Talent this and talent that! Where do all the average people work?
Plamen Ivanoff ?
Helping Recruitment Firms transition from transactional CV supply, to consultative Retained Recruitment
Talent this and talent that. Apparently, every company only recruits talented people these days, they even hire talented people called Talent Acquisition Managers to hire talented people for them. This raises a few points in my mind.
Most people are pretty average
Let us just reflect for a moment and consider that in reality, the vast majority, probably well in excess of 90%+ of the workforce of the world is at best average. That doesn’t mean they are not good at what they do, it just means that they aren’t especially gifted, they aren’t inspirational leaders, innovators or for that matter some kind of prodigy.
That diligent, gregarious and trustworthy Partner at KPMG didn't spring from the womb with an abacus in one hand and a set of annual accounts in the other.
The clinician at Boots wasn't solving complex biology equations at the age of 5 to the utter astonishment of their parents.
They are however loyal, hardworking, diligent and do their job to the best of their ability with the sincerest intentions. Many even take a great deal of pleasure from what they do, the people?they work with and for. They?ultimately ensure that an organisation functions correctly to achieve its goals and continues to be profitable.
Many people do this whilst working with pretty average colleagues reporting to average managers who in turn report into average directors with what are in reality average expectations for companies that more often than not fly under the radar of everyone else but their employees, customers and service providers.
This is a good thing, imagine a world where every company was led by a character like Gates, Bezos or Branson. As much as I admire their endeavour and achievements, I suspect it would be pretty awful.
I suppose fundamentally it's a nature-nurture debate. My experience leads me to believe that everyone is unique, everyone has a different set of expectations and needs and whilst nature (their DNA/Memes) will undoubtedly influence their potential (and the debate about which has the most influence was settled years ago, it's pretty much 50/50) ultimately you've either got a talent or you haven't.
Most haven't.
Following the monumentally captivating achievements of Emma Raducanu in the US Open at the age of 18, there is no doubt that Emma has an abundance of natural talent that combined with her personality traits and attitudes and some first-class coaching has elevated her rightfully to a World-Class Talent status.
So what is talent?
talented
(t?l?nt?d)
ADJECTIVE
Someone who is?talented?has a natural ability to do something well.
Natural means existing or innate, not manufactured or influenced by humankind.
What a bizarre world, what a twisted concept is nature to believe that someone is born with a natural talent to be an accountant, a recruiter, a travel agent?
领英推荐
There is a debate in the realms of football (soccer for American readers) that Lionel Messi is a naturally gifted footballer, he has biological and physiological advantages such as enhanced perception, balance, vision, hand/feet coordination that provides the basics to be an extremely natural footballer.
Ronaldo on the other hand may have some of those, but they have been enhanced significantly by coaching, dietary, physiological development and supplemented by his attitudes and aptitudes such as having an exceptional work ethic, tenacity, a can-do, must not fail, win at all cost mentality. We all witnessed his almost complete transformation within 2 years of joining Manchester United.
But both of these footballers are literally one in a million if not more. Despite the tens of thousands of aspiring tennis players with immense work ethics, an appetite and aptitude for learning and practice, few if any will achieve the heights of the sublimely talented Emma Raducanu. The term talent/talented is entirely justified.
The wholesale use of the word talent in every job advert, job description and even job title isn't. In fact, it is disingenuous, even harmful and counter-productive to the definition of the word and the to vast swathes of people discouraged from applying to those job adverts because they're just ordinary, average, hard-working and diligent employees.
Where do all the average companies get their talent from?
Most companies are on the face of it nothing other than average. You only have to walk through any town in England and everywhere you look there are hard-working, long-standing businesses providing great service at a reasonable price.
These stalwart businesses provide the mundane stuff that we all need, makes our economy and our daily lives possible. Most of these with the best will in the world will never ever be an Amazon, a Microsoft or similar. The truth is that the vast majority don’t even want to be. Primarily because?there isn’t a demand for?them to be anything other than?a reasonable business providing a much needed valued service or product at a price and in a way that their customers want.
But take a look at the world of work and all of these average companies must be bursting at the seams with frustrated?talented?employees desperately seeking that opportunity that will enable them to?unleash their potential, open the door to an abundance of recognition and riches.
