Understanding the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) Size Premium

In the realm of financial research and valuation, the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) size premium plays a critical role. This measure, widely used in both academic and professional fields, seeks to capture the relationship between firm size and its expected stock returns. Investors and valuation professionals often rely on CRSP size premium data to adjust discount rates in their valuation models, reflecting the inherent risks of investing in smaller firms. This article from Business Valuation Advisors will delve into the mythology surrounding the CRSP size premium, the decile classification system, and its implications for firm valuation and investment decisions.

What Is the CRSP Size Premium?

The CRSP size premium refers to the historical data that captures the excess returns generated by smaller firms relative to their larger counterparts. The concept is rooted in the "size effect," a well-documented phenomenon where smaller companies, on average, yield higher returns compared to larger firms, albeit with higher risk.

Professionals in valuation typically derive this premium from the historical returns of companies grouped by market capitalization and use it to modify discount rates when estimating a company's value. Smaller firms are generally seen as riskier, so the size premium compensates investors for this higher risk.

The CRSP data is vital to this process because it offers a comprehensive and well-established dataset of stock prices, volumes, and returns, dating back decades. The size premium is often presented in deciles, a system of ten equal groups ranked by market capitalization. Let’s explore how these deciles are structured and what each of them represents.

Decile Classification: From Largest to Smallest

The CRSP methodology for organizing firms into deciles is based on market capitalization, with companies in the first decile (Decile 1) being the largest and those in the tenth decile (Decile 10) being the smallest. Market capitalization, which is calculated by multiplying a company's share price by its total number of shares outstanding, is used as the primary measure for firm size.

Here’s a breakdown of the decile classification:

1. Decile 1 (Largest Firms): This decile contains the largest firms in the stock market by market capitalization. These are typically well-established, blue-chip companies with a history of stability and consistent returns. As such, they generally offer lower risk but also relatively lower expected returns.
2. Deciles 2-4: These deciles include companies that are large, but not as large as the top decile firms. These are still significant players in the market, often multinational companies, but may experience more variability in returns than Decile 1 firms.
3. Deciles 5-7: As we move down the deciles, the firms become smaller, and market capitalization decreases. Companies in these deciles are medium-sized firms, and they tend to have higher growth potential but also come with increased risk compared to larger companies.
4. Deciles 8-9: These deciles represent relatively small firms, typically referred to as "small-cap" stocks. They are generally more volatile than larger firms and tend to offer higher potential returns, but with significant risks.
5. Decile 10 (Smallest Firms): This decile consists of the smallest firms by market capitalization. These are often young, emerging companies that are highly speculative and volatile. They might have substantial growth potential, but they are also subject to greater risks, including financial instability and market fluctuations. Historically, these firms have offered the highest returns but at the greatest level of risk.

The CRSP Methodology for Decile Formation

The CRSP’s approach to creating these deciles involves more than just sorting companies by their market capitalization. The methodology relies on a specific universe of eligible companies, excluding certain types of securities such as unit investment trusts, closed-end funds, REITs, Americus Trusts, foreign stocks, and American Depository Receipts (ADRs). These exclusions help maintain the integrity of the dataset by focusing only on common stocks of U.S. companies.

The decile classification starts with firms listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), NYSE MKT, and the Nasdaq National Market. First, market capitalization ranks eligible companies that primarily trade on the NYSE and divides them into ten equal groups, or deciles. The largest capitalizations in each decile then serve as the breakpoints for decile assignment across all eligible firms, including those trading on the NYSE MKT and Nasdaq National Market. This approach ensures consistency across different exchanges, allowing for accurate comparison of firms regardless of where they are traded.

Importance of the Size Premium in Business Valuation

In the field of business valuation, the size premium is a crucial factor in determining the appropriate discount rate for smaller firms. Valuation professionals commonly use the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) to estimate a company’s cost of equity. In its basic form, CAPM considers three components:

• Risk-free rate: This is typically the yield on long-term U.S. Treasury bonds, reflecting the return on an essentially riskless investment.
• Equity market premium: This represents the additional return investors expect to earn from investing in stocks versus risk-free assets.
• Beta: This measures the stock’s volatility relative to the overall market.

