Understanding CPK and TCO in the Shift to Electric Vehicles in South Africa

The Supply Chain Keynote

Welcome and thank you for reading The Supply Chain Keynote. This weekly update explores the latest advancements and strategies in supply chain management, focusing on Supply Chain, Logistics. We delve into topics like leadership, trends, and futuristic insights, addressing the unique challenges and opportunities faced by supply chain management.

Want to stay informed?

Subscribe to this series using the button above and let us know what you want to hear about next week using #SupplyChainKeynote?in the comments below.

Understanding CPK and TCO in the Shift to Electric Vehicles in South Africa

South Africa, like many other countries, is slowly transitioning from internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles to electric vehicles (EVs) as it works toward reducing carbon emissions and embracing cleaner, more sustainable energy sources. The shift is heavily influenced by the need to balance the cost and operational efficiency of vehicles. In this context, two critical financial metrics come to the forefront—Cents Per Kilometer (CPK) and Total Cost of Ownership (TCO). Understanding these metrics is vital for fleet managers, consumers, and policymakers alike to make informed decisions when considering the move to electric vehicles.

This article delves into the complexities surrounding CPK and TCO in the context of South Africa's EV transition. It will provide insights into how these metrics affect fleet optimization, the long-term cost benefits of EVs, and the environmental and market dynamics shaping this shift.

The Role of CPK in Vehicle Cost Analysis

Cents Per Kilometer (CPK) is a cost metric used to evaluate the operating expenses of a vehicle per kilometer driven. It takes into account fuel costs, maintenance, and other variable expenses associated with operating a vehicle. For many years, fleet operators and vehicle owners in South Africa have relied on CPK calculations to optimize costs, particularly for ICE vehicles. However, the shift to EVs has introduced new variables, such as electricity costs, which necessitate a re-evaluation of traditional CPK calculations.

Key Influencing Factors for CPK:

1. Fuel Prices: In ICE vehicles, fuel consumption and fuel prices are critical variables in the CPK calculation. Fluctuations in global oil prices and local taxes can drastically impact CPK. For EVs, the cost of electricity plays a similar role, making electricity rates and grid stability crucial factors for CPK.
2. Maintenance Costs: EVs have fewer moving parts than ICE vehicles, reducing maintenance costs significantly. This lower maintenance requirement typically leads to a lower CPK for EV fleets.
3. Government Incentives: Incentives such as tax rebates, subsidies, and lower import duties for EVs can help improve their CPK compared to ICE vehicles. However, the lack of comprehensive incentives in South Africa limits the immediate cost advantage of EVs in CPK comparisons.
4. Charging Infrastructure: The availability and cost of charging infrastructure are increasingly vital factors affecting the CPK of EVs. In South Africa, where charging infrastructure is still developing, this becomes a crucial consideration for fleet managers.

Calculating CPK for ICE Vehicles:

• Fuel Consumption: The fuel efficiency of the vehicle is measured in liters per 100 kilometers (L/100km) or miles per gallon (MPG).
• Fuel Costs: The price of fuel per liter or gallon based on current market prices is used to estimate the cost of driving a certain distance.
• CPK Calculation: Multiply the fuel consumption rate by the price per unit of fuel to calculate the CPK for the ICE vehicle.

Calculating CPK for EVs:

• Electricity Costs: Determine the cost of electricity per kilowatt-hour (kWh) for charging the EVs.
• Energy Efficiency: Measure the energy efficiency of the EV fleet in terms of kWh per 100 kilometers.
• CPK Calculation: Multiply the electricity cost per kWh by the energy consumption rate to calculate the CPK for EVs.

Transitioning to TCO: A More Holistic Cost Perspective

While CPK remains a relevant metric for short-term cost analysis, it does not provide the full picture of vehicle costs over their lifetime. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) is a more comprehensive approach that considers not only operational costs but also the purchase price, insurance, depreciation, taxes, and resale value of a vehicle.

TCO provides a long-term view of the financial implications of owning and operating a vehicle, which is essential for making informed decisions about fleet optimization and vehicle procurement. The inclusion of factors like charging infrastructure, reduced maintenance needs, and depreciation makes TCO a more suitable metric for comparing ICE vehicles and EVs.

Key Factors Affecting TCO for EVs:

1. Upfront Purchase Costs: While EVs have higher upfront costs compared to ICE vehicles, government incentives (where applicable) and decreasing battery costs help mitigate this.
2. Charging Infrastructure: The cost of installing and maintaining charging stations must be factored into the TCO for EV fleets. In South Africa, this remains a significant challenge, particularly for fleet operators.
3. Energy and Maintenance Savings: EVs generally offer lower energy and maintenance costs compared to ICE vehicles. These savings accumulate over time, contributing to a more favorable TCO for EVs in the long run.
4. Resale Value: As EVs become more popular and the market matures, their resale value may increase, improving the overall TCO. However, the current limited supply of affordable EVs in South Africa may affect resale values in the short term.

Calculating TCO for ICE Vehicles:

• Upfront Costs: The vehicle purchase price, including any applicable taxes and fees.
• Fuel and Maintenance: The ongoing costs of fuel, oil changes, and repairs throughout the vehicle's lifetime.
• Depreciation: The expected depreciation or reduction in the vehicle's value over time.
• Resale Value: The anticipated trade-in or resale value at the end of the vehicle's useful life.

Calculating TCO for EVs:

• Upfront Costs: The purchase price of the EV, including any subsidies or tax incentives that may apply.
• Charging Infrastructure: Costs associated with installing and maintaining charging stations.
• Energy and Maintenance: The ongoing costs of electricity and lower maintenance needs over time.
• Depreciation and Resale Value: Expected depreciation and resale value for the EV fleet at the end of its operational life.

