Symmetry in FEA may be dangerous

Symmetry in FEA may be dangerous

Symmetry in FEA is great, as it reduces the size of the task. This, in turn, shortens the computing time. Computing time is still a big issue, especially when you run complex models. Without a doubt, this is why using symmetry in FEA is so popular. There is a catch to this, however, as you make some assumptions while defining symmetry. Those assumptions may lead to incomplete outcomes of your analysis.

What is symmetry in FEA

Simply put symmetry is a set of boundary conditions that make part of your model work as if you have modeled the whole model.

This is almost always explained in a classical example of a beam loaded with 2 forces:

You can clearly see here, that the model is symmetric, which means that if you split it in half (as shown with the axis) you get 2 mirror images. Such cases allow for use of symmetry, and definition of it can be derived simply by observation.

You can notice that in the middle of the deformed shape there will be no rotation at all, but it moved downward along the symmetry line/plane. This is enough to see, that symmetry boundary conditions will look like this:

With such definition, you can simply solve half of your model, and the outcomes will be correct! This is a great benefit of symmetry, as it can greatly reduce model size.

Where is the catch and a small example...

Read the full article here!

Want to learn about FEA?

This is GREAT! I have a special free FEA course just for you!


Instead of simple roler supports, sliding moment transfering bearings must have been introduced at the line of symmetry.

回复

要查看或添加评论,请登录

?ukasz Skotny的更多文章

  • The difference between linear and nonlinear FEA

    The difference between linear and nonlinear FEA

    This is a 10min read. It will be more comfortable to read the full article on my blog :) I remember my first…

    16 条评论
  • How to interpret FEA Results?

    How to interpret FEA Results?

    Interpreting analysis outcomes is not simple. Even if you already have proper values from your FEA analysis, still you…

    13 条评论
  • Boundary Conditions in FEA

    Boundary Conditions in FEA

    It's relatively easy to perform an FEA analysis, but it's definitely difficult to run an analysis that produces…

    4 条评论
  • Is math really needed in FEA?

    Is math really needed in FEA?

    I never hid with my beliefs about math in FEA. But I figured I will ask around, just to make sure I’m not missing…

    19 条评论
  • FEA on a new level! Or how to design an engine!

    FEA on a new level! Or how to design an engine!

    Some time ago I realized that I’ve got to know some amazing people in the last 2 years of blogging. Having so many…

    1 条评论
  • Design rules vs Physics

    Design rules vs Physics

    This came out in one of the discussions in FEA guild, and I figured I will expand on this idea. This will also be…

    2 条评论
  • Great FEA report for the win!

    Great FEA report for the win!

    I’ve recently posted a tip about writing good FEA report… and I must admit that what followed surprised me! This is the…

    3 条评论
  • FEA Design Tips #002

    FEA Design Tips #002

    Wow..

    2 条评论
  • FEA Design Tips #001

    FEA Design Tips #001

    (you can read this on my blog as well!) I've recently started posting FEA Design Insights on my LinkedIn profile as…

  • Benchmark for nonlinear geometry!

    Benchmark for nonlinear geometry!

    During last week I've posted a tip in the FEA Guild about using Benchmarks. Some great pointers were in the comments…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了