Twenty-Fourth Anniversary of the Riverdale Synagogue Arson Attempt: A Stark Reminder of Hate Crime’s Lingering Threats

October 8th, 2024, marks the twenty-fourth anniversary of the attempted arson of the Conservative Synagogue Adath Israel of Riverdale in the Bronx, New York. This anniversary is more than a remembrance; it is a chilling reminder of the ever-present threat of hate-driven violence that continues to haunt our society. This event was not just an attack on a religious institution—it was an early test of New York's resolve to combat hate crime, as it was the first case prosecuted under the newly minted New York State Hate Crime Law.

The attack in 2000, carried out by four young men with little or no prior criminal records, shook the Riverdale Jewish community to its core. Their motivation was ignited at an anti-Israel rally in Times Square, where emotions ran high over the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The young men attended the rally and, shortly after, made a decision that would forever alter their lives—and the lives of many others. Armed with Molotov cocktails, they sought to target the synagogue on the eve of Yom Kippur, one of the holiest days in the Jewish calendar.

As part of the investigative team that made these arrests, I saw firsthand how swiftly these men went from ordinary citizens to perpetrators of violence. It wasn't simply premeditation that led them to act, but a mob mentality stoked by heated rhetoric and inflamed passions. In the aftermath of that night, we saw how fragile the line can be between protest and violence, between political expression and hatred.

This case not only marked the first prosecution under New York’s Hate Crime Law but also set a precedent for how the city and state would handle such crimes. The law, designed to address the growing trend of bias-motivated violence, gave the justice system new tools to impose stricter penalties on those who commit crimes motivated by prejudice. But laws alone, as we learned, do not extinguish the fires of hatred.

Fast forward to 2024, and I find myself once again witnessing the same troubling dynamics. Yesterday, a pro-Palestinian rally in Times Square drew thousands of New Yorkers, highlighting the deeply emotional and divisive nature of the ongoing conflict in Gaza. While most protesters rallied peacefully, the underlying tensions and deep-seated anger were palpable. Twenty-four years ago, a similar rally fueled the actions of four young men who took their rage home with them, creating Molotov cocktails and planning an attack that could have resulted in devastating loss of life.

The timing of these events, then and now, is no coincidence. Radicalization and violence can thrive in environments where political rhetoric and religious conflict converge. Those who feel emboldened by the anonymity of crowds or the echo chamber of like-minded anger can easily be drawn into destructive acts. What is particularly striking about the Riverdale case is that the perpetrators had no extensive criminal backgrounds. They were, by all accounts, ordinary young men whose hatred was stoked in the heat of a moment, long after the crowds had dispersed.

In the 24 years since that incident, I have investigated numerous cases involving arsons at religious institutions—churches, mosques, and synagogues. Unfortunately, the majority of these targeted Jewish communities. These incidents serve as a troubling barometer of societal divisions that persist. Synagogues have long been a target for hate, often seen as a symbol of the Jewish faith and, more broadly, of issues tied to global conflicts, especially in the Middle East.

What should give all New Yorkers pause is that we are a city defined by our diversity. We are home to people of every religion, ethnicity, and political persuasion. The very institutions that foster such a mosaic—the United Nations, foreign embassies, countless religious centers—are reminders that we are interconnected. The violence in Gaza, Israel, or anywhere else in the world should not manifest as hate on our streets.

The memory of the Riverdale synagogue attack is a solemn warning. As New Yorkers, we must be vigilant in preventing the spread of the very hatred that has torn apart so many other parts of the world. This requires not just law enforcement but also community leadership, education, and interfaith solidarity. We cannot afford to let the embers of extremism ignite once more.

While we remember the horrors of twenty-four years ago, we must also reflect on the responsibilities we have today. The past is never truly behind us if we fail to learn from it. If history is any guide, it teaches us that hatred, when left unchecked, knows no boundaries.

On this anniversary, let us honor those who stood against hate and violence, and let us commit ourselves to ensuring that New York’s "beautiful mosaic" remains unbroken, unshaken by the darkness that hate seeks to bring.

?