The Tipping Backlash: Why More Customers Are Refusing to Tip

The Tipping Boil-Over

Have you ever ordered a coffee, paid at the counter, and suddenly been asked to tip 25%—before you even get your drink? You’re not alone. Customers everywhere are pushing back against what many are calling ‘tipflation.’

Tipping used to be a reward for great service—now, it’s expected everywhere, from self-checkouts to takeout windows. Consumers are frustrated, businesses are caught in the middle, and the restaurant industry is at a crossroads.

How Tipping Got Out of Control

For decades, tipping in the U.S. followed a relatively stable norm—15-20% at full-service restaurants, a dollar or two for baristas and service workers. But over the past few years, the tipping culture has changed dramatically.

• “Tip Creep” – It’s not just for waitstaff anymore. Tip screens now appear at coffee shops, takeout counters, food trucks, and even self-service kiosks.
• Self-Checkout Tipping – Some retailers are prompting customers to tip even when no human interaction is involved.
• "Guilt Tipping" – Digital payment systems make declining a tip more awkward, pressuring customers into higher percentages.

Since 2020, tip requests at fast casual restaurants have surged by over 40%, and consumers are beginning to push back.

Why Customers Are Saying ‘Enough!’

1. Tipping Fatigue – People feel like they’re constantly being asked to tip, even for minimal service.
2. Hidden Price Increases – Many restaurants have already raised menu prices due to inflation, and customers feel tipping is an added burden.
3. Lack of Personal Service – Why tip at a counter-service or drive-thru where little interaction occurs?
4. Confusing Expectations – Some restaurants pool tips, while others don’t. Customers don’t always know where their money is going.

The backlash is growing. Viral social media posts show customers refusing to tip on self-checkout screens. A recent survey found that nearly 70% of consumers believe tipping has gotten out of control.

What This Means for Restaurants

With consumer frustration at an all-time high, the restaurant industry must ask itself: Should tipping stay, should we raise wages, or is there a better model?

Restaurant operators have three choices:

1. Keep tipping—but be transparent. Clearly explain where tips go and how they benefit employees.
2. Raise menu prices and eliminate tipping. Some fine-dining restaurants have tested this model but faced pushback from both staff and customers.
3. Hybrid approach. Some brands have introduced a service charge while keeping optional tipping.

Case Study: Danny Meyer’s No-Tipping Experiment

Restaurateur Danny Meyer famously eliminated tipping at his Union Square Hospitality Group restaurants, raising wages to compensate. The move was met with resistance, and he eventually reversed it, proving that changing tipping culture is no easy task.

International Perspective: The U.S. vs. Europe

In many European countries, tipping is either built into menu prices or completely optional. Could the U.S. shift toward a similar model? Or is tipping too ingrained in American culture?

How to Manage, Lead, Coach, and Succeed Amid the Tipping Backlash

For single-unit operators and large brands, navigating the tipping debate requires strategy and leadership. Here’s how you can take control:

Manage:

A strong tipping policy begins with clear and transparent communication. Restaurant owners should ensure that employees and guests alike understand how tipping works within their establishment. Use signage, digital receipts, and employee handbooks to detail where tips go and how they benefit the team. Additionally, actively seek customer feedback to identify and address concerns related to tipping policies. Adapting to guest expectations while maintaining operational efficiency is key to finding balance.

Lead:

Leadership plays a critical role in guiding teams through these industry changes. Managers must educate their teams on addressing customer concerns about tipping confidently and consistently. Employees should be empowered to discuss tipping policies in a way that maintains guest trust. If an organization is considering a shift—such as moving to a no-tipping model or introducing service charges—leaders should first pilot the initiative in select locations before rolling out system-wide changes to measure its impact.

Coach:

Training is essential for ensuring that employees handle tipping-related conversations smoothly. Staff should be coached to maintain a service-driven mindset rather than relying solely on tips for motivation. Managers should focus on performance-based incentives to keep team morale high, whether that’s through professional development opportunities, internal recognition programs, or structured bonus plans. By fostering a team culture centered around excellence in service, restaurants can navigate changes in tipping without sacrificing employee satisfaction.

Succeed:

Success in adapting to the tipping debate requires strategic innovation. If transitioning to a no-tip model, ensure wages remain competitive and sustainable to attract and retain top talent. Leveraging technology to streamline service efficiency—such as automated ordering and payment processing—can also help reduce reliance on traditional tipping structures. Restaurant owners and executives should continuously monitor industry trends and be prepared to adjust their approach, whether that means modifying service charges, refining tipping policies, or adopting a hybrid model that balances guest and staff expectations.

Where Do We Go From Here?

The restaurant industry is at a tipping point—pun intended.

With customers resisting automatic tips and operators struggling to retain employees, it’s clear that something has to change. But what’s the best way forward?

What do you think? Should restaurants eliminate tipping, raise wages, or find another solution? Join the conversation and share your thoughts!

?? Want to dive deeper into the tipping debate or discuss leadership challenges in hospitality? Let’s connect!

?? DM me or schedule a free 30-minute ‘Ask Me Anything’ session here: https://calendly.com/jason-e-brooks/30-minute-meeting

Or visit www.jasonebrooks.com to learn more!