIn.]