Transforming One-on-Ones: From Ineffective to Impactful

"Management is about arranging and telling. Leadership is about nurturing and enhancing." - Tom Peters

TL;DR: This article explores the power of one-on-one meetings in the realm of management. It highlights the common pitfalls that render these meetings ineffective and provides practical tips and strategies for conducting effective one-on-ones. Drawing from the insights of Manager Tools, a renowned management consulting firm, the article delves into the ideal structure of a one-on-one, the role of feedback, the power of coaching, and the importance of measuring the impact of these meetings. The journey from ineffective to impactful one-on-ones requires a shift in mindset, a commitment to change, and a willingness to adapt. But the rewards - increased employee engagement, improved productivity, and a stronger, more cohesive team - are well worth the effort.

In my recent articles, I delved into the world of project and program management, exploring the strategies, techniques, and tools that can drive success in these specific areas. However, effective management extends beyond the realm of projects and programs. It permeates every aspect of an organization, influencing how we lead teams, make decisions, and ultimately, achieve our goals. As we transition from the focused lens of project management, it's time to broaden our perspective and explore the wider landscape of general management. Today, we turn our attention to one of the most fundamental aspects of leadership: conducting effective one-on-one meetings. Just as project management is crucial for guiding individual initiatives to success, mastering one-on-ones is key to fostering strong relationships, facilitating clear communication, and leading your team to its full potential.

In the world of management, the difference between arranging and nurturing, telling and enhancing, can be the difference between a disengaged employee and a motivated one. One of the most powerful tools in a manager's arsenal to bridge this gap is the one-on-one meeting. These meetings, when conducted effectively, can transform the manager-employee relationship, fostering open communication, mutual understanding, and personal growth. However, the power of one-on-ones is often untapped, with many managers falling into common pitfalls that render these meetings ineffective. This article aims to guide you on the journey from ineffective to impactful one-on-ones, providing practical tips and strategies that can help you harness the full potential of these meetings.

Section 1: The Current State of One-on-Ones

In many organizations, one-on-ones are often treated as a mere formality, with managers and employees going through the motions without clear objectives. Common practices that render these meetings ineffective include lack of preparation, focusing solely on immediate tasks, and not providing constructive feedback. For instance, a manager might use the entire meeting to discuss ongoing projects, leaving no room for the employee to voice their concerns or ideas. Research shows that such practices can lead to decreased employee engagement and productivity.

Practical Tip: Avoid turning one-on-ones into status updates. Instead, use this time to understand your employee's perspective, discuss their career goals, and provide feedback.

Section 2: The Ideal One-on-One

Manager Tools is a renowned management consulting firm that provides a wealth of resources for managers and leaders at all levels. They offer a range of services including podcasts, training, products, and tools aimed at improving management skills and effectiveness. Their approach is centered around practical, actionable guidance that can be implemented immediately to drive results.

Manager Tools is perhaps best known for their concept of the "Manager Tools Trinity?", a set of fundamental practices that form the basis of effective management. These include one-on-ones, feedback, coaching, and delegation. They also offer a variety of other resources, including the "Effective Manager" book, the "Interviewing Series", and the "RoadMap" app, which guides managers in implementing the Manager Tools Trinity?. You can find more about Manager Tools and access their resources on their website: Manager Tools

An effective one-on-one, as per Manager Tools, is a well-structured meeting that balances the needs of the manager and the employee. It starts with the employee discussing their concerns or ideas, followed by the manager providing feedback and discussing tasks, and ends with a coaching or mentoring session. For example, a manager might start the meeting by asking the employee about their recent challenges, then provide feedback on their performance, and finally discuss ways to improve their skills.

Google's Project Aristotle: Google conducted a two-year study known as Project Aristotle to understand what makes a team effective. One of the key findings was that psychological safety, which can be fostered through effective one-on-ones, was crucial for team effectiveness. Managers at Google use one-on-ones to build this sense of safety, encouraging open communication and providing constructive feedback.

Practical Tip: Follow the 10-10-10 rule for one-on-ones: 10 minutes for the employee, 10 minutes for the manager, and 10 minutes for coaching or mentoring. This will take time to grow into, but eventually this provides the right balance of bottom up, top down and long term discussions. Below is a link to the Manager Tools O3 template which is a great starting point, you should customize it for your use case.

Section 3: Transitioning to Effective One-on-Ones

Transitioning from ineffective to effective one-on-ones requires a shift in mindset and approach. Manager Tools suggests setting a regular schedule for one-on-ones, preparing for each meeting, and following a structured agenda. For instance, a manager might schedule weekly one-on-ones, review the employee's performance before each meeting, and follow the 10-10-10 rule during the meeting.

Practical Tip: Use a shared document to keep track of topics discussed in one-on-ones. This can serve as a reference for future meetings and help ensure continuity. Leveraging tools like Notion or OneNote, you can create a shared document that evolves over time while retaining historical context.

