The Truth About Interviews
James Caan CBE
Recruitment Entrepreneur Chairman | Serial Entrepreneur | Investor on BBC's Dragons’ Den (2007-2010)
It's a common misconception that an interview should have a question-answer structure. Take my word for it - I’ve been working in the recruitment industry for over 30 years now. Having met literally thousands of candidates over this period, I’ve spotted a few patterns. The best interviews are always a two-way street. In an interview, you need to ask questions at every opportunity. It’s not an exam, it’s an exchange.
You should hear your own voice just as much as you hear the interviewers. Don’t be afraid to speak up: a fluid, dynamic conversation will impress any employer - it will tell them that you are confident, that you are knowledgeable and, most of all, that you will be someone they’d like to work with. Nobody wants a robot for a colleague.
There are an infinite number of questions you could ask. If you’ve done sufficient research, you can trust that they will come readily. At that point, you can afford to be selective. Don’t ask the generic questions that everybody else will - about the company structure, the challenges of the role, the potential career path etc. If you’ve done your homework, you will know the answers to these already. Instead, use your knowledge as a springboard to ask something a little more nuanced, for instance:
1. What are your experiences within the company? As an interviewer, what qualities do you look for that you personally feel fit into the organisation?
2. What successes have other employees with similar backgrounds to me had in the company? How have their experiences played out to their advantage?
If you’re struggling to think of something outside of the box, make it simple: what information couldn’t you get on the internet?
One of the best questions I ever received as an interviewer was what they could do better than their predecessor. This kind of specific, constructive question will not only help you in your performance should you get the job, but shows that you are forward thinking and proactive.
So, asking the right questions will allow you to show yourself in the best light. It will allow you to demonstrate qualities that can’t just be talked about - no employer is going to ask you if you are proactive, you simply have to show them. In my experience, I consistently find that candidates that stand their ground in an interview have the most success.
This is not only because, at the most basic level, it shows that they have something to say, but because it means they have enough words to make their case. You have to create your own opportunities in interviews - clear a space for your true colours to shine through.
What’s the best question you’ve ever asked or been asked in an interview?
--
5 年c
Administrative Assistant at Arthur J. Gallagher & Co.
5 年Interviewers, as well as interviewees(Person applying for?a position)?are both seeing if the interviewer wants the interviewee as well as if the interviewee wants to work for their company.? I have turned down several because I did not care for the interviewers.? I thought they were not open minded and a?poor representation?of their company!
Experienced Senior Living Executive Director-Retired
5 年One question I like to ask is, If you could be one animal, what would it be and why. It kind of gets them to step out of that shell.
Experienced Programme manager
5 年I find that a two-way conversation, whilst revealing for both the candidate and the panel, also benefits from having a structure.? My successful interview last week (I start on Monday) saw me bringing a four-slide presentation on a nominated subject whilst the two interviewers had a set of structured questions, to which they needed to obtain answers.? As it happened, they commented part-way through that my presentation - and the conversation - was answering quite a few of their questions ahead of the "structured" part of the interview. ? So, whilst I would not be hide-bound in prescribing a specific "do or don't" structure for an interview, intelligent human beings are usually able to glean what they need from other humans by conversation - aided by a structure of some sort. It's an approach which has worked well for me - both as candidate and interviewer - over the past few decades.
Zero fluff job search advice | Career Coach | Former HR Director | INSEAD MBA | Keynote Speaker | Podcaster | Helped clients negotiate 30-300% salary increase | LinkedIn Top Voice 2024
5 年Great article! I've interviewed literally thousands of pepple, and I always start the meeting with, "This is a chat to get to know each other and see if there is a fit with the position'. People are almost always instantly put at ease when I use the word 'chat'.? My favourite question to ask a candidate is 'why are you the right person for this position' because I need to know if they can sell. Convince. Influence.? When I'm a candidate, I enjoy asking? the interviewer: 'What are the two best things you love about your job'. Tells you a lot about them AND the organisation.