UN-supervised plebiscites, the Kashmir Question, and trade restrictions
Michael Horlick, MPM, M Ed., PMP
Educator, Lexicographer, and Incurable Idealist
?Terms to note from today’s PRC Ministry of Foreign Affairs press conference:
- å°±èŒä»ªå¼? [jiù zhà yà shì]? inauguration ceremony:?
Today’s quote:
åº”é˜¿æ ¹å»·æ”¿åºœé‚€è¯·ï¼Œä¹ è¿‘å¹³ä¸»å¸ç‰¹ä½¿ã€å…¨å›½äººå¤§å¸¸å§”会副委员长æ¦ç»´åŽèµ´é˜¿æ ¹å»·é¦–都布宜诺斯艾利斯出å¸ç±³èŽ±æ€»ç»Ÿå°±èŒä»ªå¼ã€‚11日,米莱总统会è§æ¦ç»´åŽã€‚æ¦ç»´åŽå‘ç±³èŽ±è½¬è¾¾äº†ä¹ è¿‘å¹³ä¸»å¸çš„çƒçƒˆç¥è´ºå’Œè‰¯å¥½ç¥æ„¿ã€‚ç±³èŽ±æ„Ÿè°¢ä¹ è¿‘å¹³ä¸»å¸æ´¾ç‰¹ä½¿å‡ºå¸å°±èŒä»ªå¼ï¼Œè¯·æ¦ç»´åŽè½¬è¾¾ä»–å¯¹ä¹ è¿‘å¹³ä¸»å¸çš„诚挚问候和良好ç¥æ„¿ï¼Œå¼ºè°ƒé˜¿æ ¹å»·æ–°æ”¿åºœé«˜åº¦é‡è§†é˜¿ä¸å…³ç³»ï¼Œå°†ç»§ç»åšå®šå¥‰è¡Œä¸€ä¸ªä¸å›½åŽŸåˆ™ï¼Œé˜¿æ–¹æ„¿è¿›ä¸€æ¥ä¿ƒè¿›ä¸¤å›½ç»è´¸ã€äººæ–‡ç‰å„领域交æµåˆä½œæ·±å…¥å‘展。?
At the invitation of the government of Argentina, President Xi Jinping’s Special Envoy and Vice Chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress Wu Weihua attended the inauguration of President of Argentina Javier Milei in Argentina’s capital Buenos Aires. On December 11, President Javier Milei met with Wu Weihua. Wu Weihua extended President Xi Jinping’s warm congratulations and best wishes to President Javier Milei. President Javier Milei thanked President Xi for sending the special envoy to attend his inauguration, and asked Vice Chairman Wu to extend his sincere greetings and best wishes to President Xi. He stressed that the new government of Argentina attaches high importance to its relations with China and will continue to firmly follow the one-China principle and the Argentine side stands ready to further promote the in-depth exchanges and cooperation between the two countries in various fields including economy and trade and cultural and people-to-people exchanges.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on December 12, 2023)?
Previous PRC history of the term:
?? 应土耳其共和国政府邀请,国家主å¸ä¹ 近平特使ã€å…¨å›½äººå¤§å¸¸å§”会副委员长ä¸ä»²ç¤¼å°†èµ´åœŸè€³å…¶ï¼Œå‡ºå¸6月3日在安å¡æ‹‰ä¸¾è¡Œçš„埃尔多安总统就èŒä»ªå¼ã€‚?
At the invitation of the government of the Republic of Türkiye, Ding Zhongli, President Xi Jinping’s special envoy and Vice Chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress (NPC), will attend President Recep Tayyip Erdo?an’s inauguration ceremony in Ankara on June 3 [2023].? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on June 2, 2023)?
?? åº”å·´è¥¿æ”¿åºœé‚€è¯·ï¼Œä¹ è¿‘å¹³ä¸»å¸ç‰¹åˆ«ä»£è¡¨ã€å›½å®¶å‰¯ä¸»å¸çŽ‹å²å±±åœ¨å·´è¥¿é¦–都巴西利亚出å¸å·´è¥¿æ–°ä»»æ€»ç»Ÿå¢æ‹‰å°±èŒä»ªå¼å¹¶åŒå¢æ‹‰æ€»ç»Ÿä¸¾è¡Œä¼šè§ã€‚?
