Transparency, please

Transparency, please

The Wellington economics fraternity was up in arms last week. The reason was a job opening.

Treasury is seeking a Senior Analyst for its Economic Strategy unit. Advertised as a ‘unique opportunity’, Treasury explained they were looking for “a well-rounded candidate”. Fair enough.

But then the Government’s economic advisory department added that “an economics background is not essential.”

Former Treasury employees and academic economists were outraged. How could you have a senior position in economic strategy without knowing economics, they asked. Quite.

Still, there is another and equally concerning problem about Treasury’s job advertisement: it totally lacks specificity.

This is everything the job ad tells us about the candidate’s required characteristics:

  • Critical thinking through constructive debate
  • Good people and relationship skills
  • Comfort working at pace (when required) and dealing with ambiguity
  • Be a superb communicator with good EQ
  • The ability to motivate and influence others
  • An interest in mentoring and supporting other team members

Based on these requirements, anyone could apply. None of these criteria are specific, let alone formal.

Keeping public sector job ads so vague is problematic. It opens the door to arbitrariness and stands against best international practices.

New Zealand regularly leads Transparency International’s ‘Corruption Perception Index’. So it might be worth also taking their recruitment advice onboard.

Transparency International’s Anti-Corruption Resource Centre warns that “in many developing countries, weak HR management processes have resulted in oversized and under-qualified civil services, with distorted incentive structures and poor work ethics that ultimately undermine the goal of building a strong, efficient and accountable public sector.”

Now, New Zealand is not a developing country. But we do not want to become one, either.

Transparency International strongly recommends precise definitions of skills in public sector recruitment: “If merit is vaguely defined in broad terms, such as ‘able to do the job’, many candidates may be adequate, and the ambiguity may be misused to favour relatives or political supporters to the detriment of other outstanding candidates.”

This is not corruption of the bribery kind. But it allows an intellectual corruption in which a candidate’s actual qualification can be trumped by irrelevant considerations.

Next time Treasury advertises a position, it should be more specific. If it wants a lawyer or an accountant instead of an economist, fine, but then it should say so. Ideally, it should identify the qualifications and experience of the candidate.

What is good advice for other countries is good advice for New Zealand.

First published in 'Insights', The New Zealand Initiative's weekly newsletter. Subscribe here.

Eyal Apatov

Senior Analyst at Oranga Tamariki—Ministry for Children

3 年

I think we are heading that way regardless of our HR practices.... I just wonder what will happen to the $NZ once synthetic milk and lab-grown meat will become cheaper than dairy/milk... We don't invest enough in ICT, so once our meat/dairy exports are down, the only thing we will be able to sell to the world will be tourism

回复

Unfortunately there has been a trend ina lot of public service recruitment advertising to be just like this. It applies equally across Australia and helps to create the perception thatjobs are being targeted to suit political ideology of the government rather than tequired skills. It’s a reason why many people won’t apply for government jobs. Even if the perception is wrong, perception determines reality

Gary Neat

Former Chairman & CEO. Foreign Correspondent. Chevening Scholar.

3 年

Too late!!!

Anil Dsouza

Electronic Engineer

3 年

Many countries don't employ the specifically qualified people though there is enough tallent. And other countries don't believe on foreign people whatever their qualification and experience. They tell to study first there. The average people can't study in Europe or any advanced countries. So tallented people may not migrate in that way. But the people only do have money.

回复
Gavin Lawrence

Independent director and strategic advisor | Veteran | Volunteer | Passionate advocate for serving and former New Zealand Defence Force personnel

3 年

Astounding…and yet so disappointingly unsurprising.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Oliver Hartwich的更多文章

  • How central banking lost its way

    How central banking lost its way

    Three bits of news from the world of finance and central banking this week: The Reserve Bank increased the cash rate by…

  • Long live Helen Clark

    Long live Helen Clark

    We all wish Helen Clark a long life. At the same time, that prospect makes us nervous.

    7 条评论
  • Don't know much about history?

    Don't know much about history?

    It does not happen every day that I find myself in agreement with the Ministry of Education. But its reasoning for…

    1 条评论
  • Effective and affordable – Why the ETS is sufficient to deal with the climate emergency

    Effective and affordable – Why the ETS is sufficient to deal with the climate emergency

    Parliament has declared a climate change emergency. Having committed to cutting its emissions to net-zero by 2050, New…

    5 条评论
  • In search of Kiwi excellence

    In search of Kiwi excellence

    One of the first management books I ever read was Tom Peters’ A Passion for Excellence. I must have received it in the…

    26 条评论
  • Ta ta ta taaaa! Roll over Beethoven

    Ta ta ta taaaa! Roll over Beethoven

    There is something special about Adele, Madonna and Sia. Because these pop divas are only ever referred to by their…

    2 条评论
  • We don’t know how unlucky we are in NZ

    We don’t know how unlucky we are in NZ

    All eyes are on New Zealand. In the lead-up to the election, Time magazine admired our “calmer democracy.

    50 条评论
  • The vexing issue of Damien Grant's 'career-ending' convictions

    The vexing issue of Damien Grant's 'career-ending' convictions

    Should a convicted fraudster be allowed to work as an insolvency practitioner? If your spontaneous answer is “no way!”,…

  • Learning to live with Covid-19?

    Learning to live with Covid-19?

    At the end of this week, New Zealand is back in a situation we hoped to have left behind. With Auckland in lockdown and…

    5 条评论
  • A return to normal? Forget about it.

    A return to normal? Forget about it.

    Covid-19 is not just a medical and economic crisis. It is a historical watershed moment with massive effects for entire…

    3 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了