Is Swedish Payroll More Complex Than Other Countries?

With 25 years of experience in Time and Payroll, including roles as Project Manager, Solutions Architect, and Implementation Consultant, I have often received the question:

Why is it difficult and expensive to implement a Payroll system in Sweden, compared to other countries?

This is an question I intend to answer though my series of articles on Sweden and its Payroll System.

The purpose of these articles is to explain how Sweden contrasts themselves from other countries and why these manifest. I will provide an explanation for why payroll calculations in Sweden can be perceived as challenging. Furthermore, I will share my reflections and advice to companies who are planning on implementing a Payroll System in Sweden, when not considering Sweden to be their primary market.

The Historical Context:

From 1932 - 1976, The Social Democrats had the governing power in Sweden. ?During their time in power, the corporatist governance model was established. The model was characterized by the interplay between the state, employees and unions, and is often referred to as The Swedish Model.

The Swedish Model includes a generous welfare state, active labor market policies, and strong labor rights. However, the model is also centered around corporatist governance. Therefore, a key aspect of this model is the minimal legal regulation of labor market rules (with the exception of labor laws focusing on employment protection, work environment, and negotiation rights.) Instead, most issues are regulated through collective agreements between employer associations in various industries and corresponding unions.

These agreements occurs on two levels:

1. A central level where extensive guidelines are set in stone by large unions for both the white-collar and blue-collar employees.
2. A local level, where agreements are adapted to specific conditions within particular industries, regions, etc.

Traditionally, the local level system has been very successful, because it allows certain rules to be tailored to unique conditions of each industry, which fosters mutual understanding. Agreements made by industry representatives also lead to more stable regulations with fewer changes in payroll calculation principles - For example, there is no statutory minimum wage in Sweden because it is regulated through various collective agreements. This also applies to rules for overtime working hours - which are primarily governed by these agreements. Consequently, the overarching principles established in Sweden by the largest unions are - from a system perspective - to be regarded as statutory rules, affecting the entire labor market.

Focus on Equality, Fairness, and Solidarity

Another significant factor would be Sweden's strong focus on equality, fairness, and solidarity. Until the late 1980s, Sweden had a very compressed wage structure with small differences. Although this has changed significantly in the last 30-40 years, many aspects of the wage regulation system still reflects this factor.

Examples of Complexity

One example is the varied methods for calculating absence deductions, which depend on the reason and length of absence. This requires numerous absence codes for employees to register the reason for their absence.

Another example would be sick leave. Sick leave calculations in Sweden are complex, because they are influenced by several parameters including the length of the sick leave, and how often an employee is sick. In addition, the deduction for the first unpaid sick day is structured so that an employee who works many hours on that day - such as 10 hours due to shift work - is not financially disadvantaged compared to an employee who works 8 hours on a regular day.

Vacation Management and calculation

Vacation handling in Sweden is quite complex. When calculating vacation accruals, various factors must be taken into account besides the vacation entitlement, such as the length of employment during the accrual year and the number of days of absence due to sickness, parental leave, child care, etc. Additionally, it is important to determine whether the absence was for a full or partial day under specific conditions. Employees are allowed to save all earned vacation days exceeding 20 days for up to five years. However, many agreements also require saving the average employment percentage for the earning year. The payment should be fair compared to other employees on all terms.

Overtime Compensation

Overtime compensation varies depending on the time of day, day of the week or holiday. Employees can also choose to save overtime as time off, with the accrued time being based on when the overtime was worked, similar to monetary compensation. The employee has the right to later choose to convert saved overtime back to money without resulting in financial loss. Each type of saved hour must be recorded separately based on how it was earned to ensure accurate compensation. You should have the same payment, as if you had choose a payout already in the first stage.

The Importance of Time Tracking

Accurate time tracking is fundamental for Payroll calculation in Sweden. This means that Payroll Consultants and Implementers must have extensive knowledge of both Time and Payroll regardless of whether these are integrated and managed into the same system through an integration solution.

Reflections for International Companies

Companies that do not have Sweden as their primary market but need to implement a Payroll System in Sweden should be aware of these complexities. It is essential to have a thorough understanding of Swedish collective agreements, fairness regulations, and time tracking to succeed in the implementation.

In my next article, I will deep dive into some of the more complicated areas of Swedish Payroll, Time, Absenteeism and Holiday Pay Calculations.

About the author

Arne Stroff has over 25 years of experience in Time and Payroll, primarily in a Swedish context. He has been a solution architect and lead implementation consultant in several of the largest SAP payroll installations in Sweden, including the Swedish Armed Forces and ABB. In addition, he has served as Project Manager and Solution Architect in several SuccessFactors implementations.

• Learn more about Gavdi and our payroll solution: SAP Payroll | Employee Central Payroll | Gavdi Group