At the invitation of the Brazilian government, Chinese President Xi Jinping’s Special Representative Vice President Wang Qishan attended the inauguration ceremony of Brazil’s new President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and met with him in Brasilia, capital of Brazil.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on January 4, 2023)
- 克什米尔问题? [kè shén mÇ Ä›r wèn tÃ]? Kashmir question; Kashmir issue:?
Today’s quote:
在克什米尔问题上,ä¸æ–¹çš„立场是一贯的,也是明确的。这一问题是å°å·´ä¸¤å›½ä¹‹é—´çš„历å²é—ç•™é—®é¢˜ï¼Œåº”è¯¥æ ¹æ®ã€Šè”åˆå›½å®ªç« 》ã€å®‰ç†ä¼šå†³è®®å’Œæœ‰å…³åŒè¾¹å定的规定,以和平方å¼å¦¥å–„解决。有关方é¢åº”当åšæŒé€šè¿‡å¯¹è¯å商解决有关争议,维护地区和平稳定。?
China’s position on the Kashmir issue is consistent and clear-cut. The Kashmir issue, left from the past, needs to be resolved peacefully and appropriately in accordance with the UN Charter, Security Council resolutions and relevant bilateral agreement. Parties concerned need to settle the dispute through dialogue and consultation so as to maintain regional peace and stability.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on December 12, 2023)?
Previous PRC history of the term:
?? ä¸æ–¹åœ¨å…‹ä»€ç±³å°”问题上的立场是一贯和明确的。这一问题是å°å·´ä¸¤å›½é—´çš„历å²é—ç•™é—®é¢˜ï¼Œåº”è¯¥æ ¹æ®ã€Šè”åˆå›½å®ªç« 》ã€å®‰ç†ä¼šå†³è®®å’Œæœ‰å…³åŒè¾¹å定的规定,以和平方å¼å¦¥å–„解决。有关方é¢åº”é¿å…å•è¾¹è¡ŒåŠ¨é€ æˆå±€åŠ¿å¤æ‚化,应通过对è¯å商解决有关争议,维护地区和平稳定。?
China’s position on the Kashmir issue is consistent and clear-cut. The Kashmir issue, a dispute left from the past, needs to be resolved peacefully and appropriately in accordance with the UN Charter, Security Council resolutions and relevant bilateral agreement. Parties concerned need to avoid unilateral moves that may complicate the situation. Efforts should be made to settle the dispute through dialogue and consultation so as to maintain regional peace and stability.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on October 27, 2022)
- 贸易ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰? [mà o yì bÇŽo hù zhÇ” yì]? trade protectionism:?
Today’s quote:
贸易ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰ä¸åˆ©äºŽå•†å“ã€æœåŠ¡ã€èµ„本ç‰è¦ç´ 的自由æµåŠ¨ï¼Œæ‰æ›²èµ„æºé…置,æŸå®³æ¶ˆè´¹è€…利益,ä¸åˆ©äºŽæ高生产效率,ä¸åˆ©äºŽä¸–ç•Œç»æµŽçš„å¤è‹å’Œå‘展。令人担忧的是,一些国家以安全为借å£æžâ€œè„±é’©æ–链â€ï¼Œæ‰“ç€â€œåŽ»é£Žé™©â€çš„æ——å·æžè´¸æ˜“é™åˆ¶ï¼Œè¿™åªä¼šè®©ä¸–界更ä¸å®‰å…¨ï¼Œåªä¼šå¸¦æ¥æ›´å¤šé£Žé™©ã€‚?
Trade protectionism is not conducive to the free flow of factors including goods, services and capital, distorts resource allocation, and undermines consumers’ interests. It does no good to the production efficiency and the recovery and development of the world economy. What is concerning is that some countries have been pushing for decoupling and severing of supply chains under the pretext of security, and imposing trade restriction measures in the name of “de-riskingâ€. This will only make the world even less safe and bring more risks.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on December 12, 2023)?
领英推è
Previous PRC history of the term:
?? 我愿强调,ä¸æ–¹ä¸€è´¯å对å„ç§å½¢å¼çš„贸易ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰ã€‚欧盟方é¢æ‹Ÿé‡‡å–的有关措施ä¸åˆ©äºŽå…¨çƒæ±½è½¦äº§ä¸šé“¾ä¾›åº”链稳定,ä¸ç¬¦åˆä»»ä½•ä¸€æ–¹åˆ©ç›Šã€‚ä¸æ–¹æ•¦ä¿ƒæ¬§ç›Ÿä»Žç»´æŠ¤å…¨çƒäº§ä¸šé“¾ä¾›åº”链稳定以åŠä¸æ¬§å…¨é¢æˆ˜ç•¥ä¼™ä¼´å…³ç³»çš„大局出å‘,与ä¸æ–¹å¼€å±•å¯¹è¯ç£‹å•†ï¼Œä¸ºä¸æ¬§ç”µåŠ¨æ±½è½¦äº§ä¸šå…±åŒå‘å±•åˆ›é€ å…¬å¹³ã€éžæ§è§†ã€å¯é¢„期的市场环境,共åŒå对贸易ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰ã€‚?
