Strategic Decision-Making for U.S. Manufacturing Companies: Continue Operations, Acquire, Merge, or Sell?

In the ever-evolving landscape of U.S. manufacturing, companies frequently face pivotal decisions that determine their long-term viability. Whether to continue operations independently, acquire or merge with another company, or sell outright depends on a variety of factors, including financial performance, industry trends, competitive positioning, and market conditions. Each strategic move comes with inherent risks and rewards, and business leaders must conduct thorough due diligence before committing to a path forward.

This article explores the key decision factors influencing manufacturing firms and offers a structured approach to evaluating strategic alternatives. It also provides industry examples, statistical data, and resources for further research.

1. Evaluating Financial Health and Performance

Revenue Growth and Profitability

The first factor to consider is the company’s financial stability. Businesses experiencing consistent revenue growth and strong profit margins may be well-positioned to continue independent operations or pursue acquisitions. Conversely, firms with declining revenues, increasing debt, or eroding margins may need to consider alternative strategies.

• Example: In 2023, General Electric (GE) successfully split its energy and healthcare businesses into separate entities due to differing profitability trajectories, allowing each unit to focus on core strengths.
• Data Insight: According to the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM), U.S. manufacturing output grew by 3.2% in 2023, but profit margins have been under pressure due to rising labor and material costs.

Debt and Capital Structure

A high debt-to-equity ratio may limit strategic flexibility. Companies burdened with debt may struggle to invest in growth initiatives, making them prime candidates for acquisition or a sale. On the other hand, firms with a strong balance sheet can leverage financial strength to expand through mergers or acquisitions.

• Example: The acquisition of Rockwell Collins by United Technologies in 2018 for $30 billion was facilitated by the latter’s strong financial position and access to capital markets.

2. Market Conditions and Industry Trends

Industry Growth and Competitive Landscape

Manufacturing companies must assess their industry’s overall health. Is the sector growing, stagnant, or in decline? Certain industries, such as aerospace and electric vehicles, are expanding, while others, like traditional steel manufacturing, face stagnation due to global competition.

• Example: The U.S. semiconductor industry has seen increased consolidation due to global supply chain disruptions, prompting companies like Intel and GlobalFoundries to pursue strategic acquisitions to maintain competitiveness.
• Data Insight: The U.S. manufacturing industry is projected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 3.7% from 2023 to 2028, with advanced manufacturing (automation, robotics, and AI-driven production) leading the charge.

Regulatory and Trade Considerations

Government policies, trade tariffs, and environmental regulations can impact strategic decisions. For instance, firms relying on international supply chains may face increased costs due to tariffs, making domestic consolidation more attractive.

• Example: The 2022 CHIPS Act, which incentivizes semiconductor production in the U.S., has led to increased domestic investment and mergers among semiconductor manufacturers.

3. Assessing Strategic Options

Continuing Independent Operations

If a company has a strong market position, financial health, and a clear growth strategy, remaining independent may be the best option. Investments in automation, workforce development, and R&D can enhance competitiveness.

• Key Considerations:
• Example: Tesla continues to operate independently, investing in gigafactories and proprietary battery technology rather than pursuing mergers.

Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A)

Merging with or acquiring another company can provide operational synergies, expanded market access, and cost savings. M&A is particularly attractive in industries with high competition and thin margins.

• Key Considerations:
• Example: The 2021 merger between Raytheon and United Technologies created a $100 billion aerospace and defense giant, allowing both companies to leverage synergies in innovation and cost reduction.

Selling the Company

For business owners nearing retirement, experiencing financial distress, or looking to capitalize on high valuations, selling may be the best option. A sale can maximize shareholder value and ensure business continuity under new leadership.

• Key Considerations:
• Example: In 2020, BorgWarner acquired Delphi Technologies for $3.3 billion to strengthen its electrification capabilities, a strategic move driven by market demand for electric vehicles.

4. The Role of Company Size

Small to Mid-Sized Manufacturers

Smaller firms often struggle with capital constraints and economies of scale, making them attractive acquisition targets. They may benefit from merging with larger players or private equity firms that can provide capital and expertise.

• Example: Private equity firm KKR acquired C.H.I. Overhead Doors in 2022, helping the company expand its market reach while maintaining operational autonomy.

Large Enterprises

Bigger companies have more strategic options. They can pursue acquisitions, spin off underperforming units, or invest in innovation. However, large-scale mergers often attract regulatory scrutiny.

• Example: The failed merger of Siemens and Alstom in 2019 highlights antitrust concerns that can arise in large-scale deals.

5. Resources for Further Research

For executives and business owners considering strategic options, the following resources offer valuable insights:

• U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) (www.bea.gov) – Provides economic data and industry growth reports.
• National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) (www.nam.org) – Offers policy insights, industry trends, and business advocacy.
• Harvard Business Review (HBR) on M&A Strategy (www.hbr.org) – In-depth analysis of merger and acquisition strategies.
• PitchBook (www.pitchbook.com) – Tracks private equity and M&A deal trends.
• SEC Edgar Database (www.sec.gov/edgar.shtml) – Provides financial statements of publicly traded companies, useful for M&A analysis.

Conclusion

Deciding whether to continue independent operations, merge, acquire, or sell is a complex process that depends on financial health, industry conditions, strategic fit, and long-term goals. Companies must conduct comprehensive due diligence, consider market trends, and assess their competitive positioning before making a decision.

For manufacturing firms, the right strategy depends on their size, financial strength, and ability to adapt to industry changes. While mergers and acquisitions offer growth opportunities, staying independent or selling may be the best choice for firms facing unique challenges or opportunities. Business leaders should leverage available resources, consult financial and legal experts, and ensure alignment with shareholder and stakeholder interests before proceeding with any major strategic move.

Contact Strategic Value+ for a Free Strategic Session

The Veteran Advisors of the Strategic Value+ Collaborative are experienced and well-versed in the issues facing U.S. manufacturing companies as they pave their roads to their futures. For a fresh perspective on strategic alternatives, contact the Strategic Value+ by emailing [email protected] or schedule a free comprehensive 90-minute 360-degree strategic impact session at https://strategicvalueplus.com/contact. You have nothing to lose and a new view on your manufacturing company's future to gain.

Join the Strategic Value+ Solutions Collaborative for the Free U.S. Manufacturing Webinar Event Featuring Harry Moser

Your hosts are Brian McCollough - MBA, CEPA?, CMAA? , Maria L. Perez , Ruoyu Loughry . Roy Dickan , Mike Liu , William Feder , Bill Schweber , Justice Darko, PMP , Steven Shrinsky and Nelinia (Nel) Varenas, MBA

Our guest speaker is the distinguished Founder and President of The RESHORING INITIATIVE, Harry Moser. This timely and high-powered webinar will be live streaming Wednesday, March 19th, 11am PST to 12pm PST. Learn more and register for the U.S. Manufacturing Nexus Webinar Event by clicking here: https://strategicvalueplus.com/webinar-registration .

"Why Reshoring Matters for Our Economy and Our National Security" with Harry Moser, Founder and President of The Reshoring Initiative

RESHORING INITIATIVE Harry Moser Strategic Value+ Solutions #additivemanufacturing #manufacturingrenaissance #industry4 #madeintheusa #reshoring #domesticsourcing #mergers #acquisitions #exitplanning #strategicplanning