Strengthening Trust in Business at the Global Level
Greg Medcraft
Chair/Company Director and Adviser (former Chair-ASIC&IOSCO/Director-OECD/MD-Societe Generale)
Speech by Greg Medcraft, Director for Financial and Enterprise Affairs, OECD
Book launch of Trust, Accountability and Purpose by Justin O'Brien, 7 August 2019
Ladies and gentlemen
It is a pleasure to join you today for the launch of Professor Justin O’Brien’s book Trust, Accountability and Purpose – The Regulation of Corporate Governance.
I’m here this morning to first, offer a few reflections on Justin’s book, and second, to discuss global developments in trust, particularly what the OECD is doing to strengthen trust in business.
Reflections on Trust, Accountability and Purpose
If we were to simplify the core messages of Trust, Accountability and Purpose into a few short lines, they would be:
- That for many citizens, business conduct is not meeting the expectations of the 21st century;
- That trust in business, and by extension the foundations of our economy, is at stake;
- And that these challenges demand new ways of thinking about corporate and market governance.
As we all know, trust in business – and indeed all institutions – was damaged significantly after the global financial crisis. It has rebounded in recent years, but is still below pre-crisis levels. This matters because trust is the grease in the engine of our economy – it underwrites our everyday commerce, the flow of credit and capital, and the long-term investments that drive productivity. Low trust makes us all worse off.
It also matters because trust is a much more important part of the business environment today than it was before the GFC.
Social media and the 24-hour news cycle have combined to harness and amplify the power of the crowd – the community of a business’s customers, employees, investors and other stakeholders. It is now easier than ever before for citizens to monitor business behaviour, and hold a company to account when it does the wrong thing.
So how should business respond?
In his book, Justin calls for an “alignment of corporate purpose to changed societal expectationâ€, and to “complement legal obligation with a defined social licence to operateâ€. On this point I completely agree.
The expectations of the crowd forms a business’s social license to operate – and this evolves much faster than legislation or regulation. Increasingly, this includes an expectation that companies define and articulate their purpose and value to society. Businesses must monitor these expectations constantly. If they fall short, their social license may be revoked and they may find themselves deserted by their customers, investors and staff.
In almost every instance of corporate conduct scandal, we see a disconnect between the stated values of a company the actions of its staff. This book’s focus on corporate governance as a remedy gets to the heart of this disconnect, because corporate governance drives corporate culture, and culture is the single most important factor in a company’s ability to do the right thing.
Trust needs to be a central consideration in corporate culture, and that means putting the customers’ interests at the heart of everything a business does. We have seen too many examples in this country recently where this has not been the case.
The good news is that countless empirical studies, including from the OECD, have shown that a company’s reputation and level of trust is positively linked to its capacity to generate long-term return on equity and assets.
In short: building trust is simply good for business.
What the OECD is doing to strengthen trust in business
The OECD holds some of the world’s leading standards on corporate behaviour and business conduct, including in corporate governance, anti-bribery and responsible business conduct in supply chains. But as Justin observes in his book, “technical measures alone cannot fix normative problems†– that is to say, government policies are not enough to address the threat to trust in business.
This is why the OECD has launched its Trust in Business Initiative this year – to support policymakers and business alike to drive better business conduct that goes beyond laws and standards. The Trust in Business initiative focuses on the 5 core competencies of the OECD: research; standard-setting; convening; capacity building; and partnerships.
On research, we have dedicated our annual flagship publication, the OECD Business and Financial Outlook, to strengthening trust in business.
Its covers trust and:
- Financial markets;
- Financial institutions – like banks and pension funds;
- Company liability – that is, trust in companies to obey the law;
- The level playing field – on managing the rising importance of state owned enterprises and the associated conduct risks; and
- Online markets – which speaks to a rapidly rising concern in the eyes of citizens and governments alike.
This research underlines the importance of considering trust in policymaking: in market governance, financial sector supervision, law enforcement and business regulation – and it gives governments a framework to do that. The Business and Financial Outlook will be released early September.
