The Timing Dilemma: To Sell or Stay with St James’ Place?

As a long-serving St James’ Place (SJP) practice principal, you may be contemplating whether now is the optimal time to sell your book of business. The financial landscape is volatile, and recent developments at SJP present a unique set of challenges and opportunities. Here’s a deep dive into the factors you should consider in making this critical decision.

Current State of SJP: A Snapshot

SJP, Britain’s largest wealth manager, faces significant scrutiny and financial pressure. Its share price has plummeted by almost 75% since its peak in late 2021, and 2023 saw the company turn a profit of ￡407 million into a ￡9.9 million loss. Investor confidence has been shaken , with over ￡3 billion pulled from its funds in the first quarter of 2024 alone.

The introduction of the FCA’s Consumer Duty rules has intensified the focus on SJP’s fee structures, compelling the firm to reduce product management fees and announce the elimination of exit fees by 2025 for new clients. However, these measures have yet to restore full market confidence.

Selling Now: The Peak of Valuation?

Given the current turbulence, selling your book of business now might secure a higher price than could be achievable in the near future. The potential relegation of SJP from the FTSE 100, compounded by the company’s ongoing financial woes and reputational challenges, could further depress valuations. By selling now, you could capitalise on the existing client base and the relative stability of your business before more adverse conditions take hold.

Staying the Course: The Long Game

Alternatively, you may feel you have several more years of productive economic activity ahead. In this case, riding out the current storm might be appealing, especially if you believe in SJP’s potential to turn around under new leadership. The firm has made promising steps by appointing Mark FitzPatrick as CEO and bringing in new talent to revamp its investment strategies and operational transparency.

The Best of Both Worlds: Diversification and Non-Intermediating Financial Planning

If you’re looking for a balanced approach, consider setting up a non-intermediating financial planning advice firm as a side hustle . This strategy offers multiple advantages:

1. Securing Your Future: Selling your SJP practice now can provide a financial cushion and allow you to invest in your new venture.
2. Leveraging Experience: Use your extensive knowledge and client relationships to offer generic financial planning advice, focusing on retirement coaching, cashflow modeling, and succession planning. This aligns with the needs of an aging client base moving from accumulation to decumulation.
3. Minimising Risks: Diversifying your professional endeavors can mitigate risks associated with the potential further decline of SJP.

Conclusion: Making the Strategic Choice

The decision to sell or stay hinges on your personal and professional goals, as well as your risk tolerance. Selling now might maximise immediate financial returns, but staying could offer long-term benefits if SJP successfully navigates its current challenges. Alternatively, diversifying into non-intermediating financial planning can provide stability and growth opportunities regardless of SJP’s fate.

The State of St James’ Place

SJP’s challenges are significant and multifaceted. From regulatory scrutiny to financial instability, the firm’s future hangs in a delicate balance. Recent leadership changes and strategic adjustments offer a glimmer of hope, but the path to recovery is fraught with uncertainty. For SJP practice principals, the current moment is pivotal—requiring careful consideration of both immediate and long-term strategies to secure personal and professional success.

Q&A: Navigating the Decision to Sell or Stay with St James’ Place

Q1: What is the current state of St James’ Place (SJP) and how does it affect practice principals?

A1: SJP, Britain’s largest wealth manager, is facing significant financial and reputational challenges . Its share price has dropped by nearly 75% since its peak in late 2021, and the company turned a profit of ￡407 million in 2022 into a ￡9.9 million loss in 2023. Additionally, over ￡3 billion has been withdrawn from its funds in early 2024. This turmoil, driven by regulatory scrutiny and changes to its fee structure, creates uncertainty for practice principals, potentially impacting the value and stability of their businesses.

Q2: Is now a good time to sell my book of business?

A2: Given the current volatility and the potential for further decline in SJP’s fortunes, now might be an optimal time to sell your book of business. The company’s financial difficulties and the risk of being removed from the FTSE 100 could further depress valuations. Selling now could allow you to capitalise on the current value of your business before conditions worsen.

Q3: What are the risks of holding onto my business for a few more years?

A3: Holding onto your business carries the risk of further declines in SJP’s valuation and potential regulatory challenges. While new leadership and strategic changes may offer a path to recovery, the firm’s ability to navigate these issues remains uncertain. Continued financial instability and reputational damage could negatively impact your practice’s value and growth prospects.

Q4: How can I balance my desire to continue working with the potential benefits of selling my practice now?

A4: One strategy is to sell your SJP practice now to secure a good price and simultaneously set up a non-intermediating financial planning advice firm as a side hustle. This approach allows you to leverage your experience and client relationships to offer retirement coaching, cashflow modeling, and succession planning, catering to an aging client base transitioning from accumulation to decumulation. This diversification provides financial security while enabling you to continue working in a different capacity.

Q5: What are the advantages of setting up a non-intermediating financial planning advice firm?

A5: Establishing a non-intermediating financial planning advice firm offers several benefits:

• Financial Security: Selling your SJP practice can provide a financial cushion.
• Leverage Expertise: You can utilise your extensive knowledge and client relationships to offer valuable generic financial planning services.
• Risk Mitigation: Diversifying your professional endeavors can reduce reliance on SJP’s fortunes and provide a stable income stream regardless of the company’s future.

Q6: What steps is SJP taking to address its current challenges?

A6: SJP has made several strategic moves to address its challenges, including reducing product management fees, eliminating exit fees for new clients by 2025, and setting aside ￡426 million to compensate investors for advice not received. The firm has also appointed a new CEO, Mark FitzPatrick, and brought in new talent to revamp its investment strategies and enhance transparency. While these steps are promising, the effectiveness of these measures in restoring market confidence and financial stability remains to be seen.

Q7: What should I consider when deciding whether to sell or stay?

A7: When making your decision, consider your personal and professional goals, risk tolerance, and the current and projected state of SJP. Selling now could maximise immediate financial returns, while staying might offer long-term benefits if SJP successfully navigates its challenges. Alternatively, diversifying into non-intermediating financial planning can provide stability and growth opportunities regardless of SJP’s future.

Q8: What is the outlook for SJP and its practice principals?

A8: The outlook for SJP is uncertain. While the firm is making efforts to address its challenges, the path to recovery is fraught with difficulties. Practice principals should carefully evaluate their options, considering both the potential benefits of selling now and the long-term prospects of staying with the firm. Diversifying into non-intermediating financial planning could offer a balanced approach to mitigate risks and secure future stability.

For further information on retiring from regulated to financial planning visit www.AcademyofLifePlanning.com .