Understanding the Benefits and Mechanics of ESOPs in Indian Startup Culture

Introduction to ESOPs

Employee stock option plans (ESOPs) have become an increasingly common part of compensation packages, especially in startups. ESOPs give employees the right to purchase shares of the company's stock at a predetermined price, also known as the exercise or strike price.

ESOPs are intended to align the incentives of employees with shareholders and reward employees for contributing to the growth and success of the company. The basic mechanics involve granting stock options to employees which they can choose to exercise after a vesting period, typically 4 years. After vesting, employees have a window of time, usually 90 days, to purchase the shares at the exercise price.

The main benefits of ESOPs are:

• Align Incentives: Gives employees a stake in the company's growth which motivates them to increase shareholder value.
• Attract and Retain Talent: Serves as a competitive benefit to hire and retain top talent, especially for startups unable to offer high salaries.
• Shared Ownership: Allows employees to share in the company's success that they helped create.
• Tax Advantages: ESOPs enjoy favorable tax treatment in many countries compared to other forms of compensation.

In summary, ESOPs are an important way for startups to attract and retain talent while aligning employee incentives with shareholders. They give employees shared ownership and upside if the company succeeds.

ESOPs in Indian Startups

Employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs) have become increasingly popular amongst Indian startups over the past decade. As startups aim to attract and retain top talent, ESOPs have emerged as a key incentive. By offering employees stock options, startups can compensate employees beyond just cash salaries.

India's startup ecosystem has seen rapid growth, with major players like Flipkart, Paytm, Ola, and more emerging. Many of these leading startups have made extensive use of ESOPs.

• Flipkart pioneered the use of ESOPs in India. It granted ESOPs to 700 employees as early as 2009. This helped Flipkart attract and retain talent in the early stages, allowing it to become India's leading ecommerce platform.
• Paytm has also been a prominent user of ESOPs. In 2015, it gave away ESOPs worth around $8 million to 200 employees. Later in 2017 and 2021, it conducted further ESOP buybacks, providing liquidity.
• Other major startups like Ola, Zomato, Swiggy, and Udaan have followed suit and offered ESOPs to not just senior executives, but also junior employees. This has helped them build world-class teams.

Clearly, ESOPs have become an integral part of the talent strategy for many leading Indian startups. In their bid to scale rapidly and disrupt markets, ESOPs enable startups to attract top-notch talent and also help align incentives by making employees think like owners. The Indian startup success stories of the past decade have made ESOPs a sought-after employee benefit.

Why Startups Offer ESOPs

Employee stock option plans (ESOPs) have become an integral part of compensation packages at startups. There are several key reasons why startups offer ESOPs:

i. Employee Retention

One of the biggest challenges for startups is retaining talent, especially in the early stages when cash flow is limited. ESOPs help startups motivate and retain employees for the long run. Employees have a sense of ownership and see potential upside if the startup succeeds. This financial incentive makes them more likely to stick around even during difficult periods. ESOPs align employee incentives with the company's growth.

ii. Employees

By providing equity, startups motivate employees to work hard and contribute to the company's success. Employees go above and beyond when they feel invested in the startup's mission and growth potential. ESOPs make employees think and act like owners, driving them to help the company succeed. The potential for wealth creation further fuels employee motivation.

iii. Align Incentives

ESOPs help align incentives between employees and the startup. Employees who get equity aim to increase the company's value since their own compensation is tied to it. This alignment ensures employees make decisions that help the startup's valuation rather than focus on short-term gains. The result is a sense of shared purpose and vision.

In summary, ESOPs are a key strategic tool for startups to attract, retain and motivate top talent while aligning employee incentives with the company's growth and value creation. The equity compensation model has become deeply ingrained in the startup culture.

Taxation of ESOPs in India

The taxation of ESOPs (Employee Stock Option Plans) in India is governed by the Income Tax Act, 1961. There are specific tax rules and benefits applicable to ESOPs:

• ESOPs are taxed as a perquisite or income from salary. The value of the perquisite is the fair market value (FMV) of the shares on the date of vesting, minus the exercise price paid by the employee. This amount is added to the employee's income and taxed according to their tax slab.
• Long term capital gains (LTCG) tax is applicable if the shares are sold after 2 years from the date of vesting. LTCG tax is charged at 20% (plus surcharge and cess) on the gains made above Rs 1 lakh in a financial year.
• Short term capital gains (STCG) tax is applicable if the shares are sold within 2 years from vesting date. STCG is added to total taxable income and taxed as per the employee's tax slab.
• At the time of sale, while calculating capital gains, the cost of acquisition is considered as the FMV on the date of vesting, and not the exercise price. This reduces the capital gains amount.
• The employer can claim deductions on the ESOP perquisite value. The maximum deduction allowed is Rs 3 lakh per employee per year.
• Employees can claim deductions under Section 80CCD(2) of up to 10% of basic salary on the amount contributed to exercise ESOPs.
• No tax is required to be paid at the time of grant of ESOPs. Tax is only applicable at the time of vesting and sale.
• If ESOPs are allotted by an eligible startup, the employee can claim tax benefits under Section 80-IAC of the Income Tax Act.

