Strategies for establishing a robust rapport and effectively handling challenging clients: Five proven methods

Dealing with resistance is a common challenge in counselling, therapy or coaching. Clients may exhibit resistance due to apprehension, scepticism, or past negative experiences with therapy. Developing a robust rapport with clients who exhibit resistance is crucial for treatment to provide optimal results. This newsletter article will analyse five approaches validated by empirical evidence for handling challenging clients and developing strong therapeutic relationships.

For the purposes of this article, a coach is defined as distinct from a counsellor or therapist but can exhibit similar skills in a coaching session. Although they are not licensed counsellors or therapists, they have been trained in those skills.

1. The act of attentively listening and displaying empathy.

Active listening and empathy are crucial elements of every therapeutic alliance. Active listening involves fully concentrating, understanding, reacting, and remembering the client's remarks. It goes beyond receiving spoken words; it includes comprehending the emotions and thoughts underlying those words. On the other hand, empathy involves understanding and actively engaging with the client's feelings.

Empirical research consistently shows that empathy is essential for getting positive treatment results. As all experienced counsellors/therapists and coaches know, empathy significantly impacts therapeutic outcomes, highlighting its importance in building rapport.

Application: To improve their active listening and empathy abilities, counsellors/therapists/coaches should focus only on the client and avoid any distractions. Additionally, it is essential for them to actively participate in introspection on the client's comments and acknowledge and affirm their emotions. For instance, if a client expresses discontent with their living conditions, the therapist can respond by saying, "It seems that you are feeling overwhelmed and frustrated as a result of your current situation." It poses a certain level of difficulty for you.

2. Fostering self-assurance and guaranteeing safety

Building trust and guaranteeing safety are crucial preconditions for therapeutic engagement, especially when dealing with resistant clients. The absence of trust impedes clients from being open and actively engaging in the therapeutic process.

Evidence-based practice strongly supports the importance of trust and safety in therapy. Horvath and Greenberg (1989) assert that the therapeutic connection, which includes trust and safety, significantly impacts the effectiveness of treatment outcomes.

Application: Counsellors/therapists or coaches can foster confidence by regularly exhibiting dependability and impartial attitudes. Ensuring confidentiality and assuring clients that their disclosures will be treated with the utmost care are crucial. Creating a secure setting for physical safety and emotional support is essential for clients to feel comfortable openly expressing themselves. Establishing a therapy session atmosphere that is secure, calm, and free from disturbances enhances a sense of safety.

3. Enacting a Client-Focused Methodology

A client-centered approach, often known as person-centred treatment, prioritises the client's perspective and respects their autonomy. This approach is highly effective in dealing with resistance since it allows clients to engage in therapy actively.

Evidence-Based Practice: Carl Rogers, the founder of person-centred therapy, said that establishing a non-directive and supportive environment enables clients to explore and understand their emotions and behaviours. Studies suggest that a client-centered approach enhances client engagement and reduces resistance (Rogers, 1951).

Application: Implementing a client-centered approach involves respecting the client's unique pace and willingness to engage in therapy. Counsellors/therapists or coaches should avoid pressure on clients to explore subjects they are not ready to address. Instead, it is recommended that they provide unwavering positive regard, displaying acceptance and support regardless of the client's disclosures. For instance, if a client hesitates to disclose a painful incident, the therapist may reply, "We can discuss this subject when you feel ready." There is no necessity to rush.

4. Utilising Motivational Interviewing Techniques

Motivational interviewing (MI) is a therapeutic approach to enhance a client's motivation to change by exploring and resolving ambivalent emotions. It is particularly effective with persons who demonstrate reluctance to change or participate in therapy.

Empirical research has repeatedly demonstrated the effectiveness of Motivational Interviewing (MI) in several situations, including addiction treatment and fostering changes in health behaviour (Miller & Rollnick, 2013). MI helps customers understand their reasons for wanting to change, thus reducing resistance and increasing engagement.

Motivational interviewing involves many crucial strategies, including displaying empathy, encouraging inconsistency, adjusting to resistance, and enhancing self-efficacy. For example, when a client shows hesitance towards change, a therapist/counsellor or coach using Motivational Interviewing (MI) might reply by stating, "I understand that the process of making changes can be complicated." What are some of the reasons you think changing this behaviour might be beneficial for you? This strategy encourages clients to articulate their motivations, enhancing their probability of committing to change.

5. Addressing core issues and cultivating a profound comprehension

Resistance in therapy sometimes stems from underlying causes such as past trauma, fear of being vulnerable, or a lack of trust in authority figures. Resolving the fundamental problems makes reducing opposition and developing a favourable rapport feasible.

Research-based Practice: Empirical research suggests properly addressing core issues and helping clients gain self-reflective insight into their behaviours and emotions may greatly improve treatment outcomes (Lambert & Barley, 2001). Insight-oriented therapies, such as psychodynamic therapy, seek to understand the fundamental impulses that impact behaviour, which may be quite beneficial in reducing resistance.

Approach: Counsellors/therapists or coaches can utilise many techniques, including exploring the client's prior experiences, identifying recurring patterns in their behaviour, and encouraging the connection between their past and present to address underlying challenges. For example, suppose a client shows resistance because of a negative experience with authority figures. In that case, the counsellor/therapist or coach might explore this earlier occurrence and help the client understand how it influences their behaviour during therapy. Enhancing understanding can reduce resistance and foster a deeper therapeutic connection.

Implementing the strategies: A comprehensive approach

While many of these strategies may have individual benefits, their integration into a comprehensive plan can enhance their effectiveness. Active listening, empathy, trust, a client-centred approach, motivational interviewing, and addressing underlying problems all contribute to building a positive relationship and reducing opposition.

Practical integration involves the therapist/ counsellor or coach starting a session by actively listening and empathising with the client to understand their difficulties. Subsequently, they would reassure the client of the confidentiality of their disclosures to develop a sense of trust and security. The counsellor/ therapist or coach would also honour the client's preparedness to address particular subjects, adhering to a client-centred methodology. The professionals would utilise motivational interviewing techniques to investigate the client's conflicting feelings about making changes. Ultimately, the therapist will systematically tackle the fundamental factors that lead to the client's reluctance.

References

• Horvath, A. O., & Greenberg, L. S. (1989). Development and validation of the Working Alliance Inventory. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 36(2), 223-233. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0167.36.2.223
• Rogers, C. R. (1951). Client-centered therapy: Its current practice, implications, and theory. Houghton Mifflin.
• Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (2013). Motivational interviewing: Helping people change (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.
• Lambert, M. J., & Barley, D. E. (2001). Research summary on the therapeutic relationship and psychotherapy outcome. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training, 38(4), 357-361. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-3204.38.4.357

If you like this content, please subscribe; if you have subscribed, please like

If you like this information and want to know more, why not become a member for as little as $7 per month? Then click here

If you wish to join our free Facebook group, Aspiring Coaches and Therapists, and learn more, then click here