Tenured Teams: Don’t lose your new hire

You take pride in your organization’s tenured leadership team—a group of seasoned professionals who have worked together for years, fostering a strong sense of cohesion, trust, and shared history. This deep-rooted team dynamic can be a tremendous asset, but when it comes time to incorporate a new leader, it can also pose unique challenges. Without careful consideration, your tight-knit team might unintentionally create barriers to the successful integration of the newcomer. Here, we’ll explore practical strategies to ensure that your new leader feels welcomed and empowered to succeed, while also identifying common pitfalls to avoid.

Onboarding Buddy: A Trusted Guide

One of the most effective ways to help a new leader acclimate is to assign them an onboarding buddy—someone who is not their direct supervisor or official HR contact. This person should be a well-respected team member with a deep understanding of the organization’s culture and operations, not an intern or an entry level associate.

The onboarding buddy serves multiple roles: they are a guide, a sounding board, and a source of informal knowledge. They can provide the new leader with the nuances of how the organization operates, including the purpose and expectations for different meetings, insights into team dynamics, and an understanding of various working styles within the organization. This informal mentorship helps the new leader quickly learn the ropes and avoid common missteps that could stem from misunderstandings.

Daily check-ins with the onboarding buddy in the first few weeks are crucial. These meetings offer a safe space for the new leader to ask questions, provide feedback, and discuss any challenges they’re facing. Over time, as the new leader becomes more comfortable, these check-ins can taper off, but they should remain available as needed.

Shadowing C-Suite Leaders

Another valuable integration strategy is to allow the new leader to shadow other C-suite executives. Shadowing offers a behind-the-scenes look at how different leaders within the organization approach their roles, make decisions, and interact with their teams. This exposure is particularly beneficial in a tenured team where established leaders have developed their unique styles over the years.

Through shadowing, the new leader can gain insights into the organization's leadership culture and begin to identify where their approach may need to adapt or where they can introduce new ideas. It’s also an opportunity for the new leader to build relationships with their peers, laying the foundation for future collaboration and mutual respect. Encouraging this practice sends a clear message that the organization values learning and cross-functional understanding, setting the tone for a collaborative and inclusive leadership team.

Celebrating Early Wins

Acknowledgment and celebration of early successes can have a powerful impact on a new leader’s integration. These moments, no matter how small, help to validate the leader’s contributions and reinforce that they are on the right track.

When the new leader achieves an early win—whether it’s a successful project, a well-received idea, or a positive change in team dynamics—take the time to recognize it. Public recognition, even in small team meetings, can go a long way in making the new leader feel appreciated and supported. This positive reinforcement encourages them to continue bringing fresh ideas to the table and to contribute meaningfully to the organization’s success.

Avoid Comparisons with Their Predecessor

One of the most common and damaging pitfalls when bringing in a new leader is the tendency to compare them to their predecessor. It’s natural to draw comparisons, especially if the previous leader was well-liked or highly effective. However, this can be incredibly detrimental to the new leader’s ability to succeed.

It’s important to remember that you hired this new leader to achieve specific results, not to replicate the style or approach of the previous person in the role. Give them the space to operate in their way, even if it’s different from what your team is used to. Avoid carrying over any negative experiences or “trauma” from the last leader—each person brings a unique set of skills and perspectives, and they should be judged on their merit.

Focus on the outcomes, not the process. As long as the new leader is driving the organization toward its goals, allow them the freedom to do so in a way that aligns with their strengths. This approach not only empowers the new leader but also fosters a culture of innovation and continuous improvement within your leadership team.

Inclusive Engagement from Day One

Incorporating a new leader into an established team requires intentional inclusivity from the very beginning. As a tenured team, it’s easy to assume that a new leader will find their way, but this approach often leaves them feeling isolated and unsure of their role.

The responsibility of inclusion lies with the existing leadership. From the outset, make a concerted effort to involve the new leader in key meetings, projects, and discussions. Don’t wait for them to ask to be included—take proactive steps to ensure they are part of the conversation. This not only helps them get up to speed but also demonstrates that their input is valued. Inclusive engagement fosters a sense of belonging and ensures that the new leader quickly becomes an integral part of the team.

Breaking Established Patterns

When a team has been together for a long time, it’s natural to fall into familiar patterns. These patterns can manifest in many ways—whether it’s going to the same people for advice, assigning tasks based on historical roles, or simply relying on the comfort of established relationships. However, these habits can unintentionally marginalize a new leader, making it harder for them to integrate into the team.

To combat this, it’s important to consciously break these patterns. Make a deliberate effort to include the new leader in decision-making processes, project assignments, and strategic discussions. Trusting them with meaningful responsibilities early on is critical. It may take some adjustment, but giving the new leader the time and space to prove their capabilities is essential for building trust and confidence on both sides.

Conclusion

Integrating a new leader into a tenured leadership team requires careful planning, intentional inclusivity, and a willingness to break old patterns. By providing the right support systems, celebrating early successes, and avoiding harmful comparisons, you can help your new leader feel like a valued member of the team. This not only sets them up for success but also strengthens your organization as a whole, ensuring that it remains adaptable, innovative, and capable of navigating future challenges.

About Us

If you want to discuss how to hire top-tier leaders for your organization, reach out to me at? [email protected]. ?We will schedule a no-cost, no obligation 30-minute consultation to discuss how to meet your goals. If you are looking for a new career, visit our website to see positions that we are hiring or to add your resume to our Talent Network.

Maneva Group is a?woman and minority owned?national?Executive Search firm focusing on the social sector,?with expertise in completely managing the recruiting process, curating diverse and exceptionally qualified candidate pools,?and advising C-suite executives and board members through crucial hiring decisions.??

?

?

?