I would like to stress that China opposes all forms of trade protectionism. The action that the EU plans to take will disrupt the stability of global auto industrial and supply chains and will not serve anyone’s interests. China urges the EU to bear in mind the importance of the stability of global industrial and supply chains and the China-EU comprehensive strategic partnership, engage in dialogue and consultation with China, work with China to create a fair, non-discriminatory and predictable market environment for Chinese and European electric vehicle industries and jointly oppose trade protectionism.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on September 25, 2023)?
?? 为了é制美国的贸易ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰è¡Œä¸ºï¼Œå…¶ä»–国家ä¸å¾—ä¸é‡‡å–å制措施,这将导致全çƒç»è´¸ç§©åºç´Šä¹±ï¼Œé˜»ç¢å…¨çƒç»æµŽå¤è‹ï¼Œæ®ƒåŠä¸–ç•Œå„国ä¼ä¸šå’Œå±…民,使全çƒç»æµŽè½å…¥â€œè¡°é€€é™·é˜±â€.?
In order to mitigate the protectionist moves of the US, countries are left with no choice but to take countermeasures. This will disrupt the world economic and trade order, and hold back global recovery, damaging the interests of companies and people of all countries and pushing the global economy back into recession? (White_Paper_Facts and China’s Position on China-US Trade Friction_《关于ä¸ç¾Žç»è´¸æ‘©æ“¦çš„事实与ä¸æ–¹ç«‹åœºã€‹_2018_09_24)?
?? 截至2018å¹´7月底,包括ä¸å›½ã€åŠ 拿大ã€å¢¨è¥¿å“¥ã€ä¿„ç½—æ–¯ã€æ¬§ç›Ÿã€åœŸè€³å…¶åœ¨å†…的美国主è¦è´¸æ˜“伙伴å‡å·²å®£å¸ƒå¯¹å…¶è´¸æ˜“ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰æŽªæ–½å®žæ–½å制,并相继通过世界贸易组织æ起诉讼。?
As of the end of July 2018, major US trading partners including China, Canada, Mexico, Russia, the EU and Turkey had all announced countermeasures against US trade protectionism, and had filed lawsuits at the WTO.? (White_Paper_Facts and China’s Position on China-US Trade Friction_《关于ä¸ç¾Žç»è´¸æ‘©æ“¦çš„事实与ä¸æ–¹ç«‹åœºã€‹_2018_09_24)?
?? 尽管å•è¾¹ä¸»ä¹‰ã€è´¸æ˜“ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰ã€é€†å…¨çƒåŒ–æ€æ½®ä¸æ–有新的表现,但“地çƒæ‘â€çš„世界决定了å„国日益利益交èžã€å‘½è¿ä¸Žå…±ï¼Œåˆä½œå…±èµ¢æ˜¯å¤§åŠ¿æ‰€è¶‹ã€‚?
While unilateralism, trade protectionism and backlash against globalization are taking new forms, in this global village of ours where countries' interests and future are so interconnected, the pursuit of cooperation for mutual benefit represents a surging trend.? (Xi Jinping_Carrying Forward the Shanghai Spirit to Build a Community with a Shared Future_弘扬上海精神构建命è¿å…±åŒä½“_2018_6_10æ—¥)
- 贸易é™åˆ¶? [mà o yì xià n zhì]? trade restriction:?
贸易ä¿æŠ¤ä¸»ä¹‰ä¸åˆ©äºŽå•†å“ã€æœåŠ¡ã€èµ„本ç‰è¦ç´ 的自由æµåŠ¨ï¼Œæ‰æ›²èµ„æºé…置,æŸå®³æ¶ˆè´¹è€…利益,ä¸åˆ©äºŽæ高生产效率,ä¸åˆ©äºŽä¸–ç•Œç»æµŽçš„å¤è‹å’Œå‘展。令人担忧的是,一些国家以安全为借å£æžâ€œè„±é’©æ–链â€ï¼Œæ‰“ç€â€œåŽ»é£Žé™©â€çš„æ——å·æžè´¸æ˜“é™åˆ¶ï¼Œè¿™åªä¼šè®©ä¸–界更ä¸å®‰å…¨ï¼Œåªä¼šå¸¦æ¥æ›´å¤šé£Žé™©ã€‚?
