Ta ta ta taaaa! Roll over Beethoven
His name is Beethoven. Ludwig van Beethoven.

Ta ta ta taaaa! Roll over Beethoven

There is something special about Adele, Madonna and Sia. Because these pop divas are only ever referred to by their first names.

If we addressed them properly, they would be Adele Laurie Blue Adkins, Madonna Louise Ciccone and Sia Kate Isobelle Furler.

For most male singers, it is not that simple.

We could not just talk about Paul McCartney, John Denver and Mick Jagger as Paul, John and Mick. It could easily lead to confusions with Paul Simon, John Mayer or Mick Hucknall.

Except no-one would mistake the Rolling Stones for Simply Red.

The explanation of this surname conundrum is simple. Though there is only one Adele, there are so many Pauls, Johns and Micks we always need a bit more detail to identify the artist.

Should you be wondering why such a banality bears explaining these days, you have not followed the latest twist in the religion of wokeness. The activists have just discovered another bastion of male, “white” privilege: the surnames of classical music composers.

Classical music is under general suspicion anyway. It dates to a time when slavery still existed. The paper used for sheet music was not yet sustainably sourced. And the carbon emissions relating to Georg Friederich H?ndel’s Royal Fireworks Music were not offset, either.

It gets worse. Animal rights activists would not like the bird-catcher Papageno in The Magic FluteThe Abduction from the Seraglio is full of racist references to Arab culture. Meanwhile, Così fan tutte is outrageously sexist. And these are only some of Mozart’s most famous operas.

Woke activists have now detected an even worse crime: only referring to leading classical composers by their surname.

Talk about Bach, Beethoven or Mozart (without the Johann Sebastian, Ludwig van or Wolfgang Amadeus), and you are engaging in thought crime. At least according to Slate’s Chris White (yes, that is his real name!). He recently wrote how this “exacerbates the exclusionary practices that suppressed nonwhite and nonmale composers in the first place.”

The solution: “fullnaming.”

White continues: “Going forward, we need to “fullname” all composers when we write, talk, and teach about music. If mononyms linguistically place composers in a canonical pantheon, fullnaming never places them there to begin with.”

By adding Ludwig van, Beethoven shall appear a little less genial than he was. He is just another composer. At least he is dead.

“Ta ta ta taaaa,” yeah right. Roll over Beethoven, as Chuck said. Berry, that is.

Someone better tell Adele, Madonna and Sia. In the campaign for woke equality, they must be next.

This satire was first published in Insights, the newsletter of The New Zealand Initiative. If you want to receive the Initiative's irreverent take on the week, sign up here.

Rhys Goodey

Owner, Ark Wine Agencies

4 年

Adele and Madonna I find ridiculously pretentious and I would not know Sia if I fell over her. I cannot help thinking all three of them will be long forgotten when our grandchildren are still listening to Beethoven and Handel.

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Oliver Hartwich的更多文章

  • How central banking lost its way

    How central banking lost its way

    Three bits of news from the world of finance and central banking this week: The Reserve Bank increased the cash rate by…

  • Transparency, please

    Transparency, please

    The Wellington economics fraternity was up in arms last week. The reason was a job opening.

    19 条评论
  • Long live Helen Clark

    Long live Helen Clark

    We all wish Helen Clark a long life. At the same time, that prospect makes us nervous.

    7 条评论
  • Don't know much about history?

    Don't know much about history?

    It does not happen every day that I find myself in agreement with the Ministry of Education. But its reasoning for…

    1 条评论
  • Effective and affordable – Why the ETS is sufficient to deal with the climate emergency

    Effective and affordable – Why the ETS is sufficient to deal with the climate emergency

    Parliament has declared a climate change emergency. Having committed to cutting its emissions to net-zero by 2050, New…

    5 条评论
  • In search of Kiwi excellence

    In search of Kiwi excellence

    One of the first management books I ever read was Tom Peters’ A Passion for Excellence. I must have received it in the…

    26 条评论
  • We don’t know how unlucky we are in NZ

    We don’t know how unlucky we are in NZ

    All eyes are on New Zealand. In the lead-up to the election, Time magazine admired our “calmer democracy.

    50 条评论
  • The vexing issue of Damien Grant's 'career-ending' convictions

    The vexing issue of Damien Grant's 'career-ending' convictions

    Should a convicted fraudster be allowed to work as an insolvency practitioner? If your spontaneous answer is “no way!”,…

  • Learning to live with Covid-19?

    Learning to live with Covid-19?

    At the end of this week, New Zealand is back in a situation we hoped to have left behind. With Auckland in lockdown and…

    5 条评论
  • A return to normal? Forget about it.

    A return to normal? Forget about it.

    Covid-19 is not just a medical and economic crisis. It is a historical watershed moment with massive effects for entire…

    3 条评论