Tesla's Growth Hits a Roadblock: Is the End of the Dream Run Near?

Tesla's stock has skyrocketed by 62% in the past six months, especially after the 2024 US presidential elections. Investors seem to be banking on Elon Musk’s relationship with President Trump, hoping their work on autonomous and electric vehicles will fuel the company’s future. But here’s the catch: despite the political optimism, demand for Tesla’s vehicles is starting to level off. No amount of political influence can fix this fundamental challenge—Tesla's growth story may be running out of road.

Tesla's Disappointing Deliveries: A Reality Check

Tesla, which has long been considered the undisputed leader in the EV space, has seen its deliveries stagnate. In its fourth-quarter 2024 report, Tesla disclosed that it delivered 495,570 vehicles, falling short of analysts' expectations of 512,300 vehicles. This marked the first time in a decade that Tesla’s delivery numbers were down year-on-year. Its total vehicle deliveries for 2024 were 1.79 million, a decline from 1.81 million in 2023.

It’s important to note that Tesla’s growth had been extraordinary from 2020 to 2023. The company’s deliveries shot up from 499,550 in 2020 to 1.81 million in 2023.?

However, 2024 was the first year the company reported a decline in deliveries, signaling that the rapid growth Tesla enjoyed over the past few years may have reached its peak. This drop is even more concerning when you consider that Tesla added the Cybertruck to its lineup in late 2023, which was expected to drive sales higher.?

On the surface, this dip might seem insignificant. But for a company like Tesla—one that's relied on rapid growth to validate its sky-high valuation—it raises some red flags. And here's something to keep in mind: Tesla, now a $1.3 trillion company, is worth more than the next 20 largest automakers combined, according to S&P Global Market Intelligence. That’s a hefty gap.

For Tesla, vehicle sales account for about 80% of its revenue. The company’s reliance on this segment underscores the importance of maintaining strong sales. Without consistent growth in deliveries, Tesla's future as a growth stock could be in jeopardy.

The Broader EV Market Struggles: What’s Contributing to Tesla’s Slowdown?

To fully understand why Tesla is struggling, we need to take a step back and examine the broader EV market. 2024 has been a year of slower growth for EVs in general, and Tesla, despite its innovative edge, is not immune to these challenges.

One of the most significant factors is the macroeconomic environment. With interest rates at historic highs, consumers’ ability to finance large purchases, like electric vehicles, has been severely constrained. Car loans have become more expensive, and consumers are increasingly wary of making big-ticket purchases, especially as economic uncertainty looms. This has had a direct impact on demand for premium vehicles, where Tesla’s offerings predominantly sit.

Alongside interest rates, inflation continues to erode purchasing power, making discretionary spending harder to sustain. These economic pressures are felt more acutely in major economies like the U.S. and Europe, where Tesla has a significant presence. Rising energy costs and higher raw material prices for batteries are pushing up production costs for EVs, further compounding Tesla’s challenges in maintaining its margins.

Tesla and BYD: Two-Speed Global Transition

One of the most significant trends we’re seeing in the electric vehicle (EV) market is the stark contrast between China and the West. China is far outpacing the West in the transition to electric vehicles, and local players like BYD are benefiting from this rapid growth. In fact, BYD achieved a record-breaking sales year in 2024, selling 4.3 million electric vehicles and hybrids globally—well above the company’s initial target of 3.6 million. Notably, BYD’s sales of 1.76 million pure EVs in 2024 were nearly on par with Tesla’s global sales. Other Chinese automakers, such as Li Auto (500,000 units) and Leapmotor (290,000 units), also performed strongly.

China’s EV Revolution: A Game-Changer for the Industry

In 2020, President Xi Jinping approved a strategy to make “new energy vehicles” (NEVs), which include both plug-in hybrids and pure electric cars, account for 20% of China’s passenger car sales by 2025. China has far surpassed this target, with NEV sales overtaking those of combustion-engine vehicles in the second half of 2024. BYD, which now controls over a third of the domestic electric and hybrid car market, has been a leader in reducing the cost of EVs. The company’s lowest-cost electric car is priced under $10,000, and analysts estimate BYD’s production costs for EVs are 50% lower than those of European competitors, thanks to economies of scale, vertical integration, and local supply chains.

While Tesla is a major player in China, its sales growth in the region has been slower compared to the overall market. Tesla saw a 9% increase in sales in China last year, but this is well behind the near 40% growth rate of the Chinese EV market as a whole.

Western Market Challenges: Slowing Growth and Rising Competition

In the U.S., Tesla has been losing market share as other automakers have entered the electric vehicle market. Tesla’s U.S. market share in EVs fell below 50% for the first time in Q2 2024. Although EV sales continue to grow in the U.S., the pace of growth has slowed significantly. The share of EVs in new car sales in the U.S. rose from 3.4% in late 2021 to nearly 8% in late 2023, but it dipped below that level in the subsequent quarters. Affordability is a key concern, with carmakers struggling to close the price gap between electric and petrol-powered cars. Additionally, higher interest rates have made consumers more hesitant to pay the extra cost.

In Europe, EV adoption is higher, with EVs accounting for nearly 20% of car sales in the U.K. and around 12% of sales in the EU. However, EV sales in the EU fell by 6% in the first nine months of 2024, driven by weaker government subsidies. This has been particularly evident in Germany, where sales dropped by more than a quarter.

