Too Many Leaders Are Only "Half" Leading. Here's the Other Missing Half

Too often, organizations invest time, resources, and expertise into developing strategies that never fully see the light of day. Leaders meticulously outline initiatives, set ambitious goals, and build frameworks to guide success. And yet, despite all the planning, most strategies fail or only reach partial implementation. The reasons lie not in the strategies themselves but in a deeper, often unacknowledged truth about what leadership is really about: it’s not just managing initiatives and driving results. The real magic, the real transformation, depends on leaders managing people’s hearts, behaviors, and feelings.

1. Leaders Are Only Half Leading

Most leaders believe their role is to drive performance. They focus on initiatives, deadlines, and deliverables, all the while forgetting something critical: their role isn’t just to motivate but to nurture. Leadership demands more than a results-focused mindset—it requires managing the unspoken undercurrents of emotions that run through every team. Feelings impact performance, engagement, and commitment in ways that no strategic plan can predict or control. By overlooking the necessity to manage feelings, leaders risk building organizations with brittle foundations, unable to adapt, evolve, or fully commit to change.

Leaders who remember to manage feelings understand that every initiative must align not just with business goals but with the hearts and minds of the people tasked with bringing it to life. They understand that people are not simply motivated by logic or incentives but by trust, emotional safety, and authentic care. It’s here, in the emotional realm, where true alignment happens.

2. The Silent Power of Behavior

Too many leaders operate without a deep consciousness of their own behavior and its ripple effect on those around them. They may speak about accountability and performance, but without living those principles authentically, they miss the mark entirely. Real responsibility, for any role, begins with behavior—the way we communicate, listen, and show respect or disregard, whether knowingly or unknowingly. When leaders hold themselves accountable not just for what they achieve but for how they achieve it, they set a precedent that others naturally follow.

A culture of true responsibility emerges when behavior becomes a central value. This shift is subtle but transformational. It replaces a results-driven environment with a values-driven one, where the way goals are met becomes just as important as the goals themselves. Leaders who lead by example in this way inspire their teams to bring out the best in themselves and others.

3. The Blind Spot of Unawareness

One of the most pervasive challenges facing leaders is a lack of awareness—an unawareness of what they don’t know. Leaders can be unaware of the emotional and relational gaps within their teams, unaware of the struggles individuals are facing, or even unaware of their own limiting behaviors. This “unawareness of unawareness” is dangerous; it leaves blind spots, creating fractured cultures where problems quietly fester and growth stagnates.

Leaders with self-awareness and humility have a superpower that many lack: the capacity to recognize their own blind spots and seek insight from others. They listen deeply, ask difficult questions, and create a space where every individual feels valued and heard. Awareness is not a skill; it’s a mindset—a way of leading that values growth and connection over ego.

4. Change Management Lacks Depth

Change management professionals are instrumental in executing complex transformations, but too often their approach is overly procedural, relying on frameworks that fall short of addressing the emotional realities within an organization. Change is deeply personal, and yet, it’s often treated as a mechanical process, stripped of the sensitivity and empathy required to guide people through it.

When change management professionals take the time to dive into people’s lives and listen—truly listen—change feels less imposed and more invited. It becomes an opportunity for growth and collaboration, not a disruption. Understanding how people feel, what their fears are, and why they resist is essential to any successful transformation. Without these insights, change will always feel like a one-size-fits-all approach, leaving people disengaged and indifferent.

5. The Missing Role: A Chief Culture Officer

Too many companies lack a Chief Culture Officer, a role dedicated to the intangible yet invaluable aspects of culture—the heartbeat of the organization. This is a person who understands that magic, the space where innovation, breakthroughs, and genuine human connection occur, only happens in the presence of vulnerability. This is someone responsible not for strategies but for the daily experiences of employees: the mood, the unspoken conflicts, the space for feedback, and the opportunity for personal growth.

A Chief Culture Officer has one primary objective: to create an environment where people feel safe to communicate what they fear might be unsafe to express. They work to ensure that people feel seen, respected, and empowered to bring their whole selves to work. They are there not to simply create a feel-good culture but to build one that aligns with the organization’s values and vision, one where people feel part of something greater than themselves.

Without someone in this role, culture is left to chance. People may feel they are on their own, that they cannot share what matters most, that they have to protect themselves rather than grow. The absence of a Chief Culture Officer means an absence of intentionality around the organization’s emotional ecosystem, leaving strategy to fall flat, goals unmet, and people uninspired.

The Shift Leaders Need to Make

For strategies to succeed, leaders must evolve their understanding of leadership itself. Leadership is not about driving tasks, directing initiatives and generating results. It is about creating a space where people feel safe to be vulnerable, where they are free to express both ideas and insecurities. This environment of openness, responsibility, and awareness is where the magic happens. It’s the invisible force that propels initiatives forward, fosters true commitment, and ensures strategies are not just executed but embraced.

In the end, successful strategies are not made by flawless plans—they are made by people who feel "connected" to those plans. People who are empowered and valued. Leaders who recognize this, who prioritize feelings as much as goals, and who strive to cultivate a culture of awareness, responsibility, and openness will be the ones who unlock the true potential within their teams. They won’t just drive results; they’ll create a lasting impact, transforming not just their organizations but the lives of every person within them.

_____

Andrew Kolikoff is a master of masters in creating profits for organizations by elevating people and company cultures to become the very best they can be... more productive, more engaged, more servant hearted. He also leads an organization for servant hearted, heart centered leaders called The Secret Sauce Society.

If you are seeking a powerful, dynamic speaker, wanting a more transformative company retreat, in need of someone to assist with conflict resolution, better communication as a result of a merger or acquisition, a deeper commitment toward your personal development or the development of your people through coaching, or delivering a better customer experience or simply wanting to build a better organizational culture, please contact Andrew directly --> Here.

If what Andrew espoused in this article resonated with you, he invites you to comment, share and subscribe to his newsletter - The Servant Leader