Taxmann Daily
Dear Reader,
Welcome to Taxmann.com | Newsletter – Reporting the Facts with Taxmann's Analysis. Today's Edition Brings You the Day's Most Pivotal Stories, Offering Clarity and Depth.
Supreme Court upholds ICAI's limit of 60 tax audits per CA; makes it effective from 01.04.2024
In the given case, the petitioners, who were Chartered Accountants, challenged the validity of Clause 6 of Guidelines No.1- CA(7)/02/2008 dated 08.08.2008 issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) under powers conferred by the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 (Act) on the ground that the same is illegal, arbitrary and violative of Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India.
The petitioners challenged the mandatory ceiling on the number of tax audits a Chartered Accountant can accept under Section 44AB of the Income Tax Act, 1961, as per Clause 6.0, Chapter VI of the Guidelines. They also seek to quash the disciplinary proceedings initiated by the Institute in line with these guidelines.
The Apex Court held that the Council of the ICAI had the legal competence to frame the Guideline restricting the number of tax audits a Chartered Accountant could carry out. The Court held that the ICAI was established to regulate the profession of chartered accountants, ensuring that the profession in the country maintains high professional ethics and renders quality service.
The power of the Council to regulate the profession of Chartered Accountants is not only in the interest of the Chartered Accountants but also in the interest of the public at large. As the Parliament may not always be able to amend the Schedules to the Act to incorporate newer professional misconducts, the Parliament has delegated the power to the Council to make any regulation or Guideline, the breach of which would amount to misconduct. Therefore, the regulation or Guideline issued by the Council, the breach of which would result in professional misconduct, being a part of clause 1 of Part II of the Second Schedule, must be read as part and parcel of the Act itself.
Accordingly, the Council of the Institute had the legal competence to frame the Guideline restricting the number of tax audits that a Chartered Accountant could carry out, which was initially thirty and later raised to forty-five and thereafter to sixty in an assessment year.
Further, the restriction on the number of tax audits that could be undertaken by practicing Chartered Accountants doesn't violate the right to practice the profession by a Chartered Accountant. It is a reasonable restriction and is protected under Article 19(6) of the Constitution. The Court observed that the power to control and impose taxes is a cornerstone of State sovereignty.
The restriction imposed by the ICAI on the number of tax audits that can be undertaken by a Chartered Accountant is not violative of Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. The restriction was imposed by the ICAI after taking into account the letter of CBDT and the CAG Report No. 32/2014. The restriction was imposed to eliminate the possibility of conducting tax audits in an insincere, unethical or unprofessional manner. The restriction was also supported by concerns and suggestions shared by experts and practitioners over a span of thirty years. It was imposed as the best conceivable and practical measure to rectify the targeted mischief and ensure the quality of tax audits conducted by the Chartered Accountants, which is in the general public's interest.
The idea of compulsory tax audits was neither an inherent part of the practice of a Chartered Accountant nor an essential function that could be claimed as a fundamental right under Article 19(1)(g). As carrying out compulsory tax audit under Section 44AB of the Income Tax Act,1961 is a 'privilege' & not a 'right' of a CA, the limit of 60 tax audits imposed by ICAI on every CA is to be upheld as it does not curtail the fundamental right of a CA to practice his profession.
If the Parliament, in its wisdom, at a certain future date, due to technological developments or any other reason, finds that expeditious and accurate assessments can be ensured without imposing on assessees the burden of additional requirements of the tax audit report and thereby deletes Section 44AB from the IT Act, 1961, it could not be possibly argued that the right under Article 19(1)(g) has been abridged.
Accordingly, the Court concluded that the limit of the maximum number of tax audits is valid and is not violative of Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution as it is a reasonable restriction on the right to practise the profession by a Chartered Accountant and is protected or justifiable under Article 19(6) of the Constitution. However, the Guidelines dated 08.08.2008 and its subsequent amendment are deemed not to be effective until 01-04-2024.
SC waives interest on tax dues on telcos resulting from its decision classifying Licence Fee as capital exp.