From the Purchase Ledger Clerk to the Commercial Property Agent to the Butchers Assistant and the Store Manager, they must all be despondent, miserable and broken by the sheer lack of recognition for their burgeoning talent and potential. Their eyes must light up every time they see a job advert posted by a Talent Acquisition Manager looking for talented people to work for one of the greatest companies the world has ever seen…
Meanwhile the rest of us, the hardworking diligent conscientious majority just plod along doing our jobs wishing we were in the top 0.5% or less that everyone apparently wants to employ.
The use, even abuse of the word talent really needs to stop. Happily, most people aren’t talented. They are simply good hardworking considerate people who do what it takes to do a job well, provide for their families and enjoy life to the best of their abilities, a little like my parents and my grandparents and most of my friends and family.
The reason I say "Happily, most people aren't talented..." is because often as we see with singers, footballers, artists and actors, talent is often offset by some less savoury or at least less desirable personality traits and attitudes. Talent is often difficult to manage, difficult to harness and challenging to lead, direct or coordinate. Average people in diverse, complex teams tend to collaborate better and accommodate and compliment each other's strengths and weaknesses more effectively.
Plus of course, the small matter is that true genuine talent comes at a price, a price most ordinary, average companies cannot afford and there is no guarantee that paying that price will get you the results you desire.
In 2018, Monaco beat PSG to the French Ligue 1 title whilst having a wage bill that was 1/5th the size of PSG. Less "Talent", less cost, better outcome. I'm sure for Monaco fans, their win was all the better because they did it on a fraction of the budget and proved beyond doubt that average can produce better results than an abundance of expensive talent.
I applaud all those amongst us who are simply average. I have a suspicion that it would be a distinctly unsavoury world if it was full of Ronaldo’s and Lionel Messi's and similar…
Find this article insightful? If you’re a recruitment business owner and you’d like a free demonstration of i-intro?, simply book an appointment with one of our specialists by clicking HERE.
** Written by?Darren Ledger, Sales Director at i-intro?
Supply Chain/Logistics, Operations Management
2 年Good article but luck plays its part, being in the right place at the right time and then if you are Talented you will know and take advantage of opportunities by adding value to the organisation and giving more back than you take. Also how does a recruiter know whom is the best for the job, I am very often asked in significant questions and even irrelevant ones, I guess that means that many recruiters are average also as the Talented ones know their clients as well as their candidates businesses inside out.
Recruiter at ESS, Inc.
2 年It's due to Hollywood and the use of the term there. Those people don't have normal jobs, and 'the talent' is what makes or breaks a production, either in front of or behind the camera. Note too, they almost never make movies about people with normal jobs, where they come in and do some stuff, and leave and come back and do more of the same stuff. Every 'job' in movies is based around some big meeting or account they have to get, and a pitch they have to land, etc. At most they'll show one scene of the main character late at night staring at a laptop to show they're 'working.' The rest of the time they're at coffee shops, parties, dinners, etc., and notably NOT working. That's 'talent,' and it's a far more attractive idea to most people than going in to a job, having a pile of stuff on your desk that you work through, leaving at a certain point, and then coming back and finding more stuff on the pile. Most people would rather be 'talent' than an employee with an actual job, and most companies want to sell the idea that they employ 'talent' rather than people who sit at desks most of their days. Talent looks good, and sells well, but it's regular old employees that actually get stuff done. That's not glamorous, though.
?? Managing Director - Eyecare, Eyewear, Optometry & Ophthalmology Recruiter at Vision Executives ??
2 年Really interesting read this!
Highly experienced sales/recruitment leader/trainer/coach.
2 年Great piece and I agree with all of it. 'Talent' is just another business buzzword. 'Talent' in TV and film is used to describe the people in front of the camera, not behind it, even tho' a lot of people behind the camera people are no doubt talented. Other footballers with natural talent include George Best, Rodney Marsh, Stan Bowles, Gazza and others. They all had problems. Kevin Keegan didn't have natural talent but worked hard at his game, and had fewer problems. I have worked with a number of naturally gifted people, but they were all hard to handle.
International Executive Search Partner ★ Talent Acquisition Specialist ★ MEAN Specialist★ Making the Impossible Possible
2 年When I originally wrote this post, I suspect a lot of people (as is the tendency today) misinterpreted the point or objective. As a writer, of course, that's partially my fault. But essentially, I was attempting to pay homage to all the ordinary people out there who never get the chance to discover their true calling and just keep on giving, ploughing through life to make the most of what they have.