Section 4: The Role of Feedback in One-on-Ones: The OIL Method and the Situation-Behavior-Impact Model

Feedback is a crucial part of one-on-ones. Manager Tools advocates for both positive feedback for good performance and constructive feedback for areas of improvement. However, delivering feedback effectively requires more than just stating your observations. It requires a structured approach that ensures clear communication and understanding. Two powerful techniques that can aid in this process are the OIL method and the Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) model.

The OIL method, which stands for Observe, Inquire, and Listen, is a technique for improving the components of effective communication.

Observe: This involves watching for nuances and subtle changes in an employee's attitude, communications, or body language. These observations can provide valuable insights into the employee's strengths and areas for improvement.

Inquire: This involves asking thoughtful questions to gain a better understanding of situations, people, and processes. The goal of inquiry is not just to gather information, but to coach employees to self-reflect and commit to specific actions.

Listen: This involves understanding the message an employee is trying to communicate. This requires active listening, which involves focusing fully on the speaker, avoiding distractions, and seeking clarification when needed.

Practical Tip: Practice the OIL method by observing employees in their work environment, asking thoughtful questions with clear goals, and actively listening to their responses.

The Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) model is another effective technique for delivering feedback. This model involves describing the situation, explaining the employee's behavior, and discussing its impact.

Situation: This involves describing the specific context or circumstances where the behavior occurred. For instance, a manager might say, "During yesterday's team meeting..."

Behavior: This involves describing the observable actions of the employee. For example, "I noticed that you took the lead in presenting our project update..."

Impact: This involves explaining the effects of the behavior. For example, "This demonstrated your leadership skills and made the presentation more engaging for the team."

Practical Tip: Use the SBI model to provide specific, clear, and actionable feedback. By focusing on specific situations and behaviors, and explaining their impact, you can help employees understand exactly what they did well or need to improve.

Both the OIL method and the SBI model provide structured approaches to delivering feedback in one-on-ones. By observing, inquiring, and listening, and by focusing on specific situations, behaviors, and their impact, managers can provide more effective feedback and drive improvements in performance.

Feedback is one of the core aspects of the job of a manager. It is hard to give and to an extent, to receive, but it is imperative to deliver it frequently to help your team grow and improve.

Section 5: The Power of Coaching in One-on-Ones

Coaching plays a key role in one-on-ones, helping employees improve their skills and grow in their roles. Managers should use one-on-ones to provide coaching and delegate tasks that help employees develop. For instance, a manager might coach an employee on how to handle difficult clients, then delegate a challenging client to them.

In his book "The Coaching Habit," Michael Bungay Stanier provides a real-life example of how one-on-ones can be transformed into powerful coaching sessions. He suggests using specific questions to guide the conversation, such as "What's on your mind?" and "What's the real challenge here for you?" These questions can help managers understand their employees' perspectives and provide more effective coaching.

Practical Tip: Use the "GROW" model for coaching: set a Goal, explore the current Reality, consider Options, and decide on the Way forward.

Section 6: Measuring the Impact of Effective One-on-Ones

The effectiveness of one-on-ones can be measured through various metrics, such as employee engagement, productivity, and retention rates. Research shows that effective one-on-ones can lead to increased employee engagement and productivity, and reduced turnover. For example, a manager might notice an increase in an employee's productivity after implementing effective one-on-ones.

Practical Tip: Use regular employee surveys or feedback sessions to gauge the effectiveness of your one-on-ones. Ask employees about their satisfaction with these meetings and any improvements they would like to see.

Conclusion

In the realm of management, the power of one-on-one meetings cannot be overstated. They are the cornerstone of effective leadership, the conduit for clear communication, and the platform for personal development. Yet, as we've explored, many managers are not harnessing the full potential of these meetings. Instead, they're falling into common pitfalls that render one-on-ones ineffective and, in some cases, counterproductive.

But it doesn't have to be this way. As we've learned from Manager Tools, there's a better way to conduct one-on-ones. By observing, inquiring, and listening, and by focusing on specific situations, behaviors, and their impact, managers can transform these meetings from a mere formality into a powerful tool for driving performance and engagement.

The journey from ineffective to impactful one-on-ones is not a quick fix. It requires a shift in mindset, a commitment to change, and a willingness to adapt. But the rewards are well worth the effort. Effective one-on-ones can lead to increased employee engagement, improved productivity, and a stronger, more cohesive team.

As we continue to explore the wider landscape of general management, let's remember the importance of mastering the basics. One-on-ones may seem simple, but their impact is profound. So, let's commit to transforming our one-on-ones, to fostering open communication, providing meaningful feedback, and coaching our employees to reach their full potential. Because in the end, effective management is about more than just overseeing projects and programs. It's about leading people, and that's a responsibility we should never take lightly.

?