Understanding the Difference: Transportation Management System (TMS) vs. Routing System

In the world of logistics and supply chain management, two tools often come up in conversation: the Transportation Management System (TMS) and the Routing System. While both aim to optimize transportation processes, they differ in their primary scope.

Transportation Management System (TMS)

A TMS is a comprehensive digital tool companies use to manage their logistics and transportation functions effectively. It centralizes and organizes transportation data, allowing companies to plan and forecast network needs, optimize routes, manage carriers, execute and track shipments, automate processes (like load booking and tendering), handle payment and settlement, and report on network KPIs. In essence, a TMS deals with freight movement to and from facilities.

Routing System

On the other hand, a Routing System is a TMS or standalone software component that explicitly deals with optimizing and planning the most efficient routes for transporting goods. They primarily focus on the tactical aspect of transportation planning and help maximize efficiency and cost savings in route selection.

Do You Need Both?

While a TMS provides a broad range of functionalities for managing transportation operations, a Routing System focuses specifically on optimizing and planning routes. But how can an organization identify if they need both? Here are five indicators:

1. Complex Logistics Operations: If your organization has complex logistics operations involving multiple transportation modes, a TMS can provide a comprehensive solution, while a Routing System can help optimize each route.
2. High Volume of Shipments: If your organization handles a high volume of shipments, a TMS can help manage these effectively, and a Routing System can ensure each shipment takes the most efficient route.
3. Multiple Shipping Locations: Organizations with multiple shipping locations can benefit from a TMS to manage the overall operations and a Routing System to optimize routes between these locations.
4. Need for Cost Efficiency: If reducing transportation costs is a priority, a TMS can provide cost-saving strategies like load consolidation. In contrast, a Routing System can reduce costs by selecting the most efficient routes.
5. Customer Service Excellence: If excellent customer service is important, a TMS can ensure timely and accurate deliveries, and a Routing System can reduce delivery times by choosing the fastest routes.

While both systems have unique benefits, they can complement each other to provide a comprehensive solution for managing and optimizing transportation operations. The decision to implement one or both will depend on your organization’s specific needs and circumstances.

?