Trade protectionism is not conducive to the free flow of factors including goods, services and capital, distorts resource allocation, and undermines consumers’ interests. It does no good to the production efficiency and the recovery and development of the world economy. What is concerning is that some countries have been pushing for decoupling and severing of supply chains under the pretext of security, and imposing trade restriction measures in the name of “de-riskingâ€. This will only make the world even less safe and bring more risks.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on December 12, 2023)?
Previous PRC history of the term:
?? 自1992年起,è”åˆå›½å¤§ä¼šå·²è¿žç»30次以压倒性多数通过“终æ¢ç¾Žå›½å¯¹å¤å·´çš„ç»æµŽã€å•†ä¸šå’Œé‡‘èžå°é”â€å†³è®®ã€‚... 美方应当认真倾å¬å›½é™…社会的æ£ä¹‰å£°éŸ³ï¼Œç«‹å³ç»ˆæ¢å¯¹å¤å·´çš„ç»æµŽã€å•†ä¸šå’Œè´¸æ˜“é™åˆ¶åŠå°é”。?
Since 1992, for 30 consecutive times, the UN General Assembly has adopted with overwhelming majority a resolution calling for an end to the economic, commercial and financial embargo imposed on Cuba by the US.? ... This should prompt the US to listen and respond to the international community’s call for justice and put an immediate end to the economic, commercial and trade restrictions and embargo on Cuba.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on October 30, 2023)?
?? 185票的压倒性结果å†æ¬¡è¡¨æ˜Žï¼Œä¸–界上ç»å¤§å¤šæ•°å›½å®¶éƒ½å¯¹ç¾Žå›½æ»¥æ–½å•è¾¹åˆ¶è£ã€ä¸¥é‡å¨èƒå¤å·´äººæ°‘基本人æƒçš„行径表示严é‡å…³åˆ‡å’Œåšå†³å对,都支æŒå¤æ–¹ç»´æŠ¤ä¸»æƒã€å对å°é”çš„æ£ä¹‰æ–—争。 ... é¢å¯¹è”åˆå›½å¤§ä¼šè¿žç»30次以压倒性多数通过的决议,美方应该åšçš„是认真倾å¬æ£ä¹‰å£°éŸ³ï¼Œç«‹å³ç»ˆæ¢å¯¹å¤å·´çš„ç»æµŽã€å•†ä¸šå’Œè´¸æ˜“é™åˆ¶ã€å°é”,ä¸è¦å†ç»§ç»ç«™åœ¨å›½é™…社会的对立é¢ã€‚?
The fact that 185 countries voted overwhelmingly in favor of the resolution once again shows that the vast majority of countries in the world are seriously concerned about and firmly opposed to the US arbitrary unilateral sanctions on Cuba that have gravely threatened the basic human rights of the Cuban people, and that they support Cuba’s just fight for its sovereignty and against the blockade. ... This should prompt the US to heed the voice for justice, put an immediate end to the economic, commercial and trade embargo on Cuba, and stop being on the wrong side against the international community.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on November 4, 2022)
- 全民表决? [quán mÃn biÇŽo jué]? plebiscite; referendum:?
12月11日,å°åº¦æœ€é«˜æ³•é™¢è£å®šæ”¯æŒå°åº¦æ”¿åºœå•æ–¹é¢æ”¹å˜æŸ¥è°Ÿå’Œå…‹ä»€ç±³å°”地区地ä½çš„决定。这明显è¿å了è”åˆå›½å®‰ç†ä¼šç¬¬122å·å†³è®®å…³äºŽæŸ¥è°Ÿå’Œå…‹ä»€ç±³å°”问题åªèƒ½é€šè¿‡è”åˆå›½ç›‘ç£çš„全民表决æ¥æœ€ç»ˆè§£å†³çš„规定。?
On December 11 [2023], Indian Supreme Court announced a decision endorsing the Indian government’s unilateral step to change the status of Jammu and Kashmir region, which is a clear violation of UNSC Resolution 122 which decided that the final settlement of the Jammu and Kashmir issue can only take place by UN-supervised plebiscite.? (Foreign Ministry Regular Press Conference on December 12, 2023)
Read in parallel: https://tinyurl.com/5352rhfk