So in summary, ESOPs provide beneficial tax treatment for employees and startups in India, encouraging their wider adoption. The tax rules incentivize long term holding and promote ESOPs as an employee retention and wealth creation tool.

Challenges with ESOPs in India

Employee stock option plans (ESOPs) are a popular way for startups in India to attract and retain talent. However, there are some unique challenges that Indian startups face with implementing ESOPs effectively:

• Lack of clarity in regulations - The regulatory framework around ESOPs in India is still evolving. Companies have to comply with multiple regulations like Companies Act, SEBI guidelines, RBI rules, FEMA norms etc. Often these regulations are ambiguous on certain aspects of ESOPs like valuation, taxation, buyer restrictions etc. leading to confusion for companies.
• Liquidity issues - The biggest complaint about ESOPs is their lack of liquidity. To convert ESOPs to cash, employees have to wait for an exit event like IPO or acquisition. However, in India, the number of IPOs and acquisitions are much lower compared to countries like the US. This makes ESOPs less attractive for employees who may have to wait many years to liquidate their shares.
• Compliance and administration - Managing and administering ESOPs involves complex compliance requirements like shareholder approvals, audits, filings etc. Lack of clarity in regulations further complicates this. Startups need specialized legal and finance teams to handle ESOP compliance, which raises costs.
• Taxation complexities - ESOPs are taxed both at grant and at exit in India. The calculation of tax involves factoring in variables like exercise price, fair market value etc. Lack of guidelines on ESOP valuation leads to tax complexities. Employees also suffer dual taxation on ESOP gains.
• Limited participation - Typically, ESOPs in India are concentrated among senior management and key talents. Participation among rank and file employees is very low. Broad-based ESOP plans are rare due to regulatory restrictions on the number of eligible employees. This limits the motivation aspect of ESOPs.

Despite these limitations, ESOPs remain an important talent retention tool for Indian startups. However, regulators need to provide more clarity and flexibility to make ESOPs more effective. Simplifying compliance and taxation norms for ESOP will go a long way in boosting their adoption in India.

Best Practices for ESOPs

When implementing an ESOP plan, startups should follow certain best practices to ensure it is fair, motivating, and aligned with the company's goals. Some key best practices include:

a. Vesting Schedules

• Vesting schedules should be appropriately long (4+ years) to incentivize employee retention and performance over an extended period.
• Annual vesting is better than cliff vesting, as it rewards employees incrementally each year.
• Accelerated vesting can be used for specific events like acquisitions or IPOs to allow more employees to benefit.

b. Fair Valuation

• External valuations should be conducted regularly to determine fair share prices, avoiding arbitrary valuations by founders.
• The valuation methodology should be clearly explained and reasonable. Using discounted cash flow, comparable trades, or VC-based valuations are recommended approaches.

c. Clear Policies

• The eligibility criteria, grant size, vesting schedule, exercise process, and other terms should be clearly documented and communicated.
• Policies should outline how ESOPs are treated during different scenarios like termination, leave of absence, mergers, etc.
• Having clear policies prevents confusion and perceived unfairness in ESOP administration.

By implementing longer vesting, fair pricing, and transparent policies, startups can ensure their ESOP plans are equitable and serve their purpose of attracting, retaining, and motivating talent.

ESOP Alternatives

ESOPs are not the only way for startups to provide equity compensation. Some alternatives include:

a. Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)

RSUs represent the right to receive company stock in the future. Unlike ESOPs, RSUs have some key differences:

• RSUs do not require the employee to purchase the stock. The stock is granted to them for free or as part of their compensation.
• RSUs often vest over time like ESOPs, but the employee owns the shares outright after vesting, while ESOPs must be exercised.
• RSUs avoid the complexities and costs of setting up an ESOP plan.
• RSUs are taxed as income when they vest.

For employees, RSUs avoid the risks of buying stock options that may end up underwater if the valuation declines. The tradeoff is they do not benefit from an increase in valuation like ESOPs.

b. Phantom Stock

Phantom stock provides the benefits of owning stock without actual ownership. Employees are assigned a specific number of phantom shares. If the company's value appreciates, the phantom shares increase in value. Upon exit or IPO, the appreciation is paid out in cash rather than stock.

Benefits of phantom stock:

• Avoids dilution of shares like ESOPs
• Cash payouts rather than illiquid stock
• Can be tied to performance metrics

Downsides include no voting rights or dividends, and payout depends on exit events. Overall, phantom stock can provide equity-like incentives without ownership.

c. Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)

SARs are similar to stock options, but employees receive cash payments equivalent to the increase in stock value rather than actual stock. SARs avoid dilution and provide cash incentives tied to stock growth. Downsides are they do not provide equity ownership.

For startups, alternatives like RSUs, phantom stock, and SARs allow more flexibility in equity compensation. Each method has tradeoffs to consider against traditional ESOPs. Globally, these alternatives are growing in popularity alongside ESOPs.

