Strike Out

Strike Out

Did the tribunal err when striking out the Claimant's claims on the ground they had no reasonable prospects of success?

No, held the EAT in?Kaul v Ministry of Justice and ors.

The Claimant appealed against a tribunal's decision to strike out her claims of indirect discrimination, victimisation, failure to make reasonable adjustments, harassment, and discrimination arising from disability, on the ground that the claims had no reasonable prospects of success.

The Claimant submitted that on a proper application of Rule 37(1)(a) of the?Employment Tribunals (Constitution and Rules of Procedure) Regulations 2013,?the Employment Judge’s conclusion that the complaints struck out had no reasonable prospects of success was premature and not a conclusion properly open to him. Relying on authorities that support the position that decisions that a claim has no reasonable prospects of success on its facts should be rare, the Claimant argued that the decision was premature and should have been determined at a final hearing.

The EAT disagreed and found the decision of the tribunal was consistent with the authorities. The need for caution when considering a strike-out application does not prohibit a realistic assessment where the circumstances of the case permit. This case involved ordinary, undisputed events regarding the handling of the Claimant’s grievances. Taking those facts at face value, the decision that the claims would inevitably fail and had no reasonable prospects of success was permissible.

Thanks to?Kate Lea?of didlaw for preparing this case summary.

No alt text provided for this image

要查看或添加评论,请登录

Daniel Barnett的更多文章

  • Unfair dismissal: SOSR

    Unfair dismissal: SOSR

    Summary: Dismissal based on a genuine but erroneous belief that the Claimant had resigned should have been considered…

    1 条评论
  • Employment Tribunals

    Employment Tribunals

    Summary: New ET rules of procedure in force from 6 January 2025 From 6 January 2025, employment law practitioners will…

    3 条评论
  • Unfair dismissal: SOSR

    Unfair dismissal: SOSR

    Summary: Length of service and alternatives to dismissal not relevant factors where dismissal was due to irretrievable…

    2 条评论
  • Holiday Pay

    Holiday Pay

    Summary: Gap of over three months between deductions did not break chain in holiday pay claim In Deksne v Ambitions…

  • Maternity Protection

    Maternity Protection

    Summary: Suitable Alternative Employment In Hunter v Carnival plc the Employment Appeal Tribunal looked at the…

    2 条评论
  • Employment Appeal Tribunal

    Employment Appeal Tribunal

    Summary: EAT issues new Practice Direction to accompany new Rules The Employment Appeal Tribunal has published a new…

  • Whistleblowing detriment

    Whistleblowing detriment

    Summary: Disclosures made before employment begins can qualify as protected In MacLennan v British Psychological…

    1 条评论
  • Employment Rights Bill: consultation on remedies for collective redundancy and fire and rehire

    Employment Rights Bill: consultation on remedies for collective redundancy and fire and rehire

    Summary: Government launches consultation seeking views on strengthening remedies against abuse of rules on collective…

  • Employment Rights Bill: consultation on SSP reforms

    Employment Rights Bill: consultation on SSP reforms

    Summary: Government launches consultation on the percentage replacement rate for those earning below the current rate…

  • Employment Rights Bill – new Government Factsheets

    Employment Rights Bill – new Government Factsheets

    Summary: Government publishes ten factsheets about the Employment Rights Bill. Ten factsheets have been published by…

社区洞察

其他会员也浏览了