Trucking Stocks Plunge, But Citi Sees Opportunities in Market Volatility
TruckersReport.com
The largest online community of truck drivers. 210,000+ members and 1+ million users per month.
Trucking Stocks Take a Hit Amid Market Uncertainty
A new report from Citi’s transportation analysts suggests that recent declines in trucking stocks may be exaggerated, as investors react sharply to falling trucking spot rates and ongoing macroeconomic uncertainty. Despite the volatility, Citi sees potential opportunities for investors willing to navigate the turbulence.
Spot rates in the truckload market have dropped significantly in early 2025, wiping out gains from late 2024. While seasonal trends typically explain some level of rate fluctuations, this year’s drop has been steeper than expected. Analysts cite excess trucking capacity and weaker-than-anticipated demand as major contributing factors.
Insights from the State of Freight broadcast, hosted by industry experts Craig Fuller and Zach Strickland, reinforce Citi’s findings. They note that the sharp decline in spot rates is likely due to a combination of weather disruptions and uncertainty in economic policies, rather than a fundamental collapse in demand.
Signs of Market Stabilization Despite Challenges
While the freight market still faces hurdles, Citi analysts believe that excess trucking capacity is gradually shrinking—a key step toward stabilization. However, several risks remain:
? Weak consumer spending could limit freight demand. ? Industrial production remains sluggish, impacting freight volumes. ? The broader economy shows mixed signals, potentially delaying a market rebound.
Although the industry is still recovering from what many call the “Great Freight Recession”, Citi warns that a broader economic slowdown could stall or even reverse recent gains.
Q1 Earnings Risks and Potential Upside
With the first quarter of 2025 already shaping up to be challenging for freight markets, Citi analysts caution that earnings may be under pressure for trucking companies. However, there’s a potential upside to the slowdown:
?? Slower economic activity could accelerate the exit of weaker carriers, tightening capacity faster than anticipated. ?? Tender rejections have increased in recent weeks, suggesting that capacity is adjusting to demand fluctuations, a possible indicator that spot rates could stabilize.
Citi’s Take on Trucking and Rail Investments
Given the market turbulence, Citi has adjusted its outlook on several key transportation stocks:
? Knight-Swift Transportation (KNX) was upgraded to Neutral, despite near-term earnings risks. The stock rose 11% in early 2025 but has since dropped 20%, including a 4% sell-off last week. Analysts argue that market sentiment—not company fundamentals—are driving the downturn, creating a more balanced risk-reward profile for long-term investors.
? In the rail sector, Citi reaffirmed Buy ratings for Canadian Pacific (CP) and CSX. CSX, despite facing short-term headwinds, remains attractive due to its low price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio and projected growth in 2026.
Citi’s long-term outlook suggests that while trucking stocks remain volatile, investors willing to weather short-term uncertainty may find value in strategically positioned transport stocks, both in trucking and rail.
?
Source:
?