Trust and Deception: Lessons from the BBC’s 'The Traitors' on Corporate Insider Threats

The dramatic landscape of the Scottish Highlands provides the backdrop for a recent BBC reality hit: The Traitors.? Set in a baronial castle and evoking the suspense-charged atmosphere of a Harlen Coben crime thriller, a tournament of competing motives unfolds.?

Contestants, known as “Faithfuls” and “Traitors”, vie for a hefty cash prize. All profess to be a Faithful, but a small number among them—secretly appointed by the show’s host, the captivating Claudia Winkleman—are nothing of the sort.? They are the Traitors and their job is to “murder” their fellow contestants, without their true intentions ever being discovered.? They must sow seeds of doubt towards the innocent and keep suspicion off their backs.? The Faithfuls, on the other hand, must quietly identify their enemies without drawing attention or being too successful.? And in a further twist, Traitors are sometimes allowed to recruit from within.? They can approach a Faithful in an attempt to turn them.? Sometimes they agree; other times they reject the offer, such is their loyalty to their fellow Faithfuls.

Victory hinges on whether the Faithfuls can identify and eliminate all Traitors before the game’s end, winning and splitting the bounty.? But if any of the Traitors evade detection, they take the lot, leaving the Faithfuls empty-handed.

Beyond the threat of betrayal, there are tough physical and mental challenges that all participants, no matter their secret plans, face together.? These are not simply tests of strength or intellect, but crucial opportunities to add to the prize pot.? And it is within these trials that a unique form of protection emerges: the shield.? This prized charm offers a night’s protection from the Traitors’ execution order.? A chance for a lucky Faithful to sleep soundly, as each night spent in the castle is (mostly) another chance to kill off an unshielded Faithful.??

But prior to the “killing” (committed by pen on paper; not knife on neck), the whole group must first convene at a large roundtable to air their suspicions.? Accusations are made, defences are given, and then everyone reflects privately.? This ends in an opportunity to “banish”, by individual vote, the person judged most likely to be a Traitor.? Of course, the only ones among them who know for certain, are the forked-tongued Traitors.

Drawing Parallels Between 'The Traitors' and Insider Threats

While just entertainment, The Traitors mirrors real life closely: betrayal and lies clash with loyalty and judgement.? The castle’s labyrinth corridors and secretive nooks provide the perfect stage for this strategic skirmish, where only the smartest or most insightful will win.

But through the lens of this show (a personal guilty pleasure…), we can peek at the parallels between the game’s mechanics and the real-world corporate challenge of managing insider threats.? In The Traitors, the interplay of schemers, strategies and secrets is much like the world of business, where it’s hard to tell friends from enemies, and what's at risk is often more than just money.

Trust vs. Betrayal: Insights from 'The Traitors' on Unmasking Insider Threats in Business

At the very core of The Traitors lies the quest to distinguish between the sincere Faithfuls and the cunning Traitors.? The show, in essence, dramatises the eternal conflict between trust and betrayal that businesses navigate daily.? Just as Traitors blend with Faithfuls, insider threats often hide in plain sight, appearing normal and trustworthy.? An understanding of human behaviour—a skill that is both art and science—plays a big role.? And truth is, our natural ability to spot hidden motives is weak.? Take Series 1 Faithful, Tom Elderfield, for example: a “professional magician”, who “reads people for a living”.? Fully convinced of his talent to draw meaning from eye-twitches and vocal-pitch changes, he pestered and persuaded until the group acted, almost in unison, to oust children’s book author, Ivan Brett.? Alas, Tom would soon learn that Ivan was no Traitor.? And with this revelation, his dreams of becoming the next David Copperfield disappeared in a puff of smoke.?

The Role of Shields: Protective Measures in Games and Corporations

The introduction of shields in The Traitors offers players immunity from execution, a metaphor for the protective measures businesses can implement against insider threats and other adversaries.? Shields can be seen as symbolic of security policies, access controls and employee vetting and monitoring systems designed to prevent unauthorised actions.? However, just as shields in the game do not offer protection from the Banishment Vote, corporate defences are not impenetrable.? They require constant updating and adaptation to a never-static intelligence picture and evolving threats, underscoring the dynamic nature of security and risk management.

The Roundtable Discussions: Collective Wisdom and Decision-Making

The Roundtable discussions in The Traitors where players deliberate on whom to banish, highlight the importance of collective wisdom and decision-making in identifying threat and risk.? What the contestants lack is any meaningful intelligence: their deliberations are informed by bias, pop-psychology, gut-feeling and, more often than not, the opinions and manipulations of forceful personalities.? And it would be wrong to think boardroom discussions are immune from such behaviour...? But corporations act best on collaborative threat assessments, contextual understanding and defined and tested decision-making processes.??

For an effective “roundtable” discussion in the business place, picture a meeting attended by a range of departmental representatives and trusted external advisors, where information and intelligence is shared, biases are managed, and informed assessments are made, leading to prioritised, measured action plans to manage risk.??

The key lesson here is the value of information, collaboration and diverse perspectives in the collective pursuit of a common goal—security and trust.

Recruitment of Traitors: The Threat from Within

The game’s twist, where Faithfuls can be turned into Traitors, illustrates the real-world scenario of insiders being co-opted against their employer.? One lesson we can take from this is the need for emotionally intelligent leaders, ethical corporate cultures, and robust incentivisation structures to help maintain employee allegiance.? Just as players must decide whether to join the Traitors, employees may face moral dilemmas that could sway their loyalty.? Here, the corporate world can learn from the show the importance of fostering a positive work environment that minimises the allure of betrayal.

Strategies for Managing Insider Threats

The term “insider threats” often conjures up images of shadowy figures lurking within an organisation.? They are simply individuals who—whether on purpose or by accident—cause serious harm by revealing important secrets or damaging company assets.? They might be motivated by money, revenge, or simply made a mistake, but they can cause permanent harm.??

Companies can constantly enhance how they handle insider threats.? Keeping a close watch, like Faithfuls searching for Traitors, is crucial.? And building a culture of trust and transparency can discourage insiders, similar to the unity among Faithfuls.? However, it’s essential to have strong security measures, training and incident response plans in place. Businesses must be proactive in protecting their assets.?

Conclusion

The Traitors isn't just entertainment; it sheds light on corporate trust, loyalty and security.? It parallels the challenges of managing threats from within.? In the chess game of corporate security, each move must be thoughtful, considering human weaknesses and motivations.? The lessons from show serve as both a warning and guide: security is an ongoing challenge, but those who are prepared, flexible and decisive will succeed.

"Enjoyed 'Trust and Deception: Lessons from the BBC’s 'The Traitors' on Corporate Insider Threats'? Please 'Like', 'Follow' for more content, and 'Share' to spread the word.