Strategies for Assessing Vendor Claims – AI Solutions in OT/ICS Cybersecurity

To find out more about assessing vendor claims, download our FREE fact sheet. And, for deeper analysis of AI’s integration in the industrial cybersecurity space, purchase our latest report today!

Having just wrapped up our latest research into AI in industrial cybersecurity, I can tell you that this is an extremely hot—and somewhat controversial—topic right now. With AI solutions popping up all over the place, it’s becoming increasingly challenging to figure out which ones genuinely enhance security, and which are just riding the hype wave. So, how do you cut through the noise and assess the real impact of AI on your OT/ICS cybersecurity? Let’s dive into some strategies that can help.

Ask About the AI Implementation

First things first, get to know the nuts and bolts of the AI solution. Ask about the specific types of AI and machine learning techniques they’re using. Does the solution employ anomaly detection, deep learning, or perhaps supervised or unsupervised learning methods? Understanding this will help you grasp how the AI processes data and identifies potential threats.

Next, find out where the AI is deployed. Is it on-premises, cloud-based, or operating on edge devices? This is particularly crucial if you have strict cloud usage restrictions. Also, inquire about how the AI model is trained and updated. What data is used for training, and how frequently are updates rolled out? This ensures the AI stays effective against emerging threats.

Check what data sources the AI utilizes. The AI must leverage relevant data from your specific OT/ICS environment to provide accurate insights. Additionally, evaluate how the AI integrates with your existing systems and workflows. You want something that fits seamlessly into your current setup without causing disruptions.

?Request Concrete Use Cases and Metrics

To move beyond theoretical benefits, ask for specific examples of how the AI solution has detected or prevented threats in real-world scenarios. These cases demonstrate practical effectiveness and give you a clearer picture of what to expect. Also, request quantifiable metrics like false positive and negative rates, detection times, and other performance indicators. These numbers offer tangible evidence of the solution’s efficiency and reliability.

Don’t forget to inquire about any third-party validations or certifications the solution has received. External assessments can provide unbiased evaluations of the AI’s capabilities, adding an extra layer of credibility to the vendor’s claims.

Evaluate AI-Specific Security Measures

Remember, AI systems can be targets for sophisticated attacks themselves. It’s crucial to understand how the model is protected against threats like model poisoning or adversarial attacks. Ask about the safeguards in place to prevent the AI from causing operational disruptions. You want to ensure it won’t interfere with critical processes within your OT/ICS environment.

Discuss how the vendor addresses AI ethics and bias. Ethical practices are vital to reduce the risk of unintended consequences resulting from biased data or decision-making processes embedded within the AI.

?Conduct Proof-of-Concept Testing

Before committing to a full-scale deployment, consider running a proof-of-concept test by deploying the solution alongside your existing systems. This approach allows you to compare its efficacy in a controlled environment without risking your operational integrity. Measure key performance indicators such as detection rates and false positives to evaluate its performance accurately.

Test the AI against known attack scenarios specific to your environment. This will provide valuable insights into how well it can handle real threats you’ll face. It’s an essential step to assess the AI’s practical applicability and effectiveness in your unique operational context.

Assess Practical Implementation Factors

Think about the ease of use and integration of the solution. It should fit smoothly into your operations without necessitating significant changes to your existing workflows. Determine the required expertise and training your team will need to manage the AI effectively. If extensive retraining is required, this could impact the overall cost and time efficiency of the implementation.

Understand the ongoing maintenance and tuning requirements. Knowing the resources needed for sustained effectiveness will help in planning and ensure that the solution remains functional and up-to-date over time.

Consider Industry-Specific Factors

An effective AI solution should have a deep understanding of OT/ICS protocols and behaviors. Verify that the AI is tailored to industrial processes and can accurately identify anomalies that are significant within your specific context. Ensure it complies with industry-specific regulations and standards to maintain compliance and avoid potential legal issues down the line.

Evaluate Vendor Expertise and Track Record

The vendor’s experience in OT/ICS cybersecurity is a critical factor in your decision-making process. Prefer vendors with a proven focus and expertise in your field. Reviewing case studies and references can provide insights into their past performance and help predict future results. Consider the vendor’s development roadmap to ensure they are committed to advancing their solutions in the long term.

Engaging with the vendor’s existing customers and partners can offer practical perspectives on the solution’s strengths and weaknesses. Gathering insights from those already using the solution can inform your expectations and highlight potential areas of concern.

Starting Small: The Value of Pilot Programs

Before scaling up, implementing a limited pilot or proof-of-concept can be highly beneficial. This approach allows your organization to validate the AI’s effectiveness within your specific environment without making a significant upfront investment. It minimizes risk and provides concrete data to inform your decision-making process. By assessing the solution’s real-world performance on a smaller scale, you can make necessary adjustments and ensure it meets your operational needs before full deployment.

By taking these steps, you’ll be better equipped to navigate the industrial cybersecurity market. It’s all about asking the right questions and doing your due diligence to find a solution that truly enhances your security posture. Remember, not all that glitters is gold—especially in the world of AI. So take your time, start small, and make informed decisions that will benefit your organization in the long run.