On standards, I mentioned some of our key business conduct instruments earlier, and we are using Trust in Business as a platform to:
- Drive better implementation of standards worldwide.
- To better link a range of policy areas that have historically been considered separately by governments.
- To highlight these standards’ value to companies in meeting their social license to operate.
On convening, the OECD will host a Trust in Business Forum on 1-2 October in Paris, bringing together the private sector, academia, government and civil society to discuss many of today’s themes in a global setting.These include defining and measuring trust, addressing audit quality issues, and looking at the role of the board in driving corporate governance practices worthy of the public’s confidence.
On capacity building, we have a series of projects design to strengthen businesses’ ability to do the right thing, including:
- Compliance without Borders – which will create a programme of compliance expert secondments from the private sector to state-owned enterprises operating in challenging markets
- Trust Beyond Compliance – which will harness the OECD’s analytical power to better understand the challenges companies face in achieving responsible business conduct, and spread best practices for establishing a culture based on trust.
Finally, on partnerships, we are putting together a world-wide network of companies committed to trust to contribute to, support and benefit from this work. And if this sounds like your business, we want to hear from you.
Ladies and gentlemen, as Trust, Accountability and Purpose makes clear, strengthening trust is one of the defining challenges of our time. It is a challenge that demands action from governments and business alike.
The OECD is leading that action at the global level, to help ensure that business conduct meets the expectations of the 21st century.
Find out more
Governance Advisor/Educator/Author/Speaker and co-founder of UK Sustainable Money Working Group
5 å¹´Since the speech by Medcraft on August 8, the world has changed making it much more problematic to trust business CEO’s. On August 19 the US Business Round Table announced that 181 of its CEO’s made “a fundamental commitment to all their stakeholders.†“to deliver value to all of themâ€. However, as The Economists points out “this new form of collective capitalism could do more harm than good†as “It risks entrenching a class of unaccountable CEO’s who lack legitimacyâ€. As pointed out by Australian Professor Justin O’Brien, who introduced Greg Medcraft on August 8, misconduct by corporations arises “because they canâ€. The 2017-2019 Australian Royal Commission into misconduct into the financial services industry provided evidence for this view. It identified the problem as: “there is always a striking asymmetry of power and information between bank and customer that favours the bank.†No recommendation was made to counter this systemic problem. Corporate governance codes and the ISO 19600:2014 Standard are also silent on this toxic problem. However, Medcraft, identified a way to hold CEO’s accountable by recognising that: “It is now easier than ever before for citizens to monitor business behaviour, and hold a company to account when it does the wrong thing.†A way to make this approach practical was identified in my presentation during a later session on August 8 based on my article published by Justin O’Brien as the editor of Law and financial markets review. My article posted at https://doi.org/10.1080/17521440.2019.1602694 suggests that regulators require corporations to empower their stakeholders to report to shareholders on how well CEO’s can be trusted “to deliver value to all stakeholdersâ€. The US Business Round Table approach does not remove shareholder primacy. Neither does the solution described in my paper cited above on the “Causes and solutions for misconduct in the financial services industryâ€. Instead it promotes win-win solutions identified by 2009 Nobel Laureate Elinor Ostrom on how to avoid “the tragedy of the commonsâ€. Larry Fink, identified in his letter to CEO’s in 2018, why recognising stakeholders would require what he described as “A new model of corporate governanceâ€. My co-authored article with Professor Michael Pirson on “The future of management: Network governance†describes how a new model could be created without necessarily any changes in the law. Our article was posted by The European Financial Review at:?https://www.europeanfinancialreview.com/the-future-of-management-network-governance/ The take home message for global regulators is the need to also introduce a creditable basis for the public to establish trust in corporations along the lines suggested above.
My mission is to encourage ongoing reform of the financial services sector, so that it serves society better
5 å¹´This is an excellent book on a topic of profound importance to business and society as a whole