The Supreme Court, in the case of CIT v. Bharti Hexacom Ltd. [2023] 155taxmann.com 322 (SC) , overruled the Delhi High Court's ruling and held that payment of license fee to DoT under Telecom Policy, 1999 was capital in nature.
It was argued that this judgment necessitates new orders on interest payments for tax demands post-1999 Telecom Policy. This places a heavy burden on assessees from the 2000-2001 assessment year onwards, prompting them to seek a waiver of interest for this period.
Revenue objected to this submission by contending that now that the tax demand would have to be met by the Assessees, it is logical that the interest on the said demand would also have to be paid.
The Supreme Court observed that since the judgment of this Court was dated 16.10.2023, and having regard to the Telecom Policy, which commenced from the year 1999, the payment of interest for the period for which the tax demand is now to be met in respect of these cases stands waived.
The Supreme Court held that this order shall not be a precedent in any other case as this order has been passed, bearing in mind the peculiar facts of this case and having regard to the lapse of time in litigation before the Delhi High Court and Supreme Court.?
That's it from us for today!
We're keen on enhancing Your Taxmann.com | Newsletter Experience and would greatly value your input. Your feedback is pivotal in guiding our improvements. Could you spare a few moments to share your thoughts in the comments on how we might better serve your needs?
Taxmann.com | Research | Income Tax – Harness the Real Power
??85,000+ Case Laws with Integration and Headnotes/Case-Digest
Offers multiple filters and coverage from all courts
Includes 'three-line digest' for a quick overview of the case ratio
'Headnote' provides a summary of facts and ratio
'Case-digest' for detailed facts and ratio information
??Authentic, Amended & Updated Acts/Rules with Annotations & Integration
Features real-time updates of Income Tax Act/Rules and other allied Acts/Rules
Ensures authenticity and accuracy of information
Includes a 'See More' feature linking related Case Laws, Circulars, Notifications, Articles, etc.
??Authentic, Amended & Updated Forms
Covers Income-tax Forms, other Forms, Challans, Income-tax Returns, Models, and Drafts
Lists all ITRs & Forms as per Income-tax Rules
Includes various forms referred to in Income-tax Rules & allied Rules
??16,300+ Circulars & Notifications
Includes Circulars & Notifications from Income Tax Act/Rules and other allied Acts/Rules
Updated in real-time for the most current and authentic information
The 'See More' feature integrates relevant Case Laws, Sections, Articles, etc.
??9,500+ Articles
Provides insights into the grey areas of laws with articles/opinions from industry leaders
Features articles/opinions on the Income Tax Act & Allied Acts
??Income Tax Ready Referencer for Daily Tax Work
Offers access to various daily required tax information
Includes Tax Rates, Depreciation Rates, TDS and TCS Rates, Interest on Small Savings Schemes, and Cost Inflation Index
??10+ Commentaries
Provides in-depth, detailed write-ups on Income-tax Act provisions
Each commentary is divided into multiple chapters for easy reference
Authored by leading experts and updated after every Finance Act
??All-About? Income Tax Act
Trademarked feature for quick access to primary & secondary documents
Simplifies work by showing connected records in a single window for any selected Section of the Income-tax Act
??Latest News & Updates with Taxmann's Analysis
Know Income Tax Law news & updates in India within three minutes
Provides single-line and three-line summaries for quick understanding
Sourced from 1,000+ authentic & verified sources
Includes 'Most Viewed' stories, 'Editors Pick', and archival news with filters.
??Others
Finance Act – Repository of all Finance Acts since 1961, with amended & annotated sections
Finance Bill – Includes budget highlights, Finance Minister's speech, actual Bill, Memorandum, and Notes on Clauses
CBDT Explanatory Notes on Finance Acts – Circulars explaining amendments since 1961, accessible year-wise, subject-wise, and section-wise
Income Tax Reports – Access to 50+ reports from various committees on taxation law changes and recommendations
Subscribe Now and Transform the Way You Work! https://taxmann.social/Xy7an