Top 5 precedents for energy suppliers being penalized

The EU is becoming stricter in enforcing consumer protection ??, sustainability ??, and fair competition ?? in the energy market. Energy suppliers that fail to comply with evolving regulations risk fines, legal action, and reputational damage ??.

Let's check out 10 key regulations that impact the activities, business operations, and customer service of energy suppliers across the continent:

#1. ? The EU Energy Union Framework - The piece sets the overall policy framework for energy security, sustainability, and integration. It aims to make energy markets more integrated and competitive while ensuring a cleaner and more sustainable energy system across Europe.

#2. ??The Electricity Directive (2019/944/EU) - This directive sets out rules for the internal electricity market, ensuring that consumers benefit from competitive electricity prices, improved consumer rights, and access to clean energy. It also focuses on the decarbonization of energy systems and the integration of renewable energy sources.

Update in 2019:

This regulation was updated as part of the Clean Energy for All Europeans package, finalized in 2019. The new provisions emphasize the role of consumers, energy markets integration, decarbonization, and renewable energy integration. It enhances the rights of consumers to switch suppliers, access transparent pricing, and improve energy efficiency. The directive now also stresses cross-border energy trade and the creation of a European Electricity Market.

#3. ??The Renewable Energy Directive (2018/2001/EU)- This directive establishes a common framework for promoting the use of energy from renewable sources. It includes targets for renewable energy consumption in the EU, encouraging suppliers to source more energy from renewable sources and ensuring consumer access to clean energy.

Update in 2018:

This directive was updated in 2018, introducing higher renewable energy targets (32% renewable energy consumption by 2030) and reinforcing consumer rights to access renewable sources. The amendment also requires energy suppliers to provide better transparency regarding their renewable energy supply and environmental impact.

#4. ??The Gas Directive (2009/73/EC)- It regulates the internal gas market within the EU, promoting competition, enhancing transparency, and ensuring that consumers have access to natural gas supplies on equal terms. It focuses on the unbundling of gas companies and the liberalization of the gas market.

Update in 2019:

While the Gas Directive itself hasn’t been updated in terms of core principles, it was amended in 2019 to adapt to the Energy Union's goals. This update aimed to integrate non-EU countries like Norway and Russia into the internal gas market while continuing to uphold liberalization and unbundling requirements.

The Gas Directive (2009/73/EC) and broader EU energy policies were significantly influenced by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022. While the directive itself was last formally amended in 2019, the EU introduced new emergency measures and policies aimed at reducing dependency on Russian gas and ensuring energy security.

#5. ??The Energy Efficiency Directive (2012/27/EU)- This directive sets energy efficiency targets for the EU, promoting measures that energy suppliers must adopt to improve energy consumption practices. It also requires suppliers to inform and engage consumers in energy-saving measures.

Update in 2021:

The Energy Efficiency Directive has been updated with the 2021 recast. The new version, introduced as part of the EU's European Green Deal, sets a new, more ambitious energy efficiency target of 9% by 2030, reinforces the implementation of energy audits, and emphasizes consumer involvement in energy savings.

#6. ??The Clean Energy for All Europeans Package (2019) - This package includes several regulations aimed at achieving the EU’s climate goals, enhancing energy efficiency, reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and increasing renewable energy use. It covers the electricity market, governance, and energy performance in buildings.

#7. ??The EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) The EU ETS is a market-based mechanism to reduce carbon emissions, covering power stations and other heavy industry. Energy suppliers must comply with the trading of emission allowances, encouraging the reduction of carbon emissions in their supply chains.

Update in 2021:

The EU ETS was overhauled with the 2021 "Fit for 55" package, part of the EU’s broader climate goals to cut emissions by 55% by 2030. The system now includes tighter emission caps and expanded coverage of more sectors, like shipping and aviation. Energy suppliers are subject to stricter rules on carbon trading and must now work harder to meet stricter carbon reduction targets.

#8. ???The Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU) - This directive sets out the rights of consumers when purchasing goods or services within the EU, including energy services. It includes regulations on transparent pricing, billing, contract terms, and the right to switch energy suppliers without excessive fees or delays.

#9. ??The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) - GDPR applies to all energy suppliers that handle personal data of EU consumers. It ensures that suppliers must handle customer data with transparency, consent, and security, and provides customers with control over their data.

#10. ??European Network Codes and Guidelines These are technical regulations for the operation of energy networks in Europe, including the rules for the electricity and gas transmission systems. They promote cross-border electricity and gas trade, establish minimum technical standards, and ensure that energy flows efficiently and safely across borders.

Have energy suppliers across Europe ever been punished for non-compliance with various regulations?

Let's regard a few examples:

01. Failure to Provide Transparent Billing and Consumer Support - In 2018, the French Energy Regulatory Commission (CRE) fined EDF (électricité de France) for failing to provide clear and accurate bills to consumers, which violated consumer protection regulations. The fine amounted to €1 million, emphasizing the importance of transparency and consumer rights.

02. High Penalties for Misleading Marketing and Consumer Contracts - In 2019, the UK’s Ofgem (Office of Gas and Electricity Markets) fined E.ON and SSE Energy for misleading customers about the prices of their energy tariffs. These companies were accused of failing to provide transparent information, which misled consumers into signing up for energy plans that were more expensive than advertised. Ofgem issued fines totaling ￡14 million to both companies.

03. Failure to Meet Renewable Energy Targets In 2021, the European Commission imposed a fine on several energy suppliers for failing to meet their commitments to source sufficient renewable energy as per the Renewable Energy Directive. Countries like Germany and France faced penalties for not meeting national renewable energy targets, which indirectly impacted suppliers in these regions.

04. Fines for Data Protection Violations (GDPR) Under the GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation), several energy suppliers across Europe have faced fines for mishandling customer data. For example, in 2020, E.ON was fined €1.5 million in Germany for improperly processing personal data of customers without their consent. Other suppliers across the EU have faced similar penalties for breaching privacy and data security regulations.

05. Non-Compliance with the EU’s Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) In 2020, several energy suppliers were penalized under the EU ETS for exceeding their emission caps and failing to meet the required carbon allowances. These penalties are part of a broader effort by the EU to enforce stricter emission reduction measures and hold energy companies accountable for their environmental impact.

Want more?

Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive Explained in 10 Minutes

Tell us what you think below ????