Top Actions for CMOs When Marketing-Sourced Pipeline Falls Behind Targets

Conduct a Full-Funnel Analysis with Precision

Go beyond the surface by analyzing conversion rates at every stage of the funnel (from top-of-funnel awareness down to closed deals) to uncover where prospects are dropping off.

• Pinpoint the exact stages where leads disengage. Are they dropping off after the first touchpoint? Stalling at the MQL-to-SQL transition?
• Investigate common characteristics of leads at these drop-off points, looking at demographics and engagement patterns.

Next Steps: Work with the sales and SDR teams to refine handoff processes and provide them with targeted insights to improve follow-up. If MQLs aren’t converting, consider adjusting the lead scoring criteria to ensure only high-quality leads are passed.

Implement Dynamic, Data-Driven Targeting

Use advanced segmentation and predictive analytics to dynamically adjust targeting based on real-time data. This allows you to focus resources on the audiences with the highest probability to convert.

• Track behaviors and engagement signals (e.g., frequent content interactions, high interest in product pages) that indicate buying intent.
• Segment audiences into high, medium, and low propensity-to-buy groups based on these signals and assign resources accordingly.

Next Steps: Create tailored campaigns for each group. For high-propensity groups, invest in ABM or personalized outreach. For medium propensity, focus on nurturing and education. For low-propensity, try lighter engagement or awareness-building campaigns.

Double Down on Intent-Driven Content Strategy

Map content more closely to the stages of intent and adjust distribution channels to place the right content in front of buyers exactly when it’s needed.

• Identify top-performing pieces of content at each stage. What’s generating initial engagement, and what’s converting?
• Look for gaps—do you lack content that addresses the specific objections or decision criteria of your audience?

Next Steps: If certain content formats (e.g., case studies, product comparisons) drive higher conversions, prioritize creating more of those and distributing them across channels like email nurture sequences, social retargeting, and ABM campaigns.

Revamp Your Paid Acquisition Strategy Based on Deeper Analysis

Reassess each paid acquisition channel with a focus on understanding nuances like time-to-conversion, engagement depth, and attribution. Move beyond CPC and CTR to analyze revenue-per-click or other metrics tied to bottom-line impact.

• For each paid channel, look at metrics beyond click-through rates to understand true ROI (e.g., what channels generate MQLs that actually progress to SQLs and beyond).
• Review historical data to identify patterns in seasonality or days/times with high engagement to better optimize spend.

Next Steps: Reallocate budget based on channels with proven high conversion rates and short time-to-conversion. Experiment with channel-specific strategies (e.g., LinkedIn for ABM, retargeting ads for mid-funnel re-engagement) to maximize returns.

Redefine the MQL-to-SQL Handoff Process

If MQLs are failing to convert, revisit the MQL definition and the handoff process with Sales. Consider implementing a tighter feedback loop to catch issues early.

• Evaluate the profile of MQLs that don’t convert. Are they missing key qualification criteria, or do they disengage because of follow-up timing?
• Interview Sales and SDR teams to get firsthand insights into common objections or gaps they’re encountering with marketing-sourced leads.

Next Steps: Update lead scoring models to emphasize traits that make MQLs more likely to convert. Improve the handoff process by introducing a structured feedback loop where Sales can provide immediate feedback on MQL quality.

Enhance Lead Nurture Journeys with Behavioral Triggers

Rather than relying solely on linear lead nurture sequences, incorporate behavioral triggers to create personalized, responsive engagement paths.

• Analyze which specific content, messages, or actions drive the most engagement or re-engagement from prospects.
• Look at time-to-engagement and drop-off points within nurture sequences to optimize timing and content relevance.

Next Steps: Use behavioral triggers to send personalized follow-ups when prospects show interest in high-intent content (e.g., demo pages, pricing). Test cadence adjustments and time-triggered emails based on when prospects are most likely to engage.?

Expand or Update ABM Tactics for High-Value Accounts

Use ABM to engage your highest-value prospects with hyper-personalized campaigns and direct tactics.

• Review the characteristics of high-converting accounts to refine your ABM target list.
• Look at engagement metrics from past ABM campaigns to understand which personalized touches (direct mail, targeted ads, etc.) drive the most response.

Next Steps: Increase focus on multichannel ABM approaches, such as personalized LinkedIn ads, industry-specific webinars, or direct mail campaigns. For high-potential accounts, involve account executives early for a more coordinated effort.

Utilize Past Converting Data to Inform New Tactics

Analyze past successful campaigns and MQLs-to-SQLs data to uncover trends and apply similar tactics to current pipeline generation efforts.

• Identify which types of messaging, content, and channels have historically driven the best conversions.
• Look for similarities among high-quality leads (industry, job title, company size) that successfully moved through the pipeline.

Next Steps: Replicate successful elements from past campaigns, like messaging and content format, and apply these to underperforming campaigns. Leverage winning tactics from high-performing channels to see if they can improve results in weaker areas.

Optimize Retargeting Efforts Based on Intent Signals

Retarget engaged users with highly relevant content or offers, especially those who demonstrate buying intent by engaging with key product or pricing pages.

• Identify which pages or actions correlate with high-conversion rates (e.g., demo requests, pricing page visits).
• Segment audiences based on specific engagement behaviors for more targeted follow-up.

Next Steps: Craft retargeting ads with tailored CTAs for each segment, offering specific next steps based on past behavior, such as case studies or webinars for those who engaged with product information.

Develop Short-Term Lead Generation Campaigns Focused on Urgent Buyer Needs

If you need immediate pipeline boosts, create quick, high-urgency campaigns (e.g., limited-time offers, assessments) that encourage quick action.

• Assess pain points and challenges that are most likely to prompt action (e.g., regulatory deadlines, seasonal business needs).
• Identify topics or trends that create urgency and align them with relevant product messaging.

Next Steps: Launch short-term campaigns that emphasize urgency, such as exclusive webinars, free consultations, or a timely industry report. Use channels that deliver immediate reach, such as paid ads, direct email, and website banners.

?