They think it's all over ......

They think it's all over ......

The UK voted on Thursday in a referendum that resulted in 52% of those voting deciding to leave the EU.  There has been no end of posts on what this means for the UK economy and even for the EU and the global economies.  I have yet to find a good outlook, but suffice to say, that aspect has been thoroughly covered. 

Also of note is - what are the next steps from here?  Well, we now know that there will be a leadership election within the Conservative party.  The winner will become PM.  The new PM will then have the power to invoke Article 50, just as Cameron could have done last week.  And the power to not do so, just as Cameron did last week.  Cameron has already reneged on his promise to invoke Article 50, and done a runner.  He did not follow the “will of the people” and nor is any subsequent Prime Minister required to do so.  The new PM probably will at some point, but if he or she has even an once of wit, they will use the one card they have left to negotiate with the EU, either to get better terms to remain or to get better terms on leaving.

In the meantime the UK is still part of the EU.   Jean-Claude Juncker has already said he wants the UK to leave quickly.  Well, guess what?  The UK has just said it is not going to be pushed around by Eurocrats, and handed a red hot mandate to the next PM to tell the EU, and associated representatives, where to go.  Mr Juncker,’s currency is worth less than the pound right now, so he might want to step down before making any more of a fool of himself.  Merkel, ever an ally to the UK has slapped him down.  It seems to be contagious.  However, this just gives the next PM an even stronger hand in any negotiations, be that to negotiate better terms to stay or to negotiate better terms to leave.

Hollande has already had to meet Le Pen, and Euro-sceptics in every member state are queuing up to stake their claims.  If the EU is to avoid a series of referendums, then they need to manage the UK and its exit.  France and Germany in particular will be highly motivated to renegotiate terms to encourage the UK to remain.  So, the game is not yet over.

The new PM haas a range of options when he or she comes into office.  

  1. The new PM invokes article 50 and begins he process of leaving the EU.  From this point there is no way back.  The UK will leave the EU and begin a new era for itself, and quite possibly, for the whole of the EU.  This is probably the most likely outcome if Michael Gove is elected to lead the Conservative party.
  2. The new PM returns to re-engage and renegotiate with the EU.  He or she will have two more cards than David Cameron had in that he can invoke Article 50 at any point, and more importantly, he can remind everyone at the table that they have agitated people at home who are looking for a referendum of their own on EU membership.  This can not be ignored forever, and even Joncker is beginning to understand this.  Bojo stated from the point of his declaration for Leave, that a vote Leave would provide a stronger negotiating tool to confront the EU, and so he might well be interested in this approach.  From here the new PM has a range of options:
    • Come back to the public and say that there has not been enough compromise, and move to invoke Article 50.
    • Come back to the people and say that there has been enough of a compromise and decide to continue with membership.
    • Go to parliament for a decision.
    • Hold another referendum.  There is a strong case for this outcome.  Millions in the UK have already signed a petition calling for a further referendum.  Farage had stated that he would continue to fight for a further referendum if he lost with 48%, so has little moral ground to oppose it, which doesn’t mean he wont.  However, Farage has little power at Westminster and wasn’t even fully engaged in the Vote Leave team.  This leads to two possible outcomes
      1. In this case there is a strong possibility of a Remain result.  Then the UK would stay in the EU.  Until the next referendum.
      2. There is obviously a possibility of a second Leave vote.  More people could be drawn to vote Leave in response to being “bullied” into a second vote.  In this case there would be no choice but to take the UK out of the EU.
  3. The new PM does the honourable thing and calls an early election.  Why is that the “honourable thing”?  Well, mainly because that’s what the Conservative Party called upon Gordon Brown to do, when he took over.  Of course, there is no obligation to call an early general election, and this probably wont happen.  However, if the new PM does, then from here anything can happen.  
    • The Conservatives could win a larger majority, taking votes from UKIP and even labour, and take us back to options 1 and 2 above
    • There is a hung parliament or Labour are returned.  In either case it is unlikely that the UK would leave the UK without a further Referendum, which is covered in 2 above.
  4. Whilst the least likely, it is entirely possible that the new PM says that the UK is staying in the EU.  It is difficult to envisage this scenario, but it is technically possible.  The referendums no authority in UK law.

The point is that this is not the end.  There are a whole range of options open to the next PM, who would be advised not to rush into anything.  The EU, if it were not already, is now in disarray.  Stay or Leave the next PM has an obligation to operate in the best interests of the UK, and that means holding back on Article 50 to get the best deal from the EU.  We also need to be very clear here too.  The EU has a strong incentive to make leaving as difficult for the UK as possible.  They genuinely do need to demonstrate to their respective electorates that leaving the EU is economically damaging.  Many EU states are under pressure to hold referenda on membership and they want to a) avoid such a vote and b) at least win the vote.  If they can point to declining UK GDP growth and increasing unemployment, then that will help to make their case.  If that hurts them in the process, well they can blame it on the UK leaving.  This is not spiteful, or malicious.  It is not self-defeating if they genuinely believe that a breakup of the EU is a bad thing.  It then becomes the responsible thing to do.

