Stumble and Fall

Stumble and Fall

Coming to the end of the year, contemplating on what is happing in the world of CUI, I felt the urge to share some of my thoughts.

In recent years I’ve seen a lot of developments and improvements in insulation materials with regards to CUI. On the other hand, the coating market has also come up with new generations of coating and has developed ISO 19227 which engineers can use in choosing fit for purpose coatings. Positive developments, which I’m certain will bring more awareness and increase the technical knowledge in the long term.

Having said that, the consensus still remains that CUI occurs under every type of insulation material. As long as there’s a crevice between insulation material and the substrate, and moisture water will eventual ingress and accumulate in this crevice, this situation will lead to shorter coating lifespan and eventually to CUI.

EFC, NACE & CINI, in my opinion the authorities in this field, still underwrite the system approach. However, the insulation branch hasn’t come up yet with general accepted test procedures. In my experience insulation manufacturers, for obvious reasons are not eager to step up to this. Because, regardless the insulation product you will choice, CUI can always happen. Therefore in my believe asset-owners and operators should pick up the glove and should bind forces with independent organizations like CINI, Eiif, NCTI and develop such test standards.

And hopefully bring an end to all of these discussions with no end, where in people stumble and fall over each other, trying to convince their product is the best of the best.

What I see, is an insulation branch on the right track, but with still a long way of learning and improving ahead.

With this in mind, I wish you all a good and above all healthy 2020!  

Craig Stokes TICorr ACQI

Construction Superintendent

5 年

Johan, some good points there but I feel like your letting the operators off the hook........... But The problem with CUI is everyone has their opinions of which they all differ, Insulation specialists blame the painting, coating guys blame the insulation, piping guys don’t care if they install pipes on unpainted supports and no one cares if they damage the insulation “we will fix that next time” ?? One thing for sure is their are a lot of people making money out of it for sure?

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Johan Sentjens的更多文章

  • Drainholes or Drainplugs

    Drainholes or Drainplugs

    A statement that is often copied within the insulation industry originates from a NACE/AMPP “standard” SP0198. And it…

    2 条评论
  • Onafhankelijk isolatie advies blijft belangrijk.

    Onafhankelijk isolatie advies blijft belangrijk.

    Ook bij industri?le, technische Isolatie en de RVO-energielijst Energie-investeringsaftrek (EIA). Dat thermische…

  • The how and why of Cryogenic insulation. And: who is responsible for insulation design?

    The how and why of Cryogenic insulation. And: who is responsible for insulation design?

    Drawing up a good and clear insulation specification is one thing, but incorporating this specification with piping and…

    20 条评论
  • CUI, just follow the water....

    CUI, just follow the water....

    There are still quite some discussions whether water or moisture detection will help us to find CUI. Up until now, it…

    3 条评论
  • Protectem Flangebelt in cold/cryogenic insulation systems

    Protectem Flangebelt in cold/cryogenic insulation systems

    Advantages of the Protectem Flangebelt: Protectem-Flangebelts ? are mainly used in hot insulation systems to detect…

    4 条评论
  • Innovation in Industrial insulation land. A Joke? Or not?

    Innovation in Industrial insulation land. A Joke? Or not?

    Recently, during a lunch in a nice Dutch bistro, with a retired senior in the insulation industry, I held this…

    1 条评论
  • CUI for dummies (or not)

    CUI for dummies (or not)

    Dear specification engineers Saw a insulation spec today with following sentence: “FEF* Insulation is a fully sealed…

    21 条评论
  • An Inspector Calls

    An Inspector Calls

    Author: John van Voorbergen, Temati BV, The Netherlands. Published in LNG Industry- june 2017 With temperatures of…

    4 条评论
  • New DIN 4140:2014

    New DIN 4140:2014

    An excerpt from the latest edition of the German “Isolier-Technik”. For those who are not familiar with the German…

    1 条评论
  • CUI and Challenge the Need for Insulation

    CUI and Challenge the Need for Insulation

    Introduction It’s my standard statement: “CUI is a mine field”. And for more than just one reason.

    4 条评论

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了