Testing job application AI bots
Screen capture of the job matches and applications Massive performed for me

Testing job application AI bots

I tried out this job application bot, Massive , which was mentioned in an NPR segment on AI. I was hopeful that it could help speed and broaden my job search.

The TL;dr version is: don't waste your money. It's not ready for prime time yet. Here's why:

  1. The mid-range subscription level isn't customized. The $39/month "Massive" version doesn't enable customization or communication, so it's ONLY sending your standard résumé, not even a cover letter with it. You can, however, pay more for customization--which I would have done, if the bot performed as promised. Note there is also a free "Passive" subscription level, which automatically applies to every job that matches your criteria.
  2. It doesn't apply to 50 jobs a week, as promised. The claim that it applies to up to 50 jobs a week (20 during the trial) is 100% bogus. It claims to send new applications every one to three days; my experience did not support that claim. I chose 17 jobs to apply to ten days ago, and it has applied to a total of two of those jobs for me. I can and do apply faster and better on my own. And I customize my résumé and cover letter to the job.
  3. Support is practically nonexistent. When I discovered that there was the option to pay monthly instead of quarterly and to pay more for customization, I messaged on its chat three times over four days to asking about changing my subscription. I didn't get a response until four days later, when the rep told me they were behind but had a big revamp coming on Tuesday (yesterday), when everything would be so much better. (Narrator: It wasn't.)

Massive bot only applied to two positions over 10 days

Despite the fact that the user who tried it for the NPR segment said he got a 5-10% interview rate, that has definitely not been my experience.

It's really a shame, because this is EXACTLY the type of thing that AI is perfect for: feed in four or five versions of my résumé and three hundred cover letters, and apply to jobs for me. Kinda wish I had the programming skills to develop my own bot!

Has anyone tried a job application bot you DO like? I'd like to try a few more and write about my experience.

David Dzien, Jr., MBA

Vice President, Change Management Operations Analysis

1 个月

I firmly believe that the rise of AI Job Application bots is a response to the de-hoodwinking of the applicant population; the revelation that the EDI/AI-powered automatic review (dismissal) of applications based overwhelmingly on heuristics and not human review coupled with the growing population of "pipeline requisitions" that do not actually reflect real openings. It's a terrible but equal response to the abject failure of HR practices that have led us here.

A thought --- don't use AI tools...actually use AI. We saw this post and whipped up a quick Job Application Agent in about 10 minutes that does a few things automatically: https://app.kindo.ai/workstation?workflowId=45ea3065-283c-4856-98ea-4704c83c600f&chatId=clv6sp4yb00ailahxdvqrssk0&type= You can use Kindo for free at www.kindo.ai and build any agent you want to do what you want it to do in the way. you want it to!

Shannon Atkinson

DevOps & Automation Expert | Kubernetes, Docker, CI/CD Pipelines, Terraform | Cloud Specialist (AWS, Azure, GCP) | AI & ML Innovator | Patent Holder & Certified Jenkins Engineer

7 个月

Exploring AI for job applications sounds like an interesting experiment.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了