The Rise of Hybrid Vehicles

While hybrids were once seen as a compromise, they are now gaining traction, especially in markets where electric charging infrastructure is still developing. In the U.S., sales of non-plug-in hybrids surged, reaching 10.6% of the light vehicle market in Q3 2024. In China, plug-in hybrid sales increased by 70% in the first half of 2024, capturing a 42% share of the NEV market. BYD, the world’s largest producer of plug-in hybrids, is poised to benefit from this trend, with 2.5 million hybrids sold in 2024, compared to 1.8 million pure EVs.

Tesla, which has firmly committed to battery-powered electric vehicles, does not benefit from the growth in hybrid sales.?

Financial Struggles: A Decline in Profit Margins and Revenue Growth

Tesla’s financials in 2024 paint a concerning picture. While the company’s total revenue for the year increased to $97.2 billion, it grew by less than 1% year-over-year. This marks a sharp contrast to Tesla’s previous years of rapid revenue growth, and the stagnation is a clear warning sign for investors.

The company’s gross profit for the year remained flat at $17.7 billion, and its gross margin has been compressed to just 20%, down significantly from previous years. The operating income fell by 9% to $8.1 billion, and operating margins dipped by 90 basis points. More alarmingly, Tesla’s net income also saw a decline in 2024, signaling that the company is finding it harder to convert its revenue into profits.

This financial stagnation is a reflection of both the broader market slowdown and Tesla’s internal challenges. Although production efficiency has improved over the years, the rising costs of materials, especially lithium and nickel, which are integral to EV batteries, have placed a significant strain on Tesla’s profitability. Additionally, price cuts on certain models in a bid to stay competitive have hurt Tesla’s bottom line.

Tesla’s Strategic Response: Can the Innovation Giant Turn Things Around?

In response to these challenges, Tesla has ramped up its efforts to expand its product lineup and enter new markets. One of the most notable developments is Tesla’s plans to introduce a $25,000 compact sedan, which would target the mass market and significantly broaden Tesla’s appeal. If successful, this model could help the company regain its competitive edge by appealing to a price-sensitive consumer base, particularly in emerging economies like India and Southeast Asia.

Tesla is also increasing its investments in global expansion. The company is working to expand its presence in India, where the EV market is still in its infancy but shows significant growth potential. In addition, Tesla is scaling up production at its Gigafactories in Berlin, Austin, and Shanghai, which will allow it to reduce production costs and make its vehicles more affordable.

What Investors are Hoping for: The Trump Factor

Investors are pinning some of their hopes on the potential impact of the Trump administration’s policies. Elon Musk has a close relationship with Trump, and many investors believe that regulatory changes under a Republican administration could benefit Tesla. For example, Trump’s stance on autonomous vehicles—particularly his push for deregulation—could make it easier for Tesla to deploy its autonomous technology. Some analysts even speculate that Musk’s relationship with Trump could help Tesla navigate the ongoing US-China tensions, given the company’s significant presence in China.

However, not all analysts are convinced that these political factors will have a meaningful impact on Tesla’s growth. For one, Trump has indicated that he intends to reduce government incentives for EVs, including the $7,500 tax credit that benefits Tesla. While this might hurt competitors, it could also make Tesla’s vehicles less affordable in the US, potentially dampening demand.

Moreover, if Tesla fails to deliver on its promises of fully autonomous driving, any regulatory changes around AVs may not have the desired effect. For now, the Trump factor is more speculative than concrete, and it’s unlikely that any political shift will solve Tesla’s immediate challenges of slowing demand and increasing competition.

Tesla’s Stock Premium: Is It Justified or Overblown?

Tesla’s stock is currently trading at a hefty 126 times its projected earnings for the next year—three times higher than Nvidia, despite both being at the forefront of technological innovation. Even if you were to value Tesla as an AI company, its premium seems excessive. The EV maker, which has faced a tough year in terms of car sales, still saw its stock surge by 63% in 2024, pushing its market cap to $1.2 trillion—more than the next 20 largest automakers combined. This raises a big question: Can Tesla justify its sky-high valuation when its core business is facing challenges, and its competitors, like BYD and GM, are gaining traction?

The Road Ahead: Is Tesla’s Growth Story Over?

The road ahead for Tesla in 2025 remains unclear. While the company has laid out ambitious plans to innovate and expand, it faces significant challenges on multiple fronts. The broader economic environment, fierce competition, and pricing pressures will continue to test Tesla’s ability to maintain its market dominance.

However, Tesla’s track record of innovation—coupled with its continued progress in autonomous driving and energy storage solutions—means that it is not out of the game just yet. The next few quarters will be critical for the company, as it attempts to navigate these headwinds and prove that its growth story is far from over.

This article draws from sources such as Financial Times, Bloomberg, Forbes, Seeking Alpha and other reputed media houses. Please note, this blog post is intended for general educational purposes only and does not serve as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation to buy or sell any securities. It may contain forward-looking statements, and actual outcomes can vary due to numerous factors. Past performance of any security does not guarantee future results.This blog is for informational purposes only. Neither the information contained herein, nor any opinion expressed, should be construed or deemed to be construed as solicitation or as offering advice for the purposes of the purchase or sale of any security, investment, or derivatives.The information and opinions contained in the report were considered by VF Securities, Inc.to be valid when published. Any person placing reliance on the blog does so entirely at his or her own risk, and does not accept any liability as a result.Securities markets may be subject to rapid and unexpected price movements, and past performance is not necessarily an indication of future performance. Investors must undertake independent analysis with their own legal, tax, and financial advisors and reach their own conclusions regarding investment in securities markets.Past performance is not a guarantee of future results