They think it is all over, but this is only half time; and there is only one score in it.

 

 

 

 

One branch cut from the tree, and a couple more sprout forth. Not worth an update at this point. Not sure how Labour imploding alters the possible outcomes. Maybe it makes a Labour victory in an election less likely.

回复
Stephen Mitchell

Non Executive Director Investment Trusts. Trustee and chair of investment committee for charities

8 年

possible.

回复
Dr. Chris Donegan

Sceptical Empiricist.

8 年

From a straw poll I conducted yesterday it seems that many people voted "leave" secure in the knowledge that theirs was a protest vote and are now horrified at the consequences. I don't think a referendum held today would have the same outcome. For once people's votes did actually count and unused to this state of affairs many people misused them. I agree that many people do feel disenfranchised but I think that the primary reason for this is because of the irreversible evolution of open markets and globalisation that exposes the limitations of national governments, the criticality and weakness of education and the irrelevance of nation state thinking. That's a lot of culture shock and elicits a gut reaction "No". The world is changing and we can either get on board, engage and participate or pretend it's not happening. The latter strategy is not very successful judging from history.

Charles Ashwanden

Helping Asset Managers and Vendors work more effectively together

8 年

I tend to agree with much of this Stephan, although I am convinced that the man in the street was misled (and mis-lead!) by both main parties of politicians. If the resulting economic outcome of leaving the European Union had been spelled out, ie 'if you make someone or do anything that is bought overseas then you may well lose your job, your house value will fall/rent increase and the quality of public service you recieve will drop' with simple evidence that was easy to prove valid, this might have been avoided. As the options now narrow and markets continue to fall, my suspicion is that the only credible political resolution to this will be the acceleration of a new leader for the conservative party and the announcement of a general election where part of the mandate promises from the main parties will be the renegotiation of the relationship with Europe (on the terms that you discuss) This should also (superficially) deal with the breakdown of trust Alan Patterson FRICS mentions. The sooner that this end game is decided and announced, the sooner the markets and economies will stabilize. It will not solve the endemic dis-enfranchisement of the poor and the elderly, but it may buy more time for the countries facing problems to look more closely at the underlying issues creating the underclass and start planning structural reform to help rather than treating the symptoms.

Alan Patterson FRICS

Real Estate Economist and Strategic Investment Advisor at VARE Consulting Ltd

8 年

Stephen, you are confusing politics with ethics. It is because many of the working population (particularly those of the poor) believe that politicians no longer respond to their concerns that they voted Leave. You are addressing the symptons and not the causes. Restoring the credibility of the political class is, unfortunately, something that will be difficult and take a long time.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Stephan Breban的更多文章

  • Jamaican Rugby

    Jamaican Rugby

    Jamaica is one of the smaller nations in rugby circles. While there is incredible talent, there is little support for…

    5 条评论
  • Girls rugby

    Girls rugby

    Women's and girls rugby is one of the fastest areas of growth in sport. Women's sport is broadly growing rapidly.

    8 条评论
  • The Fermi Paradox – has 2020 provided the answer?

    The Fermi Paradox – has 2020 provided the answer?

    If there are billions of planets in each galaxy capable of supporting life, then millions of intelligent species are…

  • Be a part of HER success story by giving today!

    Be a part of HER success story by giving today!

    No African woman should be denied the opportunity to learn and soar. Yielding Accomplished African Women (YAA W) is a…

    5 条评论
  • Lest we forget

    Lest we forget

    On November 7th, 1920, in strictest secrecy, four unidentified British bodies were exhumed from temporary battlefield…

    6 条评论
  • Millennials – an age-old problem

    Millennials – an age-old problem

    It’s Boxing Day. Good King Wenceslas looked out and I offload some of my frustrations of the year onto my LinkedIn…

    4 条评论
  • 2017 Words/phrases of the year

    2017 Words/phrases of the year

    2017 Words/phrases of the year Youthquake - a significant cultural, political, or social change arising from the…

  • Uninhabitable Earth

    Uninhabitable Earth

    There is a very real danger that the earth is already heading for an extinction event. It actual fact this could go…

    1 条评论
  • "I wish I'd spent more time at work."

    "I wish I'd spent more time at work."

    These are the dying words of absolutely no-one. People often regret the lack of time spent with their families, and…

    4 条评论
  • African tech is exciting, and everywhere you look, so why not experience the real thing?

    African tech is exciting, and everywhere you look, so why not experience the real thing?

    African tech is this season’s black. Conferences are sprouting up everywhere, across Europe, across the US and of…

    6 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了