Understanding Metrics That Matter

Kinds of Metrics : Vanity, Proxy, and Core Business Metrics in Product Management

In the world of product management, metrics are the compass guiding us toward growth, customer satisfaction, and sustainable business success. But not all metrics are created equal. Today, let’s explore three types of metrics—Vanity Metrics, Proxy Metrics, and Core Business Metrics—and how understanding their roles can make a difference in our decision-making.

1. Vanity Metrics: The Flash Without the Substance

Vanity metrics are numbers that look impressive but don’t offer much in terms of actionable insights. They are often used to make a product or initiative appear successful on the surface, but they fail to reflect actual value or impact.

Examples of Vanity Metrics:

• App Downloads: High download numbers might look good, but without user engagement or retention, they’re only skin-deep.
• Page Views or Likes: A post that garners thousands of likes or views may be popular but doesn’t always translate into revenue or sustained interest.

Why Avoid Relying on Vanity Metrics? Relying too heavily on vanity metrics can create a false sense of success, potentially leading to misguided strategies. For instance, high page views may not be valuable if users aren’t engaging with or converting on your platform. Instead of chasing flashy numbers, focus on metrics that link directly to business goals, such as retention and engagement.

2. Proxy Metrics: Measuring Progress When the Path is Indirect

Proxy metrics are indirect indicators used when it’s difficult to measure an objective directly. They act as stand-ins that, when well-chosen, can provide a good approximation of success or progress.

Examples of Proxy Metrics:

• Time Spent on Site: This can act as a proxy for engagement if exact actions (e.g., purchases) aren’t being tracked.
• Returning Visitor Rate: When customer loyalty is hard to measure directly, tracking repeat visitors can offer clues about satisfaction.
• User Retention Rate: If customer satisfaction is challenging to assess directly, retention often serves as a helpful proxy.

Using Proxy Metrics Effectively To get the most out of proxy metrics, it’s essential to ensure they are closely tied to your primary objectives. For example, using time on site as a proxy for engagement may work for content-based sites but may be less relevant for ecommerce, where conversion might be a better indicator. Always ensure that your chosen proxy metric has a clear correlation with the actual goal to avoid misleading interpretations.

3. Core Business Metrics: The Metrics That Drive Decisions

Core business metrics are the heart of any performance tracking system. These are the metrics directly tied to your business goals and offer valuable insights into both customer satisfaction and financial health.

Examples of Core Customer Metrics:

• Customer Satisfaction Score (CSAT): Tracks customer happiness with a product or service.
• Net Promoter Score (NPS): Measures customer loyalty by assessing how likely customers are to recommend the product.
• Customer Retention Rate: Tracks the percentage of customers who continue using your product, often indicating satisfaction and product-market fit.
• Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): Estimates the total revenue a customer will bring to the business over their lifetime, helping forecast revenue and justify acquisition costs.

Examples of Core Business Metrics:

• Revenue and Revenue Growth: The ultimate indicators of business growth and market traction.
• Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): Tracks the cost associated with acquiring a new customer, useful for balancing growth and profitability.
• Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR): For subscription models, MRR helps maintain a pulse on predictable revenue.
• Gross Margin: Reflects core profitability by calculating revenue minus the cost of goods sold.

Why Core Business Metrics Matter These metrics allow you to track progress on key business objectives. By focusing on actionable metrics, you can make more informed decisions on areas like product development, marketing strategy, and customer service. For instance, a declining retention rate may indicate issues with customer experience, prompting further analysis and improvements.

Putting It All Together: How to Balance These Metrics in Product Management

While vanity metrics provide visibility, proxy metrics offer hints, and core business metrics measure real progress. Striking a balance between these types allows product teams to gain a well-rounded perspective on product performance.

Here’s how you can leverage all three effectively:

• Limit Vanity Metrics: Use them as supplementary data, not core indicators of success.
• Choose Proxy Metrics Wisely: Ensure your proxy metrics closely align with actual goals and provide directional insights.
• Focus on Core Business Metrics: Make them the foundation of your strategy and decision-making process.

By understanding the value and limitations of each metric type, product managers can craft strategies that drive real impact, delivering both customer value and sustainable business growth.

Final Thoughts

In product management, metrics aren’t just numbers—they’re insights. By distinguishing between vanity, proxy, and core business metrics, we can make more informed decisions that truly benefit our customers and drive business success. So, let’s keep our eyes on what matters, dig deeper, and make data-driven decisions that elevate both our products and our careers.

Which metrics do you rely on most in your role? Let’s start a conversation!

P.S. If you missed my last webinar on Mobile Product Management, you can watch it here: https://youtu.be/cbQDCuIN0Mk.

For more content like this on product management, follow me on LinkedIn: https://www.dhirubhai.net/in/shaikkhader/.

Looking for community support and bite-sized learning on your product manager journey? Join our WhatsApp community here: https://chat.whatsapp.com/CUeOWRmQvBH4sqgWYlEj3G.