The South African Context: Challenges and Opportunities

South Africa faces unique challenges in its transition to electric vehicles. Issues such as load shedding, high electricity costs, limited charging infrastructure, and import duties on EVs have slowed the pace of EV adoption. However, growing consumer interest in environmentally friendly vehicles and decreasing battery costs offer a promising future for EVs in the country.

Market Potential and Adoption Trends:

1. Growing Interest in EVs: A significant percentage of South African consumers are interested in hybrid and electric vehicles, driven by rising environmental concerns and increasing awareness of the long-term cost savings associated with EVs. According to a PwC survey, 76% of respondents indicated an interest in purchasing either a hybrid or electric vehicle.
2. EV Sales Growth: Despite challenges, South Africa has seen a 49% year-on-year increase in EV sales in the first half of 2024, reflecting a growing interest in the sector. The availability of more affordable models, such as the Volvo EX30 and GWM Ora, has contributed to this growth.
3. Government Support: While government incentives for EV adoption remain limited, proposals such as the investment allowance for EV manufacturing and import duty reductions are steps in the right direction. These incentives could help lower the upfront costs of EVs, making them more accessible to the South African public.
4. Environmental Impact: The South African transport sector is responsible for a significant portion of the country's emissions. The shift to EVs can substantially reduce carbon emissions and improve air quality, particularly in urban areas. This aligns with South Africa’s commitment to reaching net-zero emissions by 2050.

CPK vs. TCO: Which Metric Should Fleet Managers Prioritize?

Traditionally, CPK has been the go-to metric for fleet managers in South Africa. However, as EV technology advances, there is a growing need to shift the focus from CPK to TCO. Here’s why:

• Short-Term vs. Long-Term Cost Savings: While CPK provides a snapshot of short-term operational costs, TCO gives a broader, long-term perspective on the cost of vehicle ownership. For EVs, the higher upfront costs are offset by lower operational and maintenance costs over time, which is better reflected in the TCO.
• Inclusion of Additional Costs: TCO accounts for vehicle depreciation, insurance, and resale value, providing a more holistic view of costs. In the case of EVs, it also factors in the cost of charging infrastructure, which is critical for fleet managers considering a transition to electric vehicles.
• Comprehensive Decision-Making: TCO helps fleet managers make more informed decisions about vehicle procurement by considering all aspects of vehicle ownership. This is especially important as the South African EV market continues to evolve and the true cost benefits of EVs become more apparent.

EV Market Dynamics and Sustainability Considerations

The environmental benefits of electric vehicles are driving consumer interest in South Africa. EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, helping reduce air pollution and carbon footprints in urban areas. The transport sector currently contributes over 10% of South Africa’s national gross emissions, making the shift to EVs an essential component of the country’s broader environmental strategy.

Key Environmental Benefits of EVs:

1. Zero Emissions: EVs eliminate pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), improving air quality and public health.
2. Renewable Energy Integration: South Africa’s abundant solar and wind resources can be leveraged to power EVs through renewable energy, further reducing dependence on fossil fuels.
3. Climate Commitments: South Africa’s commitment to reaching net-zero emissions by 2050 necessitates a transition to electric vehicles. EV adoption is critical for reducing the transport sector's carbon footprint.
4. Sustainable Transport: EVs are an integral part of the sustainable transport agenda, which includes reducing reliance on fossil fuels and decreasing overall energy consumption.

Challenges to EV Adoption in South Africa

Despite the potential benefits, several significant challenges remain for the widespread adoption of EVs in South Africa:

1. High Purchase Prices: EVs in South Africa are significantly more expensive than ICE vehicles. The lack of sufficient government incentives, such as tax rebates or subsidies, further exacerbates the high upfront costs, making EVs less accessible to the average consumer.
2. Limited Charging Infrastructure: While private companies are leading the way in installing charging stations, South Africa still lacks a comprehensive national network. This limits the practicality of long-distance travel and creates “range anxiety” among potential buyers.
3. Load Shedding: Frequent electricity supply interruptions due to load shedding make EV charging unreliable, particularly in areas where grid stability is a concern.
4. Import Duties: High import duties (up to 25%) on EVs make them even more expensive than their ICE counterparts, further slowing adoption rates.

Conclusion: The Road Ahead

The transition to electric vehicles in South Africa is inevitable, but it will require strategic planning, government support, and continued investment in infrastructure. As the market matures and more affordable EV models become available, both consumers and fleet operators will need to shift their focus from traditional CPK calculations to a more comprehensive TCO approach.

By understanding the full lifecycle costs of EVs and embracing the environmental benefits they offer, South Africa can make significant progress toward a sustainable and cost-efficient transport future. However, overcoming challenges such as high purchase prices, charging infrastructure, and energy supply issues will be critical to ensuring the success of the EV transition.

As government policies evolve and consumer interest continues to grow, the future of electric vehicles in South Africa looks promising. With the right strategies in place, EVs can offer long-term cost savings, improved fleet optimization, and a cleaner, greener future for the country.

Final Thoughts

If you want to talk over your options, click here to schedule a meeting with me to see how we can help you revolutionize supply chain management and delivery.

If you enjoyed The Supply Chain Strategist, I have a quick favor to ask:

• Subscribe to this series using the button at the top of this post so you don’t miss a single update.
• Share this post with your network on LinkedIn if you think they could benefit from the message using the Share button below.