Time to Tell? Directive Leadership

Time to Tell? Directive Leadership

The way we understand strong leadership has undergone a real transformation over the last decade or two. Traditional ideas about a military-like model of the authoritarian, hierarchical leader have been replaced by a more democratic, consultative ideal.

While nobody is advocating a return to autocracy, it is worth asking the question:

Has the pendulum swung too far?

Creating workplaces and cultures with engaged, autonomous teams that get results requires an intentional, considered approach to leadership communication. Getting people involved and engaged in strategy and change is the same.

Books on leadership all trend toward a facilitative, participatory communication style – encouraging us to ask, coach, enquire and empower. These are critical skills for an emotionally aware leader, especially in the long term.

However, there’s still an important place for leaders who tell, particularly in times of change and uncertainty. People aren’t afraid of change – but they do struggle with uncertainty. In the most uncertain of times, teams need as much clarity as possible about what’s coming and what will be required of them – and a failure to provide that can lead to disengagement, cynicism and insecurity.

“There’s still an important place for leaders who tell, particularly in times of change and uncertainty”

I’m current working with a team of senior public leaders to roll out a new strategic direction, who are finding new ways to manage change communication. Rather than assuming that high participation is intrinsically ‘good’, the team has been experimenting with a full toolkit. Together, we are learning that authenticity in leadership means respecting the time, intelligence and needs of your team - by being honest and respectful about the scope for involvement at different stages of the change process. 

In some role-playing exercises for this last week, it was surprising how many of us found it initially difficult to stand up and say things like “Here’s what we need to do” and “These are my expectations of you.” Even more surprising was the reaction of the others in the room – “I felt safe” “I appreciated the clarity”.

“A genuine leader is not a searcher for consensus, but a molder of consensus” Martin Luther King, Jr.

In times of urgency, uncertainty, or compliance, facilitative leadership can be damaging. Not only because it provokes further unease, but because it can be seen as disingenuous. Over the last 20 years, the public sector has been increasingly encouraged to consult and engage with their communities over policy and direction. This has been largely positive – except when it hasn’t. Communities aren’t stupid. They know when you are ‘consulting’ for compliance rather than participation. And your teams are the same.

The IAP2 Spectrum of Public Participation has six steps – from inform, all the way through to empower. The initial thinking behind the spectrum was as a guide to select the appropriate level of engagement to suit the task at hand – but somewhere along the line, we got the idea that more participation is always better. Operating at the ‘empower’ end of the spectrum demands a huge amount of time and effort from leaders, from staff, and from communities and should be used in circumstances that would genuinely benefit from that level of participation, not as a blunt force instrument.

No alt text provided for this image

Using the right tool for the job is critical in a changing, ambiguous environment. Knowing when to tell can be the difference between aligned teams with a clear sense of purpose, or uncertain, disengaged teams who are struggling to take charge of their roles.

Directive leadership looks like this:

  • Setting clear goals and expectations
  • Providing information
  • ‘Bottom lines’
  • Defined roles and responsibilities
  • Planning and scheduling
  • Monitoring and accountability
  • Guiding and showing expertise.

Are you asking, when you should be telling?

When to Tell:

  • In times of great uncertainty
  • When there is no real scope for change (compliance)
  • Under urgency
  • When facing new or unexpected challenges
  • When teams have low autonomy or experience
  • To set the boundaries of a new strategy or approach.
Alison Flett

Customer Experience Manager at Waikato Regional Council

5 å¹´

Good article and very true. There is a time "for telling" and, as with anything, the words you use and the manner in which you "tell" is as important as the information.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Alicia McKay的更多文章

  • For when it feels like you can't change anything

    For when it feels like you can't change anything

    This is a teaser for my latest Wednesday Wisdom over on Substack. You'll get to the juicy bit with the 'what to do now'…

    2 条评论
  • Stay alive in 2025: Why strategy is a survival skill this year

    Stay alive in 2025: Why strategy is a survival skill this year

    Note: This is a Wednesday Wisdom newsletter, which is sent directly to subscribers every Wednesday morning NZ time. If…

    32 条评论
  • Reclaiming my attention and pushing out the middleman

    Reclaiming my attention and pushing out the middleman

    In July 2018, I sent out my first Wednesday Wisdom newsletter to 28 subscribers. Six years later, I'm still sending out…

    15 条评论
  • Joining the Dots: How Systems Thinking Helps Leaders Drive Organisational Change

    Joining the Dots: How Systems Thinking Helps Leaders Drive Organisational Change

    These days, it feels like everyone is in a continuous loop of organisational change - every leader I know is currently…

    8 条评论
  • How to Run An Eight Week Strategy Sprint: Leadership Away Days

    How to Run An Eight Week Strategy Sprint: Leadership Away Days

    Strategy is your most important job Strategy is the most important job of any leader. It's why we have leaders.

  • 3 Excellent Reasons to Leave Traditional Employment

    3 Excellent Reasons to Leave Traditional Employment

    If you've caught the news in the last year, you might be wising up to the false security of employment and starting to…

    5 条评论
  • What To Do Before You Quit Your Job and Go Consulting

    What To Do Before You Quit Your Job and Go Consulting

    What should you do before you leave your job to start your own consulting business? What boxes do you need to tick, and…

    5 条评论
  • How to Do Scary Things

    How to Do Scary Things

    Being a person is pretty scary, to be honest. If you're a mildly anxious human like me, you might face a frequent war…

    4 条评论
  • Something A Little Different - Friday Flurry: Travel, Skin, and Being A Kid

    Something A Little Different - Friday Flurry: Travel, Skin, and Being A Kid

    Introductory Note: This Friday Flurry is published on my Substack. If you're subscribed to the Not An MBA newsletter…

    9 条评论
  • Introducing: Current Fad

    Introducing: Current Fad

    A fortnightly newsletter featuring the thought flurries and temporary fixations of Alicia McKay, hosted on Substack…

    4 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了