Trans dogma weakens the battle for abortion

Trans dogma weakens the battle for abortion

In the headlines?

Ukrainian military commanders say they are fighting a second day of “difficult bloody battles” with Russian forces?inside Mariupol’s Azovstal steel plant. The sprawling 4 sq mile complex is the last pocket of resistance in the besieged port city.?Hundreds of Tory candidates in today’s local elections are distancing themselves from the Prime Minister, says HuffPost. Conservative hopefuls in Hartlepool pleaded with voters not to “punish” them for “mistakes made in Westminster”.?The shirt worn by Diego Maradona when he scored his infamous “Hand of God” goal against England at the 1986 World Cup has sold at auction for £7.1m, smashing the previous record for sports memorabilia. More like “Hand of Wad”, says Metro.

Comment

Trans dogma weakens the battle for abortion

No alt text provided for this image

An abortion-rights protester outside the Supreme Court. Sarah Silbiger/Getty

Something has gone wrong with American feminism, says?Hadley Freeman?in?UnHerd. Abortion is, unambiguously, a women’s rights issue. But when it emerged this week that the Supreme Court is set to overturn Roe v Wade – the ruling that gives women the right to have an abortion – many liberal commentators couldn’t actually bring themselves to use the word “women”. One right-on congresswoman tweeted that “birthing bodies have the right to freedom”, somehow overlooking the rather crucial point that the “bodies being fought over here don’t want to give birth”. The avowedly pro-choice American Civil Liberties Union couldn’t bear to “say the dreaded W word” in its own response. Why the reticence? Because saying “women” might make trans women feel left out.

Conservative pro-lifers will of course bear ultimate responsibility for overturning Roe. But I find it hard to separate “the disintegration of a woman’s right to bodily autonomy in America from the rise of gender ideology”. By tangling itself up in knots over “birthing bodies” and “cis privilege”, the left has made it much harder to talk about women’s rights – and therefore to protect them. Maybe “focusing on vaginas and misogyny feels super uncool and smelly and Mum-like” to a generation which has grown up taking abortion access as a given. But the Supreme Court news shows just how desperately liberals need to return to feminism’s roots. Because it’s women, not trans women, who will be dying from back-alley abortions if Roe v Wade is overturned. “And, contrary to gender theory’s teachings, you can’t identify out of that.”

Gone viral

No alt text provided for this image

When an egg is cracked open underwater, it doesn’t “dissolve into a gooey mess”, says Mental Floss. Instead, the pressure of the sea keeps the delicate material intact. As it drifts around, “the strands of egg whites resemble a jellyfish’s tentacles”.

Quirk of history?

A terrible experience on holiday can set you against a country for life, says The Fence. This was certainly true of the late Colonel Muammar Gaddafi. After his son Hannibal was arrested in Geneva in 2008 for beating servants, the Libyan leader unsuccessfully proposed, at the following year’s G8 summit, “to have Switzerland partitioned between Italy, France and Germany”. He also later banned Swiss watches from Libya’s capital, Tripoli.

Life?

The veteran American paparazzo Ron Galella, who has died aged 91, had, in Andy Warhol’s words, the knack of being “in the right place at the wrong moment”. He was impertinent enough for Marlon Brando to punch him in the mouth in 1974, knocking out several of Galella’s teeth, says The Times. The actor’s fist then became infected and he spent three days in hospital – something Galella proudly attributed to his “paparazzi germs”.

Comment

Putin is winning the war at home

No alt text provided for this image

A protester being detained in Moscow in March. AFP/Getty

The Kremlin hasn’t made much headway in its invasion of Ukraine, says?The Economist. “But in its simultaneous imposition of near-totalitarian control in Russia, it has been far more successful.” Since the start of the war, Vladimir Putin’s regime has been “vigorously suppressing dissent and demoralising opponents, turning a relatively open country into a complete dictatorship”. Gregory Asmolov, an expert on Russian information warfare, says this is the Kremlin’s biggest achievement in the conflict: “You couldn’t even imagine this straightjacketed political reality a few months ago.”?

State propaganda claims 81% of Russians back the war. The true figure is lower, but it’s impossible to know by how much: up to 90% of the population “refuses to participate in political polling”. And for most Russians, toeing the government’s line is the easiest – and safest – option. Getting a manicure in the blue-and-yellow of Ukraine’s flag “can get you arrested”; spreading “fake news” is punishable by up to 15 years in jail. And even among close friends, there is a fear of?donosy, or denunciations, as there was in Stalin’s era. One entrepreneur in his 30s says friends warily eye each other up around the dinner table, “trying to guess where loyalties lie”. At home, he keeps his own plans to leave Russia quiet, “lest the state TV presenter in the apartment upstairs” overhears him. It’s all part of Russia’s “new reality of fear and anxiety”.

Staying young

No alt text provided for this image

A 100-year-old man has broken the Guinness World Record for the longest time working at a single company. Walter Orthmann, from the Brazilian city of Brusque, began working for the textile firm ReneauxView in 1938, when he was just 15 years old. Now a sales manager, he says the office is still his favourite place to be – even after 84 years.?

Tomorrow’s world?

Engineering boffins in Germany have invented “smart screws” that can tell you when they need to be tightened, says Gizmodo. Sensors in the screw heads measure the pressure being applied, and if, over time, the screw comes loose, the pressure decreases and a wireless warning signal is sent out.

Snapshot

No alt text provided for this image

It’s the world’s only set of nonuplets, celebrating their first birthday. Halima Cissé, a 26-year-old from Mali, gave birth to the record-breaking brood in Morocco last May. The five girls and four boys were delivered by caesarean section around 10 weeks prematurely, each weighing only between 1lb 1oz and 2lb 2oz. Only two other sets of nonuplets have ever been born, but neither survived beyond a few days. “It’s not easy but it’s great,” Cissé tells BBC Afrique. “Even if it’s tiring at times, when you look at all the babies in perfect health... we forget everything.”

?Quoted?

“The first sign of a politician in dire straits on either side of the Atlantic is that he either compares some modern foe to Hitler or pleads Churchill’s shade in his own cause.”?– Max Hastings?

That’s it. You’re done.

Get The Knowledge in your inbox – we cut through the noise to give you the news you need. Sign up for free?here.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

The Knowledge的更多文章

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了