If a team runs itself for six months while you hire a manager, you shouldn't be hiring; you should be promoting

Leadership remains a topic of continual interest and debate in today's fast-paced business environment. Yet, one of the most undervalued aspects of leadership is recognizing innate leadership qualities within a team that may function perfectly well without a designated leader. So, what happens when a team runs itself efficiently for an extended period, such as six months? Conventional wisdom may argue that hiring an external manager to 'stabilize' the team is the perfect opportunity for internal promotion rather than external hiring.

Recognizing Leadership from Within: A Closer Examination

Recognizing leadership from within is multifaceted, with several dimensions extending beyond the traditional understanding of managerial prowess. It delves deep into the symbiotic relationship between individual capabilities and organizational ethos, making the case for internal promotion more compelling than ever.

Deep Organizational Understanding

One of the most significant assets of promoting from within is an internal candidate's comprehensive grasp of company culture, workflow, and mission. This knowledge is not acquired overnight but results from years of immersion in the corporate milieu, contributing to a profound understanding of the subtle and explicit nuances that define the organization.

Strategic Alignment: This deep-seated understanding ensures that the internal leader can make decisions that are strategically aligned with the company's long-term vision. They are in a position to foresee how a specific choice will reverberate across different departments or how it aligns with the corporate strategy, ensuring cohesive and intelligent decision-making.

Cultural Sensitivity: An internal candidate is culturally sensitive to the established norms and values within the company. This sensitivity is invaluable when navigating complex projects that require a harmonious interplay between various stakeholders, both internal and external, thus reducing the risk of conflict and misunderstandings.

Follow Karthik K

Built-in Credibility

Another advantage of an internal promotion is the built-in credibility that the candidate brings to the leadership role. Team members are more likely to respect and follow someone they've worked with, especially when that individual has demonstrated their capabilities through past contributions.

Trust Factor: The element of trust is already established, which is crucial for open communication and team cohesion. This trust can be the glue that holds the team together in periods of change or crisis, enabling quick and effective problem-solving.

Skill Verification: The team has already had a chance to see this individual's skills in action. Whether it's technical expertise, crisis management, or the ability to inspire, these skills have been verified in a real-world setting, eliminating the 'trial and error' phase that often accompanies an external hire.

Sending a Strong Organizational Message

Promoting from within is a functional decision and a powerful message to the entire organization. It demonstrates a company’s commitment to employee growth and signals that excellence within the ranks is noticed and rewarded.

Incentive for Excellence: When team members see their colleagues being promoted, it is an intrinsic motivator. It reinforces the belief that hard work and loyalty are rewarded, creating an environment that encourages excellence.

Social Dynamics: Internal promotion capitalizes on existing social dynamics. Team members are more likely to be receptive to one of their own stepping up to take the reins, thus making the transition smoother and ensuring that group synergies are maintained or even enhanced.

Final Thoughts:

Teams that are capable of running themselves demonstrate qualities such as strong collaboration, clear communication, effective decision-making, and a high degree of ownership and accountability. They will likely have individuals with potential leadership qualities like initiative, responsibility, and the ability to influence and coordinate with others.

If such a team is meeting or exceeding its objectives consistently, it proves that they have harnessed their collective skills to deliver results effectively, even in the absence of a manager. This indicates a mature team dynamic that values collective success over individual glory.

Ultimately, a leader's role should be to cultivate potential leaders within their teams and provide opportunities for their growth. If a team can successfully run itself, it’s a testament to the fact that it already houses individuals capable of stepping into leadership roles. This should be recognized and leveraged for the growth of the team and the organization.

Agree?

Three questions serve as a cornerstone for any organization contemplating this issue:

• Are you underestimating the reservoir of talent and skill already existing in your current team?
• Does an impressive external resume blind you to the entrepreneurial vigor demonstrated by your team?
• Are you willing to invest long-term in your organization by endorsing the potential leadership from within?

Answers to these questions could redefine how you view leadership and its source, affecting your organization's long-term health and success.

Author: Karthik K