However, for smaller firms, the standard CAPM model may underestimate risk. Small-cap stocks often have more unpredictable cash flows, less liquidity, and higher market sensitivity, which can lead to greater volatility in stock prices. The size premium is added to the CAPM calculation to account for the additional risk associated with investing in smaller firms.

Incorporating the Size Premium

The adjustment process typically works as follows:

1. Start with CAPM: A basic CAPM model is used to estimate the cost of equity.
2. Add the Size Premium: A size premium, derived from historical CRSP data, is then added to the CAPM result. This premium compensates investors for the additional risks they are taking on by investing in a smaller firm.

For example, if a small company is in the tenth decile, the historical data might suggest that investors require an additional return of 2-4% to compensate for the risks associated with the company’s size. This added premium adjusts the discount rate used in valuation models, ensuring that the risks are adequately reflected in the firm’s estimated value.

Why Use Deciles in Size Premium Calculations?

The decile approach is especially useful because it groups firms into ten equally populated portfolios, making it easier for researchers and practitioners to analyze return patterns across different size classes. By breaking the market down into deciles, the data highlights the relationship between firm size and stock returns in a clear, structured manner. This segmentation also helps in identifying trends that may be overlooked if the entire market were analyzed as a whole.

One key advantage of the decile method is that it provides a range of data points, allowing professionals to fine-tune their valuation models based on a company’s size relative to others in the market. Additionally, the historical performance of each decile provides insights into how different size classes perform in varying economic conditions.

Academic and Practical Applications

The CRSP size premium has been extensively studied in academic finance, providing empirical support for the size effect. Rolf Banz conducted one of the earliest and most significant studies on this phenomenon in 1981, which showed that smaller firms typically outperform larger firms over extended periods of time. Numerous subsequent studies have confirmed this finding, making the size effect a fundamental concept in asset pricing and portfolio management.

For valuation professionals, the CRSP size premium is a practical tool for adjusting discount rates and improving the accuracy of their valuation estimates. By incorporating size premiums, professionals can better account for the higher risk associated with smaller firms, leading to more accurate and defensible valuations.

Challenges and Considerations

Despite its widespread use, the size premium is not without controversy. Some researchers argue that the size effect has diminished in recent decades, potentially due to changes in market structure, improved information dissemination, or the rise of index investing. Others suggest that the size effect is more pronounced in certain economic environments, such as during periods of economic expansion, and may weaken during recessions.

Moreover, applying the size premium in practice requires careful consideration. The specific size premium used should be based on current market conditions and the firm’s characteristics. Blindly applying historical premiums without adjusting for changes in the market environment could lead to inaccurate valuations.

Conclusion

The CRSP size premium is an invaluable tool for understanding the relationship between firm size and stock returns. By organizing firms into deciles based on market capitalization, the CRSP methodology allows for a detailed analysis of how size affects risk and return. For valuation professionals, the size premium provides a way to adjust discount rates, ensuring that the higher risks associated with smaller firms are adequately reflected in their valuations.

While the size premium is a well-established concept, it is essential to use it judiciously, taking into account the latest market data and the specific characteristics of the firm being valued. Blindly applying historical premiums without adjusting for changes in the market environment could lead to inaccurate valuations.

This is where Business Valuation Advisors can offer critical expertise.

At Business Valuation Advisors, our professionals bring deep knowledge of the CRSP size premium and its application in the valuation process. Our expertise ensures that the discount rates used in your firm’s valuation accurately reflect the risk profile.

For business owners, investors, and stakeholders seeking to make informed decisions, Business Valuation Advisors offers a blend of academic rigor and practical experience. By leveraging our expertise in size premiums and valuation methodologies, we can help you navigate the complexities of business valuation with confidence.

If you would like to learn more, subscribe to our newsletter, or if you need valuation services, send us a direct message here on LinkedIn.