Case Studies of ESOPs

Employee stock option plans (ESOPs) have been quite popular amongst Indian startups as an employee incentive and retention strategy. Here are some examples of Indian startups that have successfully implemented ESOPs:

• Ola Cabs: The ride-hailing startup Ola has issued ESOPs to over 3,000 employees amounting to around 3 percent of the company. Several senior executives have gained handsomely from selling their vested ESOP shares during later funding rounds.
• Flipkart: The ecommerce giant Flipkart has relied heavily on ESOPs right from its early days to hire and retain talented employees. During its acquisition by Walmart in 2018, more than 100 Flipkart employees became crorepatis by cashing in their ESOPs.
• Zomato: The food delivery unicorn Zomato has utilized ESOPs widely, with its employee stock option pool standing at around 6.5 percent currently. Several senior executives and early employees earned millions of dollars by trading their ESOPs.
• Swiggy: The arch rival of Zomato, food delivery startup Swiggy has also offered ESOPs to over 1,200 employees. Many earned handsome rewards during the company's fundraises from Prosus Ventures and others.
• Freshworks: The SaaS startup Freshworks has strongly emphasized ESOPs as a key talent acquisition and retention strategy right from its early days. Several employees turned millionaires after the company's NASDAQ listing in 2021.
• BrowserStack: The software testing platform BrowserStack has relied on ESOPs to attract top tech talent globally. Its ESOP buybacks have created huge wealth for early employees before the company's eventual acquisition.

The success of ESOPs in these leading Indian startups underscores how effective they can be for attracting talent and aligning employee incentives with company growth.

Global Perspective on ESOPs

Employee stock option plans (ESOPs) are a popular way for startups worldwide to attract and retain talent. Here is an overview of how ESOPs are utilized and regulated in major startup ecosystems beyond India:

a. United States

• ESOPs emerged in the 1950s as a way for companies to incentivize employees and align their interests with shareholders. Many of today's largest tech companies like Microsoft, Apple, and Google used ESOPs to great effect in their early years.
• ESOPs receive beneficial tax treatment in the US. Employees pay no tax when options are granted or exercised, just when the stock is eventually sold. This defers taxation and encourages long-term holdings.
• Strict securities regulations govern how private company ESOPs are administered to protect participants. Companies must register ESOP plans, share educational materials, allow option exercise periods, and avoid repricing underwater options.

b. China

• ESOPs are increasingly popular among Chinese startups and tech giants like Alibaba, Tencent, and Bytedance. However, the practice is still relatively new compared to the US.
• Chinese ESOP regulations are less mature than in Western countries. Tax rules, participant rights, and plan administration standards remain uneven. Problems like unfair option repricing are common.
• The Chinese government has increased scrutiny of ESOP practices to balance startup funding needs with worker protections. More guidance and guardrails are likely as the industry matures.

c. Europe

• ESOP use varies widely across Europe. Tax incentives are often less favorable than the US, hampering adoption. Countries like France have promoted alternative equity compensation schemes instead.
• EU regulations like GDPR and rules against repricing can make administering stock options complex. Startups must navigate differences between countries' ESOP policies.
• However, stock options are still a vital recruiting tool for leading tech hubs like London, Berlin, and Stockholm. The EU's scale-up environment may drive greater ESOP adoption long-term.

Future of ESOPs in India

The future of ESOPs in India looks promising with expected policy reforms and new trends emerging. The government has shown an interest in making ESOP policies more favorable for startups to aid their growth. Some expected reforms include:

• Relaxing taxation rules on ESOPs to reduce the burden on employees at the time of exercise. There are recommendations to only tax ESOPs at the time of sale of shares rather than at exercise.
• Allowing ESOPs to be offered to consultants and advisors of startups in addition to employees. Currently, ESOP benefits are limited to employees.
• Simplifying compliance requirements related to ESOP administration and filings.
• Providing more flexibility in structuring of ESOP plans, such as introducing stock appreciation rights.
• Allowing ESOPs to be offered earlier in a startup's lifecycle, rather than waiting for 3 years.
• Introducing incentives or deductions for employees holding ESOPs to encourage more startup employees to accept ESOPs as part of compensation.

In addition to policy reforms, some emerging trends shaping the future of ESOPs are:

• Startups moving towards net exercise of ESOPs to reduce burden on employees.
• Introduction of phantom stock option plans and other ESOP alternatives to provide benefits to a wider pool of contributors.
• More structured vesting schedules and early exercise options in ESOP contracts.
• ESOP buybacks emerging as an attractive exit option for employees in absence of IPOs.
• Increased focus on ESOP education among startup employees regarding valuation and liquidity.

With supportive policies and evolving best practices, ESOPs are likely to continue gaining prominence as an integral compensation component for Indian startups.

Subscribe this newsletter and follow Legal Suvidha? and First Unicorn ?? ? to get more updates about exciting startups where you can invest and if you are a startup having a great vision/mission and solving a big problem connect with us for funding opportunities.

?

If you are planning to launch your Startup, read my Free e-book here: https://growsocio.com/product/e-book-launch-like-a-pro-the-mvp-method-for-startup-success/